3 ms·
All cars use more energy to climb hills. If you'd like to factor that into your Tesla planning, check out https://evtripplanner.com/ https://evtripplanner.com/
by greglindahl 12y ago
All cars use more energy to climb hills. If you'd like to factor that into your Tesla planning, check out https://evtripplanner.com/ https://evtripplanner.com/ -- It shows the Vacaville/Truckee segment as taking 173 rated miles to cover 130 actual miles.
- rconti 12y agoIt's worth noting also that he's not talking about "driving in hilly terrain", the original comment is talking about driving almost exclusively uphill. Going to Tahoe you'd go from somewhere around 0ft to around 8500ft depending on the pass, and then down only to 6200ft. Of course, this will impact all cars, though I find only a few MPG difference in our vehicles driving up to the ski resorts around Tahoe. One curious thing I've noticed is that my relatively-high-Torque-and-HP car with a manual transmission gets almost the same mileage on flat ground versus going up and down mountain ranges, assuming there's no net elevation gain. My girlfriend's fairly underpowered Subaru with a 4 speed automatic does significantly worse in the hills than it does on flat ground. Also interestingly, the Tesla should get significantly better mileage in thinner air (on flat ground) where a gas-engined car has to deal with less air to burn which balances out the lower wind resistance. Would also be interesting to see how the elevation change would affect a tesla at net 0. Say, drive from Sacramento to Truckee and back; I think the range should be plenty.
- greglindahl 12y agoThe website I referenced can do that computation for you. It's been accurate +/- 5 mi per supercharger segment for me. It estimates 216 rated miles to drive 201 actual miles, from Sacramento to Truckee to Sacramento.
- repiret 12y ago> a gas-engined car has to deal with less air to burn which balances out the lower wind resistance. Thats only true if you have an old carbureted car that requires turning a screw under the hood to adjust the air-fuel mixture. Modern cars measure the amount of O2 in the exhaust and adjust the mixture to keep the moles-of-O2 to moles-of-gasoline ratio roughly fixed. The thinner air means you have to open the throttle wider to achieve the same manifold pressure, which in turn means that with the throttle wide-open, the engine will produce less power. But the thinner air should have no effect on the amount of gas you need to burn to achieve a particular amount of power.
- throwketchup 12y agoIf anything, you'd expect lower fuel consumption for a given amount of power due to the reduced pumping losses.
- baddox 12y agoI'm pretty sure most cars don't get less than half the fuel economy in mountains than on flat roads, which is what the commenter claimed.
- greglindahl 12y agoMost cars have a much lower MPGe than the Model S, so it's hard to directly compare the change in effort needed for steep uphills. Both Model S and "most cars" have to obey the same physics in order to lift the car to the top of the hill. [Edit: you can think about it this way: A 89 MPGe Tesla Model S going up a steep hill at only 44 MPGe is still twice as efficient as a 20 MPG SUV driving on the flat.]