4 ms·
My children's school sent me a questionnaire on Common Core. They ended with a comment, maximum of 300 characters. Here is what I told them: Educational refo
by btilly 12y ago
My children's school sent me a questionnaire on Common Core. They ended with a comment, maximum of 300 characters. Here is what I told them:
Educational reforms usually result in an ambitious curriculum being presented by underprepared teachers to unprepared students. And parents don't understand the homework and can't help.
For example, "New Math" ended with "Johnny Can't Add". I wish my kids weren't victims of the current round.
I stand by that comment. Given how many failed reforms there have been over time, how could these smart people not have predicted what has happened?
Right now we have a new set of standards. A new set of lesson plans. Every teacher has been retrained to teach in a new way. We have new homework going home with kids, which makes little sense to anyone. Kids learn to perform the operations, but do not seem to be mastering the concepts. There is an endless drum beat of positive messaging being sent home from schools. Parents that I talk to are..shall we say..less than convinced.
This is about the worst kind of big bang upgrade that you could have.
- debacle 12y agoDoes it help that I haven't talked to a single teacher who has been bullish on the Common Core? Many of them feel that it breaks the K-8 curriculum up in such a way that it front-loads the wrong things. Almost all of them have been derisive of what they have seen as a "cash grab" for Common Core textbooks that are riddled with errors and also somewhat awful. Many also lament that it restricts their ability to expand on aspects of the curriculum, effectively lowering their autonomy. As a programmer, I have never seen a "one size fits all" system that can both bring up bad programmers and also provide good programmers with the autonomy they need to continue to be good programmers. Common Core is a "one size fits all" system to a much more complex problem.
- barry-cotter 12y ago>Almost all of them have been derisive of what they have seen as a "cash grab" for Common Core textbooks that are riddled with errors and also somewhat awful. This would be more convincing if there were some examples of good textbooks that were scrapped, or good textbooks period. The textbook procurement process in the US has been appalling for longer than most readers of this forum have been alive.[ http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm ] Never mind that the best evidence available suggests that unsccooling, i.e. providing no systematic instruction to children whatsoever leads to a delay of one year in educational outcomes. Primary school hardly seems worth it unless the point is not education but teaching children to sit down, shut up and do as they're told. [ http://www.researchgate.net/publication/232544669_The_impact_of_schooling_on_academic_achievement_Evidence_from_homeschooled_and_traditionally_schooled_students=16 http://www.researchgate.net/publication/232544669_The_impact... ]
- nemo 12y agoHonestly if we had kept "New Math" we'd have had made life simpler for the coming generations of programmers/computer scientists. The main changes were introducing boolean algebra, matrices, other tools at a younger age, and even touched on octal and binary. It also did reduce the emphasis on arithmetic to spend time on other areas of math. This completely freaked out parents who had no understanding of the math that the kids were learning, but a lot of the response was reactionary anger at strange seeming ideas, and general anger centered on the notion that kids should only learn arithmetic by rote learning as the rest of math is pointless like the "Johnny Can't Add" book. I have little to say about Common Core, since I haven't been following it, though I am seeing a lot of the same knee-jerk reactionary criticisms that are grounded in a sense of traditionalism and desire to focus on rote learning rather than any understanding of math, which we should be careful about.
- Retra 12y ago>Kids learn to perform the operations, but do not seem to be mastering the concepts. This was already the problem. Parents didn't learn anything either, they just learned to perform the operations. If they _had_ learned the concepts, they would have no trouble understanding their kids' new homework.
- btilly 12y agoIf they _had_ learned the concepts, they would have no trouble understanding their kids' new homework. Not so. I understand the concepts perfectly well. The problem that I have is that there are multiple ways that I can map my understanding of the problem to the needlessly overcomplicated homework question in front of me. And if I can't figure out which of those ways matches what my child was taught, I can't tell my child which pointless and silly way of answering it is the "right" one. You can object that this is opposite to the intent of the Common Core initiative. But it doesn't change the fact that this is the implementation of the Common Core initiative that my children actually have to deal with.
- 21echoes 12y ago> Kids learn to perform the operations, but do not seem to be mastering the concepts This is explicitly what Common Core is designed to fix -- Common Core is designed to break K-12 math's traditional focus on rote arithmetic and instead focus on learning math as abstract reasoning and multiple different solution strategies. That you would include this barb in your comment shows that you're more arguing against the concept of changing standards, and not against Common Core itself. That's not an indefensible position, and you do consistently argue from that stance throughout your comment, but I fail to see how it's constructive. The US is ranked ~30th in math worldwide -- obviously things need to be changed. Perhaps there are better ways to change our standards: what would you propose?
- btilly 12y agoCommon Core is designed to break K-12 math's traditional focus on rote arithmetic and instead focus on learning math as abstract reasoning and multiple different solution strategies. The fact that it is designed to do so does not mean that it succeeds in any way. What I see is the replacement of rote arithmetic with the rote repetition of formulaic statements that are not connected to actual understanding. This is not an improvement. That you would include this barb in your comment shows that you're more arguing against the concept of changing standards, and not against Common Core itself. That's not an indefensible position, and you do consistently argue from that stance throughout your comment, but I fail to see how it's constructive. The US is ranked ~30th in math worldwide -- obviously things need to be changed. Perhaps there are better ways to change our standards: what would you propose? I would suggest incremental improvement, not revolutionary change. The education establishment has a long history of revolutionary change, and knows exactly how to go about it. This always turns out badly. The much safer way to go is to incrementally improve, with constant feedback and repetition. It doesn't feel day by day like progress, but it has much higher odds of actually succeeding. What our educational system has done is the equivalent of throwing out a major software system, and rolling out a new one. Such big bang upgrades seldom go well, and the larger the system the worse the disaster that follows. Even if you can wind up in a situation where success can be declared, huge amounts of damage are done.