7 ms·
The problem with Common Core is that it phrases questions like yours using weird words and focuses on specific procedures instead of the correct answer (or a ra
by bane 12y ago
The problem with Common Core is that it phrases questions like yours using weird words and focuses on specific procedures instead of the correct answer (or a range or reasonable answers).
So depending on some factors, your question might be answerable with either "about $5" "about $5.50" "$5" "$5.50" or "$5.55".
Which one is the one that will get the child a correct mark? No idea. But you can see any number of angry parents posting pictures of they're children's homework grades where "$5.55" is marked wrong even though it's the most correct.
Some people will argue that "well the subject was about estimation", well that still leaves the child with 4 possible correct answers, but school being school, only one of them will be counted as "correct" and anything else will be marked wrong.
It turns what's normally an error bounded estimation problem with degrees of accuracy into a binary right/wrong problem that looks exactly like arithmetic and is graded like arithmetic, but unless you have the curriculum guide with the answers in it, it's a crap shoot to figure out what the expected "correct" answer is.
- kaitai 12y agoCommon Core doesn't phrase the questions in weird ways. The standards are clear and don't tell you how to teach. Much of the training around it and essentially all of the curriculum (repackaged old stuff, new section headings on the same crap) is terrible. But that's the corporatization of education and the poor support for professional development of US teachers at work, which we allow to happen regardless of curriculum content. http://www.corestandards.org/Math/ http://www.corestandards.org/Math/
- bane 12y agoHere, you figure out what question #1 is supposed to be about http://roundtheinkwell.files.wordpress.com/2013/10/the-math-test.pdf http://roundtheinkwell.files.wordpress.com/2013/10/the-math-... What the hell is a "number sentence"? What about #12? "What's the related subtraction sentence?" followed by four answers which all use addition. What the hell is a "counter"? Should first graders also learn about incrementers and changing bases, carry bits and overflow flags? "Write a subtraction story..." What? Based on #12 it must be something about addition since subtraction sentences all use addition. These are barely comprehensible to college educated people with multiple degrees. People who are used to math, critical thinking, who speak multiple languages and solve incredibly complex problems in their day-to-day. I've run this by nuclear engineers with multiple PhDs who couldn't pass this test. It's absurd gibberish to a 6 year old. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2013/10/31/a-ridiculous-common-core-test-for-first-graders/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2013/10/...
- parfe 12y agoNumber sentence is an equation explained using words a six year old understands. Children use counters all the time. Ever played air hockey? I'm not sure how that would be confusing. A number story is a word problem.
- bane 12y agoNobody uses these terms to describe these things. The fact that you described the crazy way CC calls things with more familiar terms is specific evidence of that. Air hockey doesn't use "counters" it uses a scoreboard or score keeper. Number sentence is not what these are called. We're teaching children the wrong things. Now they have to learn the concept twice. Once wrongly, the second time correctly. It's objectively the wrong way to teach.
- codyb 12y agoWell vernaculars differ and a counter is a totally intuitive way to describe the air hockey score keeper. I'd be hard pressed to call it a score board especially since the keepers are on opposite sides of the table generally. But I'm totally with you about teaching children that these are equations. I wouldn't be surprised if this curriculum or whatever was built by someone not comfortable with the word equation themselves, for whatever reason.
- sukilot 12y agoParent is thinking about an electronic scoreboard. Parent's problem problem is that they assume anything different from their idiolect is stupid and wrong.
- Retra 12y ago>It's objectively the wrong way to teach. Is it? I'm fairly certain that teaching is one of the most difficult things that we try to do, and that almost everything I've ever learned has be taught 'the wrong way' and then corrected later. But then, I have a degree in physics, and everything I've been taught about physics has either been wrong or is open to being made wrong. I was explicitly told as a freshmen "nothing we'll teach you in this class is true." It doesn't matter what those are called. All that matters is how they work.
- parfe 12y agoWhile I don't doubt some teacher at some school somewhere on america may have done something ill conceived, do you have a source? A quick Google found some common core work on estimation which was multiple choice, clearly geared towards understanding magnitude. Teachers don't sit around all day thinking up ways to trick students and anger their parents.
- spdustin 12y agoThose weird words and procedures are taught to the students. My kids understand them just fine. It's the parents who aren't in the classroom getting the instruction that goes along with the homework that are complaining. I simply ask my kids, on those occasions where I can't suss it out on my own, what concept the teacher was teaching them about. I don't expect a perfect answer to that question - their teachers are instructing learners and not teachers after all - but the responses to my question usually give me enough context to recognize that they are just a new vernacular for the way my mind does math anyway.