3 ms·
I think it's a dick move. It's like calling the cops because your neighbor is smoking pot in their garage. The activity isn't harming you, it only "harms" the p
by briandear 12y ago
I think it's a dick move. It's like calling the cops because your neighbor is smoking pot in their garage. The activity isn't harming you, it only "harms" the people with a relationship with the company. If it were me, I'd likely use the competitor's lack of PCI compliance as a tool for my own marketing -- I wouldn't even use the competitor's name, but do something like "Unlike many of our competitors <my_awesome_product> is fully PCI compliant because we care about your security." Turn the "weakness" of the competitor into your strength. But reporting him to the authorities? That's very Stasi-esque.
Unless a law is being broken AND it's creating an unsafe situation for your customers or your company, leave it alone. In my opinion it's a classless move to go after your competitors in that fashion. Beat them with a better product. In this case, a "better" product would seem to be one with PCI compliance.
As far as the "toxic waste" analogy -- I've never heard of anyone getting cancer and dying from a lack of PCI compliance. In fact, there are likely more important things to worry about than PCI compliance -- Target and all of the other high profile retailers that were credit-card hacked -- they were all allegedly PCI compliant, yet it still didn't do much good. I'm not hear to debate the value of PCI compliance -- if it's a requirement of your business, then obviously you have to do it. But I am debating the ethics of reporting a competitor for an activity that is NOT illegal, nor is it directly harming your customers or your business.
- chrischen 12y agoI think it's a dick move to only care about something when it affects yourself. Are you advocating that unless you're black, you shouldn't have supported (or got involved with) the black civil rights movement?
- vcarl 12y agoIt may not be harming YOUR customers, but I don't agree with the premise that you only have an ethical obligation to protect the people paying you. The competitor's bad practice vastly increases their customer's risk of having their cards stolen, not only by people who break through the "security", but also by disgruntled employees.
- icebraining 12y agoThe activity isn't harming you, it only "harms" the people with a relationship with the company Actually, no. If the CC numbers are used fraudulently, the clients of that company will just issue chargebacks; at most, they'll need to get new cards. The people who'll have to pay are the merchants who will get hit with those chargebacks - and indirectly everyone else, since prices are raised to pay for those losses.
- tzs 12y ago> Target and all of the other high profile retailers that were credit-card hacked -- they were all allegedly PCI compliant, yet it still didn't do much good. How do you conclude that it didn't do much good? The Target breach involved installing malware on the point-of-sale terminals to grab the data as the customer was paying. As far as I know, the attackers didn't get to the stored credit card data. I suspect that they didn't get to that data in large part because Target was mostly in PCI compliance, meaning that the stored data was encrypted, on database servers isolated from the databases not involved in payment processing, on separate networks with strong access restrictions. If Target had been treating PCI the way OP's competitor is, the Target breach could have been much much much worse. > But I am debating the ethics of reporting a competitor for an activity that is NOT illegal, nor is it directly harming your customers or your business. For a small business that is doing its own credit card storage, PCI compliance costs can be significant. They can easily double or triple the number of boxes you need at the data center. The competitor is saving a lot of money by completely ignoring credit card security, which gives him an unfair advantage over OP. I'd consider that sufficient harm to OP to justify taking action.
- jacquesm 12y agoYour underlying assumption is that they are doing this to save costs or that there is malice involved. I see no evidence of that, merely either incompetence or a company struggling to get with the times or built at a time when this stuff wasn't so much on the radar as it is today. That happens a lot and there are ways to deal with it, ratting out your competitors to authorities with silent hopes of crippling them and taking their business in the name of protecting the consumer is bad form at best and will come back to bite you hard at worst.
- mst 12y agoI concur. I once wrote code (happily long since retired) that stored credit card numbers unencrypted. It wasn't about cost cutting. It was about me being young and foolish (and, looking back, I'm not sure it's even the stupidest mistake I've deployed to production in my career, but I'm not sure I want to admit to the other candidates just now :).
- philwelch 12y agoWhile PCI compliance might not be as important as dumping toxic waste, it's sure as hell more important than whether you smoke pot in your garage.
- pc86 12y ago> The activity isn't harming you, it only "harms" the people with a relationship with the company. This is not true. As a vendor, I assume costs associated with PCI compliance and other industry-standard best practices. If my competitor is ignoring these I am fundamentally disadvantaged. It's not an equal marketplace at that point. Whether intentional on the competitor's part or not, this is saving them money and placing their customers at risk of identity theft, financial fraud and who knows what else depending on what's stored in that database. > But reporting him to the authorities? That's very Stasi-esque. Holy hyperbole, Batman. As a customer, I deserve to know if my vendor is eschewing industry-standard security practices. And they should be mercilessly shamed if they are.