3 ms·
Can someone with knowledge or experience on the subject explain how the "2+1"[0] road is better than a standard 3-lane highway? [0] FTA "Building 1,500 kilomet
by pc86 12y ago
Can someone with knowledge or experience on the subject explain how the "2+1"[0] road is better than a standard 3-lane highway?
[0] FTA "Building 1,500 kilometres (900 miles) of "2+1" roads—where each lane of traffic takes turns to use a middle lane for overtaking—is reckoned to have saved around 145 lives over the first decade of Vision Zero"
- rdl 12y agoI think it is an improvement vs existing 2 lane roads. It wouldn't have cost anything to convert a 3 lane roads to 2+1.
- Svip 12y agoI don't know what a 'standard 3-lane highway' is. But a 2+1 highway means one lane in each direction, as well as a middle lane that changes direction at certain points. The advantage of these is that rather than forcing drivers to overtake into opposing traffic, they can wait until their direction gets the overtaking lane. These sort of roads are very common in Denmark. And I've seen a few of them in Germany as well. (This is not to be confused with 2+1 highways where the middle lane change direction depending on the time of day, these have been phased out. There are usually clear markings on 2+1 highways when the direction change.)
- DanBC 12y agoA three lane highway is similar to a UK motorway. A road has six lanes, three (plus an emergency "hard shoulder") for each direction seperated by a central crash barrier.
- pc86 12y agoYes that is what I meant, thank you for clarifying. My US-centric viewpoint came through more than I expected!
- johnbatch 12y agoThe Wikipeda article is quite good. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2%2B1_road#Sweden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2%2B1_road#Sweden all the 2+1 roads in Sweden have barriers.
- to3m 12y agoA 3-lane highway is like 3 lanes in each direction though, isn't it? A 2+1 road has 3 lanes in total, and no central reservation (or just a fence), so it's less than half as wide.
- codfrantic 12y agoI'll try, imagine a road like this: http://lh6.ggpht.com/_gt_enTZIj1g/TMq0zFITxUI/AAAAAAAADo8/Rb7HaW7Yb6Q/s912/IMG_1388.jpg http://lh6.ggpht.com/_gt_enTZIj1g/TMq0zFITxUI/AAAAAAAADo8/Rb... (not sweden but Netherlands but it works for the example.) Overtaking is not allowed (except for farm traffic), in a 2+1 situation there would be three lanes all the time, alternating between directions. This means that there will always be a legal spot to overtake within a few minutes. (usually the climbing direction would be two lanes so you can overtake slow trucks e.d.) Therefore you don't have to overtake a slow driver by using the oncoming lane. By a 'standard 3-lane highway', I assume you mean three lanes each way, these roads have nowhere near enough traffic on them to explain all that extra tarmac.
- pc86 12y agoYes that is what I meant, the main highway I drive to work on is 3 lanes each direction. Bumper to bumper < 40 MPH (65 KPH) in rush hour, sporadic traffic going 75-85+ MPH (135+ KPH) at other times. We have a few of these roads in my area but not very many, and you can easily go many many miles on a road similar to the one in your picture with no passing lane.