3 ms·
I'm finding the 2x difference in efficiency hard to understand. Gasoline cars get worse mileage in mountains, obviously, but it's nowhere near 2x. Is there some
by baddox 12y ago
I'm finding the 2x difference in efficiency hard to understand. Gasoline cars get worse mileage in mountains, obviously, but it's nowhere near 2x. Is there some particular difference that would make the Tesla penalty so much worse? Perhaps the Tahoe area is also very cold, and Tesla's interior heating is a major battery killer?
- userbinator 12y agoOn level ground, the majority of the energy goes into overcoming wind and drivetrain resistance, whereas going uphill requires a lot more energy just to "lift" the car (i.e. increasing its gravitational potential energy.) Since the Tesla is more efficient than a regular car on level ground, it makes sense that the difference between that and slopes will be higher too. On a regular car the efficiency is already low enough that the difference between hill-climbing and level ground operation is reduced. The 500Wh/mi difference is essentially the energy needed to lift the car. Consider another hypothetical car, much less efficient, that took 2000Wh/mi on level ground; then it might take 2500Wh/mi going uphill, which is only 25% more. Note that the Tesla will also recharge its batteries going downhill with regenerative braking, so it mostly balances out - as long as you don't completely flatten the battery going up.
- baddox 12y agoPerhaps I'm not following, but doesn't that explanation imply that a Tesla's efficiency increase over the average car comes overwhelmingly from reductions in wind and drivetrain resistance? For the numbers to come out this way, that efficiency increase would have to be vastly larger than I would have guessed. I would have guessed that most of the loss of efficiency (as in the fuel's heat of combustion divided by the displacement of the car's weight) of a gas car was heat loss from the internal combustion engine. But I know very little about cars.
- CHY872 12y agoThere are other things. For example: Teslas improve general efficiency considerably by (for example) using regenerative braking, which will be utilised in normal driving but not if you're travelling up a big hill on a freeway. Furthermore, they're particularly heavy cars - a Ford Fusion (similar sized saloon) is about 1500kg, whilst the Tesla is 2100kg, presumably because of the batteries - the extra effort to lift up a hill is linear in the weight, so it'll be at least a 25% drop in the surplus cost over normal driving. Overall, it's not really an efficiency thing because the costs of fuels vary so much. For pure heat-to-wheel efficiency, the most important one is that since Teslas are about 80% efficient at turning power into motion, and charge efficiency is about 97%, and a combined cycle power station is about 55% efficient at converting heat energy into power, then the total efficiency from heat to wheel is about 43%, whilst a modern petrol car might be expected to see more like 30%.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoI don't know about the Tahoe area, but I get a lot less gas mileage when driving the hills of Los Angeles. It's not just the inclines, but even the flat-ish roads are very curvy, which involves a lot of braking and then acceleration.