4 ms·

One "comfort noise" that Just Ain't Right is the fake engine noise they pipe over the speakers of cars that have a lot of sound proofing, etc. It gives you fee

One "comfort noise" that Just Ain't Right is the fake engine noise they pipe over the speakers of cars that have a lot of sound proofing, etc. It gives you feedback (which increases safety) but it raises trust issues.

jimmaswell 12y ago
I once tried to start a car that was already started because its engine was so quiet.
- nvader 12y ago
  Only once? You must be a fast learner! I learned to drive on my parents' then 10-year-old car that never let you forget when it was running. When I started renting cars, it was quite a shock to me to find how quiet modern cars are.
- jleader 12y ago
  Note that in current gas/electric hybrids, the concept of "started" loses most of its meaning. The system as a whole can be "on" or "off", but doesn't intrinsically make any sound that distinguishes the two states. The gas engine subsystem will get turned on and off at the whim of the controller; if the engine is up to operating temperature and the battery's charge level isn't too low, the controller will turn off the engine whenever its power isn't needed (stopped at a stoplight, driving very slowly, coasting down a hill, etc.). On some models, it's also possible to press a button to tell the system "delay starting the gas engine as long as possible". Hence the concerns about hybrids "sneaking up" on pedestrians.
rtpg 12y ago
On this, I've had taxis sneak up in me (small streets) because they were hybrid and were driving slowly. I , for one, like that fake car noises are a thing. Maybe a new sound would be necessary though
- chriswarbo 12y ago
  Maybe some kind of red flag could work? Carried by a person ahead of the car? ;)
chiph 12y ago
The (well-heeled) car enthusiasts have nothing good to say about the engine sounds that BMW plays through the car's speakers. http://www.cnet.com/news/bmw-m5-generates-fake-engine-noise-using-stereo/ http://www.cnet.com/news/bmw-m5-generates-fake-engine-noise-...

jimmaswell 12y ago

I once tried to start a car that was already started because its engine was so quiet.

nvader 12y ago
Only once? You must be a fast learner! I learned to drive on my parents' then 10-year-old car that never let you forget when it was running. When I started renting cars, it was quite a shock to me to find how quiet modern cars are.
jleader 12y ago
Note that in current gas/electric hybrids, the concept of "started" loses most of its meaning. The system as a whole can be "on" or "off", but doesn't intrinsically make any sound that distinguishes the two states. The gas engine subsystem will get turned on and off at the whim of the controller; if the engine is up to operating temperature and the battery's charge level isn't too low, the controller will turn off the engine whenever its power isn't needed (stopped at a stoplight, driving very slowly, coasting down a hill, etc.). On some models, it's also possible to press a button to tell the system "delay starting the gas engine as long as possible". Hence the concerns about hybrids "sneaking up" on pedestrians.

rtpg 12y ago

On this, I've had taxis sneak up in me (small streets) because they were hybrid and were driving slowly. I , for one, like that fake car noises are a thing. Maybe a new sound would be necessary though

chriswarbo 12y ago
Maybe some kind of red flag could work? Carried by a person ahead of the car? ;)

chiph 12y ago

The (well-heeled) car enthusiasts have nothing good to say about the engine sounds that BMW plays through the car's speakers. http://www.cnet.com/news/bmw-m5-generates-fake-engine-noise-using-stereo/ http://www.cnet.com/news/bmw-m5-generates-fake-engine-noise-...