2 ms·
The two obvious "ugh" factors here are 1. it's reliant on a "sufficiently complex" user password, and 2. it's reliant on DNS, and only recommends everyone in th
by peterwwillis 12y ago
The two obvious "ugh" factors here are 1. it's reliant on a "sufficiently complex" user password, and 2. it's reliant on DNS, and only recommends everyone in the DAME system use DNSSEC. For both these reasons, nobody should depend on this system to transmit classified information.
In general, mail has always been a highly centralized distributed system. You would think someone on the darknet would want to decentralize this a bit more, and you know, make it harder to attack than GMail. (This is technically easier to attack than GMail itself) I don't understand why people today don't implement one-time pads into their cryptosystems. It's true that it's probably the most problematic to implement, but it's also the most secure (theoretically).
Let's be frank here: the NSA does not really give a crap about your data, and will probably never look at it, because your data is mainly pictures of cats. But on the off-chance that you are communicating with someone who might be a threat to national security, don't trust the safety of your transmission to protocols that can be breached, 3rd parties who can be issued NSLs, and systems you don't administer. A properly implemented one-time pad between each communicant will stymy even the biggest black ops budget, to the point where your primary concern will be your physical safety and not your password strength.
- rwallace 12y agoOne-time pads only work if you already have a secure way to transmit the pads, and if you have that, you could probably use it to transmit your actual data.
- peterwwillis 12y agoYou only have to transmit the pads securely once, if you send enough of it. The rest of the time you can transmit non-expensively. That's the whole point. It's the tradeoff of one extra-expensive secured communication once so you can transmit anytime, anywhere afterwards securely. If you really care about nation states grabbing your data, this is a much more reliable system than what is proposed herein. (Though really, just a two-factor auth system would be more secure than what is proposed)