6 ms·
Over 80 Percent of Dark-Web Visits Relate to Pedophilia, Study Finds
- im3w1l 12y ago>Whistleblower sites like SecureDrop and Globaleaks, which allow anonymous users to upload sensitive documents to news organizations, accounted for 5 percent of Tor hidden service sites, but less than a tenth of a percent of site visits. The impact is not proportional to number of visits. One whistleblower has a larger positve effect than one pedo looking at child porn has a negative effect. I wonder if an 800:1 ratio can be justified though.
- ethomson 12y agoReally? That's a stunning claim. You're comfortable making this judgement call that whisteblowers are more positive than child rape is negative?
- sirsar 12y agoThere is a difference between viewing and creating pedophilic pornography. Certainly, demand drives creation, but one pageview is not one child raped. One whistleblower pageview is much more likely to be one whistle blown, which can have impact ranging from nothing to an arbitrary number of lives saved.
- chris_wot 12y agoWow. Just wow. You guys are seriously comparing the impact of whistleblowers to the impact of child rape?
- aaronem 12y agoWelcome to Hacker News!
- ethomson 12y agoI'm sympathetic to your suggestion that a whistle blow may have far reaching consequences. But as you suggest, it may not. It may have no impact at all. It may be wholly inconsequential. It may be a misunderstanding, a hoax. Meanwhile, a child was abused to make kiddy porn. No equivocation there. To suggest that the aforementioned whistleblower is always more positive than the kiddy porn is negative is shocking. To then try put a ratio on it seems particularly callous.
- paperplane 12y ago> Meanwhile, a child was abused to make kiddy porn. Drawn pictures (e.g. manga) are absolutely considered child porn in large parts of the world (e.g. the UK).
- sliverstorm 12y agoThe 1:1 comparison is, as your parent points out, ultimatly irrelevant because the reality is not 1:1. So I'm not worried about the 1:1 comparison.
- linksbro 12y agoHere's the torproject's response to this article. I think they bring up valid points about not drawing decisive conclusions based on this study. "Tor hidden service traffic, which Dr. Gareth Owen discussed in his talk this afternooon, is only 1.5% of all Tor traffic. Tor gets about 2 million users per day total. The researcher ran a set of Tor relays for a six month period, and recorded how many times somebody attempted to look up a hidden service (this lookup is one of the steps in visiting a hidden service). Then at the end of that period, he scanned the hidden services he'd learned about, to find out what sort of content was on them. Dr. Owen's data shows that there's a lot of churn in hidden services, so nearly all of the sites were gone by the time he did these scans. His graphs only show data about the sites that were still up many months later: so his data could either show a lot of people visiting abuse-related hidden services, or it could simply show that abuse-related hidden services are more long-lived than others. We can't tell from the data. Without knowing how many sites disappeared before he got around to looking at them, it's impossible to know what percentage of fetches went to abuse sites. There are important uses for hidden services, such as when human rights activists use them to access Facebook or to blog anonymously. These uses for hidden services are new and have great potential. PS: Law enforcement agencies use Tor to stay anonymous while they catch bad guys. Law enforcement agencies use and run hidden services, too." https://blog.torproject.org/blog/tor-80-percent-percent-1-2-percent-abusive https://blog.torproject.org/blog/tor-80-percent-percent-1-2-...
- belorn 12y agoI agree with promoting caution when drawing conclusions on that data. We don't know how much of that data is generated by people, by bots, or what purpose they had. For example, I would assume that any national agency whose job it is identify and catch child abuse would run web scrapers at pedophilia sites. Wasn't there a article a while back that said around 95% of all internet traffic was imitated by computers and not humans? What would the percentage be for hidden services?
- sp332 12y agoI don't see any slides posted, but video of the talk will be here eventually (probably by tomorrow) under the title "Tor: Hidden Services and Deanonymisation" http://media.ccc.de/browse/congress/2014 http://media.ccc.de/browse/congress/2014
- _wmd 12y agoTheir streaming site seems to be having reliability issues, but seems it's still there. You can watch the raw recording at http://streaming.media.ccc.de/relive/6112/ http://streaming.media.ccc.de/relive/6112/ already
- minimax 12y agoThe good news is that law enforcement agencies aren't completely helpless in these cases and are actively developing technology (a la Torpedo†) to infiltrate these sites and prosecute their users. † http://www.wired.com/2014/08/operation_torpedo/ http://www.wired.com/2014/08/operation_torpedo/
- jcromartie 12y agoThis is good news?
- modarts 12y agoIt absolutely is. I'd be interested to hear a counterargument though.
- TillE 12y agoA system that is not secure for bad people is not secure for anyone. Tor is pretty good though, and few attacks relate to its core functionality.
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoThey used an iframe for the payload that could be easily placed on legitimate sites by third parties to put innocent people on FBI's pedophile list.
- jcromartie 12y agoYou will just have to take the FBI at their word that it's for your own good, then. It's not clear from that Wired article that they stopped anybody who actually abused children. What they have obviously accomplished, however, is a way to decloak at least some users of Tor and probably dissuaded many more people from using it for secure anonymous communication.
- rubiquity 12y agoBad news for Tor, good news for humanity, excluding the parts of humanity that are privy on privacy.
- Issac 12y agoWow thats truly a bit shocking , I dont think its surprising that visits to Whistleblower sites are less than 1% , if it was more we would live in an other world. About the high percent of visits to those abuse-related hidden services , which is a horrible fact , is mostly related to the kind of service provided ... whistleblower sites are veeery special in a way and not that many people even have any motivation to use them . All of those illegal markets get far more visits naturally but those who use them as buyers(which must be the main group of visiters )maybe only check them out like once a week ( maybe like most of us use amazon maybe even a bit less). But now think of youtube or sex related video Sites ... they naturally get more visits from 1 user in a week than any other service ... so i think thats a huge chunk of it. So just to get this right , i really think its disgusting and shocking how much visits these sites seem to generate, but i think its not necessary related that most user in the dark Web use these services , but maybe just more like those who use them are using them much more exessive than any other service. Also we have to mind the factors mentioned in the article like DOS attacks etc...
- jrochkind1 12y agoCan we kill the phrase "dark web" somehow? It seems to be used to mean at least 4 different things, some of them vague and unspecified.
- chobo 12y agoTo kill "dark web" we need a good alternative. I'm all ears!
- jrochkind1 12y agoWell, I suppose it depends on what you're talking about. If you're talking about Tor hidden services, "Tor hidden services" seems like a pretty good alternative. Yes, non-technical people don't know what this means, but they can learn. Non-technical people don't know what the "dark web" means either, but it sure sounds mysterious, and has the added danger that they often erroneously think they do, but have no idea what they're talking about.
- function_seven 12y agoThe only thing I've personally heard it refer to is Tor, Freenet, etc. What else has it been used for?
- canjobear 12y agoContent unreachable from search engines. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Internet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Internet
- jrochkind1 12y agoThat wikipedia article is actually terrible, and so a great example of the confusion. > refers to any or all network hosts on the Internet that no-one can reach.[1] According to some estimates, only 0.03% of the web is searchable, hence leaving almost 100.00% of all data being dark Internet Apparently the wikipedia authors think that "network hosts that no-one can reach" is the same thing as "not searchable". I mean, a network host that no-one can reach is obviously not searchable (if really no-one can reach it, is it a 'network host' at all?), but a lot more is too, and of course it depends on what mechanisms you are using to search. Those estimates that "only 0.3% of the web is searchable" are surely not saying that 99.7% of the internet is "network hosts no-one can reach". The wikipedia article goes on: > Failures within the allocation of Internet resources due to the Internet's chaotic tendencies of growth and decay are a leading cause of dark address formation. One form of dark address is military sites on the archaic MILNET. These government networks are sometimes as old as the original ARPANET, and have simply not been incorporated into the Internet's evolving architecture. I am not sure what they are talking about, and introduce a new term without explaining what it means, "dark address", what? If they really don't have routable IP addresses, are they part of 'the internet' at all, let alone 99.7% of the internet? Hosts 'not incorporated into the internets evolving architecture' seems to be yet another thing again, although perhaps it's a subset of "network hosts that no-one can reach", but is an entirely different thing from Tor hidden services, and probably not a part of "websites not searchable [by Google?]" because they probably aren't "websites" at all, and arguably aren't on "the internet" at all if they were "not incorporated into the Internet's evolving architecture", whatever that means. Really, the entire wikipedia article makes almost no sense from a technical perspective. My non-technical friends hear various things about the 'dark net', and conflating different vague definitions, tell me they heard that the vast majority of the internet (nearly 100% according to wikipedia!) actually consists of pedophilia that you need special technical measures to access, or something like that. Um.
- tomelders 12y agoIt's an uncomfortable truth that Tor is enabling people to engage is activities that are the result and cause of human suffering, and it's something that doesn't sit well with me. That's said, Tor is a noble project with a noble cause and these side effects aren't unique to Tor. Anything that gives people true anonymity is going to result in people using it to do things most people would find disturbing. There's a parallel here with the "guns don't kill people" sentiment that's often brought up when people call for stricter gun controls. And here I fnd myself exhibiting some cognitive dissonance; I could say "Tor doesn't exploit and abuse children, people do" and I believe that, but I also believe that guns are inherently bad and I would like to see stricter controls. I'm not sure there's a solution to this moral puzzle and I find myself actively choosing hippocracy. I'll keep on advocating stricter gun laws whilst vehemently opposing stricter controls on the freedom of information. So if anyone has a logical or philosophical solution to this mini moral crisis of mine, I'd really love to hear it.
- jqm 12y agoThat same argument could be made against the internet in general. My philosophical solution is never to blame tools.
- jmgrosen 12y agoI, too, find this hypocrisy within myself. I find myself supporting groups such as EFF (which I believe should be supported) who take on quite radical positions, if not as radical as the NRA's. I'd like a solution to this problem as well, but one probably does not exist. Perhaps hypocrisy is a fundamental part of humanity...
- drewrv 12y agoTor is designed and engineered to allow anonymity. Handguns and semi-automatics are designed and engineered to kill humans. If the creators intent matters, then there is a moral difference between the two.
- tdees40 12y agoWell yes, and I'm no gun-rights advocate (quite the opposite), but approximately 0% of guns (in the US at least) are actually used to kill people, and this is telling me that 80% of dark web activity is used for pedophilia. That seems like a very big deal.
- sildur 12y agoThe other 20 percent are probably 404 errors.
- pdeuchler 12y agoAs ~linksbro points out, hidden sites have a huge amount of churn. In fact, back in the days when I used to frequent the darker side of things most hacking forums would change addresses monthly/weekly/sometimes daily. A lot of various hidden sites are ad hoc communication platforms, put up and taken down as needed. And yet, even still, there is a large amount that are incredibly well hidden and require several jumps/prior knowledge to get to (i.e. not just hitting a certain url). Ignoring all hits that went to sites dead after six months (an eternity for hidden services) is akin to the weight loss studies that throw out the data points representing people that dropped out when they didn't lose weight. Almost blatantly dishonest and shows a pretty superficial understanding of that which they are trying to study. Beyond that there are still so many statistical fallacies and logical leaps going on in this article it's pretty astounding... for instance the author editorializes that: >>> What they may instead show is that Tor users who seek child abuse materials use Tor much more often and visit sites much more frequently than those seeking to buy drugs or leak sensitive documents to a journalist. Completely ignoring the possibility that these pedophilic sites are comprised of images, which could artificially increase the amount of requests (i.e. one person looking at 10 images = 10 unique hits in the study). I could go on and on here, but I think this money quote from the study principal sheds some light upon the true objectives at play: >>> “Before we did this study, it was certainly my view that the dark net is a good thing,” says Owen. “But it’s hampering the rights of children and creating a place where pedophiles can act with impunity.” Edit: In my mind, the real takeaway from this article is that the FBI/Interpol seem pretty content leaving these sites up for extended periods of time while they go after the drug marketplaces, carders, and counterfeiters