20 ms·
Blimps Protecting Washington, D.C
- codezero 12y agoI'm curious whether it is common to test this kind of technology right on top of large US cities? Don't most missile defense technologies get tested in more practical, or at least, remote settings? Why aren't these hovering over places that actually are subjected to, or at least more likely to be subjected to missile attacks, like Korea or Israel?
- ceejayoz 12y agoI suspect they're interested in tracking aircraft (and drones) to enforce the flight restrictions around the White House and other areas. As it can track ground vehicles, it could also be useful for tracking vehicles of interest for undetectable surveillance. If I were a Secret Service agent, my biggest fear would be swarm of off-the-shelf drones carrying grenades into something like inauguration. Something like this could give the early warning they need.
- kenrikm 12y agoNot sure about that being feasible to detect things of that nature with this system. For example you can build a mini quadcopter (size of a bird) weighing 5-800gms that can provide 2+KG of thrust. Back of the napkin math says a 400gm m67 grenade is easily within the payload capacity (Assuming 70% throttle to hover all up payload would be 1400+-gms). I would be very impressed if this could differentiate "bird sized flying objects" from birds. With that in mind I think we can be glad that complicated plots of that nature stay in the realm of James Bond rather then reality. Also I think the Boston bombings show that bad people don't need complicated technology to do bad things.
- walshemj 12y agoSound like an entry in Bruce Scheiers Movie plot competition - I would assume that the Secret service and other TLA's have been thinking about this already - off the shelf drones would be a bit to easy to jam I feel. I believe that the IRA did experiment with RC planes but found that DIY mortars where simpler - they very nearly hit downing street a few years back.
- influx 12y agoThese blimps have been used for well over a decade in the southern US border to detect low flying drug smuggling aircraft.
- vibrolax 12y agoFor example, the aerostat that's been tethered at cudjoe key since about 1980. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tethered_Aerostat_Radar_System http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tethered_Aerostat_Radar_Syste...
- adestefan 12y agoIt's not on top of a large US city. They're tethered at Aberdeen Proving Ground which is ~35 miles from downtown Baltimore and ~70 miles from downtown Washington, DC.
- graupel 12y agoThey actually tested these in Dugway, Utah - way, way out in the remote desert - the deployment in Washington isn't as much of a 'test' as it is a real-life use.
- dragontamer 12y agoWashington DC is a valid nuclear target, is it not? It seems like the blimp is designed to at least try to track ICBMs (which are notoriously hard to find and track).
- mikecb 12y agoThis has a range from DC to Boston. If it saw an ICBM, it would be the reentry vehicle, and it would be too late.
- dragontamer 12y agoToo late to stop, but maybe not too late to warn a few critical people to GTFO to their nuclear bunkers.
- mikeash 12y agoI thought ICBMs were trivial to track. They emit a vast plume when they launch, and in the cruise phase they're way up in space, far away from anything that might confuse radars. The threat of ICBMs isn't that they're hard to track, but that their great speed makes them extremely difficult to intercept.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tantalor 12y agoHow does this compare to traditional ground-based radar?
- TwoFactor 12y agoGround-based radars a typically constrained by line-of-sight on the horizon, and the curvature of the earth - you can't see anything beyond the horizon. Being elevated gives you a much larger range as that tangent line moves significantly outward.
- Animats 12y agoThis is Raytheon's JLENS tethered radar surveillance blimp. It's not a new system, or particularly exotic. Sales pitch video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8hkpQ8ujyM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8hkpQ8ujyM The dumbed-down version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiJWBszuq-c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiJWBszuq-c Detailed procurement history: http://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/jlens-coordinating-cruise-missile-defense-and-more-02921/ http://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/jlens-coordinating-cruis... Tethered radar blimps aren't new. One of them provided the first warning of the invasion of Kuwait in 1990. (http://www.tcomlp.com/aerostat-system-kuwait/ http://www.tcomlp.com/aerostat-system-kuwait/) That system had just been installed, and hadn't even been turned over to the Kuwaiti military, what there was of it, yet. A radar operator from TCOM, the manufacturer, detected a big group of approaching tanks. They called in a warning. Unlike Pearl Harbor, it wasn't ignored; the Kuwaiti royal family immediately left the country, escaping the invasion. The JLENS system, unlike older systems, has fire-control capability. That means it has not just a surveillance radar, but can lock onto targets and direct weapons. The real question to ask is what weapons systems are being installed in the Washington area for it to direct. There's no point in having fire-direction capability without weapons to direct. There is an optical surveillance add-on for JLENS, but it's supposedly not on the Washington area blimp. It's surprising this is going up now. I would have expected something like this to have been deployed around November 2001.
- dragontamer 12y agoOld tech designed to protect the President, very likely. A 2013 test confirmed the ability to track short-range ballistic missiles in their boost phase. If a Nuke is to hit Washington DC, we'll want to make sure that the President is warned in time and can enter his nuclear bunker. That said, "Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier" just came out, so people are probably thinking this is some sort of auto-kill sky cannon mounted on Helicarriers for the purpose of suppressing the US Population.
- jedmeyers 12y agoWhat kind of a short-range nuke is going to hit Washington, DC? If it was installed in Seoul, South Korea then maybe, but not DC. There is already a large system in place to detect long-range ICBMs.
- ryan-allen 12y agoIt looks like something out of Half Life 2. Very creepy.
- flurpitude 12y ago"As of press time the aerostats are intended to stay in the air 24/7, and to be taken down only for a monthly maintenance cycle and during extreme weather events such as hurricanes." To any potential attackers, read that statement carefully. There's a clue in there. Disclaimer to NSA etc.: not advocating attacks on the US. Just spotting an apparent loophole.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoProbably they'll keep their detection areas overlapping and take down one blimp at a time...
- baddox 12y agoAnd probably aerial attacks against the United States are even less practical during a hurricane.
- olefoo 12y agoDepends on how much you trust the guidance systems on your cruise missile. That said, I can't see the advantage to any one player in taking out Washington DC unless they can shift attribution to someone else. I mean the small crazies (DPRK etc.) might want to do so but have to know that even success would be fatal to them. And the big crazies (Putin, the Ayatollahs, whoever's really running the show in China) would be too concerned about the consequences. Not saying it couldn't happen, but the odds are, any entity capable of carrying out such an attack successfully has enough to lose that they would be dissuaded from doing something that would have extremely unpredictable consequences.
- squozzer 12y agoCool. But are we fighting the last war?
- mikeash 12y agoThe threat of MAD and nuclear WWIII never actually went away. People just sort of forgot about it.
- eric_h 12y agoThe current proximity of this story to "The weirdness of 50s bomb shelters" on the front page seems remarkably apt.
- ilikepi 12y agoTethered to the ground from almost 2 miles up? I'd imagine this would require a decent sized exclusion zone for air traffic. Also, there's always going to be some wind aloft pulling the blimp away from its anchor. It would be interesting to see a risk assessment for the land immediately surrounding the anchor point given the worst case of the cable separating from its attachment point on the blimp.
- spacefight 12y agoYes, it's within a restricted area ('R'): http://skyvector.com/?ll=39.34010380401439,-76.18002318690418&chart=301&zoom=2 http://skyvector.com/?ll=39.34010380401439,-76.1800231869041...
- ilikepi 12y agoAh, the sectional I was viewing on flightaware.net didn't show that note. I was just reading[1] how a similar aerostat is flown from Cudjoe Key, Florida by the DEA. That one appears to be marked in its own 4 mile wide zone.[2] [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cudjoe_Key,_Florida http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cudjoe_Key,_Florida [2]: http://skyvector.com/?ll=24.664298,-81.482339&chart=301&zoom=2 http://skyvector.com/?ll=24.664298,-81.482339&chart=301&zoom...
- rbcgerard 12y agoThis seems more likely to be used against ground targets (u.s. Citizens) than any arial threat that ground based radar couldn't detect. What non-state actors have cruise missiles?
- electromagnetic 12y agoGround based radar is blind below the horizon, and generally blind near the horizon. At 3.2km (2 miles) up the horizon is 202km away. At 12m (40ft) for a ground based radar (pulled that out of my arse, just for an example) the horizon is at 12.4km. Then we discuss things like the Clutter Zone, which is a big issue for ground based radar systems. Planes and helicopters can fly Nap-of-the-Earth - below about 500ft is the usual stated height - because everything from buildings to wind over 15mph can make it unreliable for ground based systems. An elevated system eliminates most of these problems, and this system has a radar horizon that covers all water and land from DC out to the Atlantic coast. There's a lot of areas where a submarine could launch from unnoticed, and I'm guessing trying to detect a sub in busy waters is a lot harder and less reliable than a radar system to target a missile launch and try to take down a short range ICBM.
- hga 12y agoOr a nuclear tipped supersonic missile like the Mach 3 Sunburn (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-270_Moskit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-270_Moskit), or back in the '80s I heard of the concept of using SLBMs in a "depressed trajectory" mode, where they didn't really get up high but used their rocket energy to travel horizontally really really fast. Putting these sorts of defenses in D.C. is in part about avoiding a "decapitation" attack.
- tomaskafka 12y agoSurprised that nobody mentioned blimp's usefulness for real-time tracking of crowd of revolting citizens in streets.