4 ms·
> In the same vein, an article[1] in The Telegraph entitled "The Hobbit: How the 'clomping foot of nerdism' destroyed Tolkien's dream - and the fantasy genre" m
by PhasmaFelis 12y ago
> In the same vein, an article[1] in The Telegraph entitled "The Hobbit: How the 'clomping foot of nerdism' destroyed Tolkien's dream - and the fantasy genre" makes a few similar points.
My first impression of that article was that anyone who, in the 21st century, still thinks that "nerd" is a cutting insult, can be safely ignored.
Brief perusal of the original article that the Telegraph references (M. John Harrison's screed against worldbuilding as "the great clomping foot of nerdism" [1]) confirms that he's basically trying to prove that a writing style he doesn't like is, therefore, logically and objectively inferior to a style he does like. I'm comfortable that my first impression was accurate.
[1] http://web.archive.org/web/20080410181840/http://uzwi.wordpress.com/2007/01/27/very-afraid/ http://web.archive.org/web/20080410181840/http://uzwi.wordpr...
- akanet 12y agoYou should expect people to try to prove what they believe! I also find the "I found X safe to ignore at Y point because of Z" to be a rather poisonous take on processing other viewpoints. I'm sure you mean well with it but you come off as looking for excuses to be dismissive.
- bitwalker 12y agoI'd agree up to a point, but if I read something where early on there is an obviously biased and/or incorrect series of statements being made, it's not much of a stretch to assume the rest of the content will share that trait. Still, it doesn't necessarily mean they won't make some decent points regardless, but it makes it all too easy to dismiss an argument when it's formed that way. I'm not sure I'd call it "looking for an excuse to be dismissive", as much as "not giving the author a chance to redeem their argument in spite of obvious weaknesses".