4 ms·
Extraordinary story. What I always found strange was how super rich corporations like Shell will skimp in making purchases of the required safety mechanisms, tr
by pm90 12y ago
Extraordinary story. What I always found strange was how super rich corporations like Shell will skimp in making purchases of the required safety mechanisms, try to avoid taxes etc. and will ultimately end up with disasters such as this one, which could have been avoided if the tug had been stronger or better equipped, and the shackles had been new and strong.
- jws 12y agoThe shackle gets a lot of ink in the media, and it did fail. The questions about who inspected it and how seem a bit misplaced given that it was rated at 120 tons and the tow line alarm registered over 300 tons more than 30 times, so missing provenance or not, it seems like the shackle was performed beyond its design limits and beyond what the engineers required. They were just wrong. The towline itself was only rated to 85 tons, the towline manufacturer did well.
- radiowave 12y agoTypically, shackles of this sort have a safety factor of 5, meaning that if the maximum working load is 120 tons, the minimum breaking load should be >= 600 tons. Strictly, once the maximum working load has been exceeded, the shackle should be considered compromised. I don't have experience with any shackle on that scale, but my feeling is that you ought to be able to expect a good shackle to withstand 30 pulls to half of its minimum breaking load.
- mccr8 12y agoIt seems like a kind of tragedy of the commons. There are many people involved, and each one can reap some personal reward by cutting corners just a little bit ("I should get a raise because I saved the company X dollars in Q3 by reusing existing assets!"), but if enough people do that, and you get a little bit of bad luck, then you get a failure cascade that threatens far more money than anybody saved.
- nl 12y agoIsn't that almost exactly the wrong conclusion here? They built a brand new tug, more than twice as powerful as the most powerful existing one in Alaska. They paid for the work to be checked, and then arguably a subcontractor used out of spec parts They used a route that was less safe for they rig because it was safer for the workers. No fan of oil companies, but I'm not sure this story supports your conclusions.