3 ms·
> Would the average person dare tell a nuclear engineer how he should be designing his reactor? If the average person were ocasionally or maybe even throughou
by rdtsc 12y ago
> Would the average person dare tell a nuclear engineer how he should be designing his reactor?
If the average person were ocasionally or maybe even throughout their life engaged in designing and building reactors, even just once, yes they would.
Let's say an engineer build one nuclear reactor during their lifetime. Would you give their opinion any weight in nuclear reactor design? Well you should. Especially if the reactor is still standing safely and producing electricity (or you know, loads of Plutonium) [extrapolate to -- they are gainfully employeed in a profession, not starving, or sleeping on the streets].
Unlike nuclear reactor or QM circuits building every adult is at some point engaged in learning. Both as the one being taught (child, student) and the one doing the teaching (parent, mentor, tutor).
> Does that mathematician who helped designed the Common Core standards have any experience working with a class where 97% of the students are on free lunches and their parents are in jail and addicted to cocaine? Of course not
Agreed. But then you take their datapoint as a singular data point, and with a grain of salt that they came from a family of college professors, etc etc. Instead of drug dealers.
Moreover, what the mathematician designing the Common Core should have done was to look at what are some of the components in a country with better scores and a more successful school system. I think we talked about about the school system in Finland here (or was Reddit, can't remember anymore). The key was that it wasn't just "better teacher" or "better worksheets" but a better environment. Like you said, not being afraid of going home and getting beaten by a drunk parent or worrying about not having a dinner that night. No ammount of fancy new Worksheet and "shotcuts" will help that child.