4 ms·
not keeping a general ledger at all To be fair, you don't need a general ledger if you are setting up a website to trade playing cards. Say an Online eXchange
by gaius 12y ago
not keeping a general ledger at all
To be fair, you don't need a general ledger if you are setting up a website to trade playing cards. Say an Online eXchange for Magic the Gathering.
Every time an Mt Gox story comes up, the most incredulous thing to me is, why was anyone even expecting these guys to act like a bank? Why did anyone even consider trusting them with actual money?
- s_kilk 12y agoBecause bitcoiners were willing to believe anything which fit their narrative, logic and diligence be damned.
- gaius 12y agoLOL Bitcoin fanboys have shown up on this thread I see judging by our down votes...
- hawkice 12y agoYou'd probably still want a ledger there, if you're trading physical goods. That way you can correlate confirmed receipts on both ends of whatever cards were traded.
- hga 12y agoNo probably. Presumably you're doing this for a cut of the action, so that's income on one side, then there's your out of pocket costs to run the system etc. Knowing how these two compare can tell you all sorts of things, including how much you can safely take out for yourself if things are going well enough, vs. knowing you'll have to pay next month's co-lo fees out of your pocket. Now, of course, at that level something as formal as a general ledger isn't quite required, but you still need to do the same things in e.g. watching the organization's bank balance.
- hawkice 12y agoI am admittedly a bit of an accounting fanboy, and may jump to more rigorous tracking of things I control or are accountable for than is needed. For instance, upon discovering a large portion of the intelligence funding in the United States is "off-budget", I was concerned about their financial rigor (your budget should include all the things you spend money on -- it's odd to think the US Government is quite a few steps and security clearances away from being able to answer "How much do you spend on pens a year?")
- dragonwriter 12y agoIt wasn't an online exchange for MtG cards, it was an exchange for MtG:Online cards (digital collectibles), and, IIRC, other than buying the name, the bitcoin exchange didn't have much in common with it.
- krapp 12y agoMt. Gox was popular. In an environment without some sort of central accrediting authority or standards body for Bitcoin businesses (the very idea would be abhorrent), popularity confers legitimacy, and convenience confers popularity. I also suspect there were also more than a few people who trusted it implicitly because it wasn't a bank, they just assumed it worked because Bitcoin. When you begin from the premise that the models followed by the financial world are at best obsolete and at worst a criminal facade, of course you might not bother referring to them if you start a business, or care to find out if an exchange follows the best practices of an industry you consider corrupt and useless. I'm not saying this describes all bitcoin holders or Mt. Gox customers by any means, but the politics around Bitcoin do seem to lend themselves to an unwillingness to hold third parties up to any sort of standard.