4 ms·
Well, honestly, why shouldn't people dream big dreams? Since when was everyone supposed to just ignore the larger issues of life and assume the real point is t
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
Well, honestly, why shouldn't people dream big dreams? Since when was everyone supposed to just ignore the larger issues of life and assume the real point is to accumulate money, or whatever other shit society holds we're supposed to do?
- pron 12y agoWho says people shouldn't dream big? But singularity isn't a dream, it's a religious salvation story. There's nothing wrong with religion, either (well, no more than many other ideas that guide humanity), but the difference between this religion and other, older ones is that older religions focused on morality and human nature, while this one is not even about humans at all. The part about the guy weeping because previous generations didn't have Kahneman was clearly written to reflect Christian sorrow for the generations prior to the coming of Christ, but the latter group is sad about those who didn't hear Jesus's message about kindness and love, while the former was crying about those who couldn't tweak their minds to be more robot-like (not that he can, either, but at least he imagines he can).
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>But singularity isn't a dream, it's a religious salvation story. Ok, as long as we're bothering to make this distinction, I don't think that's correct. Most singulatarians I've hung out with place the locus-of-control in their story internally: they believe that, as a group, they will ensure that The Singularity comes to pass, in all its Charles-Strossian-weirdo-glory. As detailed in the article, they have actual groups that are trying to make this happen. They can be incompetent at it, but you can't say they're sitting around waiting for someone else to save them. They're more like Communists than Christians. >the difference between this religion and other, older ones is that older religions focused on morality and human nature, while this one is not even about humans at all. If you followed the article, the whole movement we're talking about has a loud, public component called Effective Altruism who follow Peter Singer's (noticeably Christlike, for all I'm not at all Christian) idea of giving away large portions of their personal income to the highest-impact disease-fighting and antipoverty charities operating in the Third World. Extreme, impersonal charity might be inhuman, in some degree, but I'd be hard-pressed to call it either immoral or disconnected from moral concerns. >The part about the guy weeping because previous generations didn't have Kahneman was clearly written to reflect Christian sorrow for the generations prior to the coming of Christ A guy wept because previous generations didn't have Kahneman and Tversky's foundational findings in behavioral economics? Excuse the following several minutes of nonstop giggling. Sorry, now, you're telling me it's patterned after some Christian thing? I can't really tell yes-or-no here, since I've got no background in Christianity. >but the latter group is sad about those who didn't hear Jesus's message about kindness and love, while the former was crying about those who couldn't tweak their minds to be more robot-like (not that he can, either, but at least he imagines he can). Well, this provides a good opportunity to sum up, and to mention a couple of things. Firstly, I too find it funny that people want to tweak themselves to better operate as fully, calculatively rational utility maximizers. There's a whole literature of bounded rationality showing that throwing out one's information and computation bounds and just trying to approximate unbounded rationality in finite space is a very bad idea ;-)! But secondly, just saying, if people once got sad about others not hearing Jesus's message of kindness and love, well, what of these people and Peter Singer's message of realizing kindness and love in the here-and-now? Or, to get one level crazier, what of the people going to Secular Solstice and weeping that mankind has not yet defeated death, and that we will all lose our loved ones, suffer ourselves, and then die ourselves? I rather imagine that the single fundamental fact of the human condition as we know it is an entirely appropriate target for religious yearnings! The Buddha said, "Existence is suffering." The extropians said, "Let's fix that." Disagree with their cause, or predict that they'll fail, and we can converse sensibly about why they're wrong. Making fun of them for falling into the common psychological modes of religion, and I think you're missing the big human-condition-shaped elephant in the room that simply isn't going to go away.
- pron 12y agoOh, I am well aware that their entire mode of operation is part-and-parcel of the human condition, I'm only noting the irony that this is exactly what they think they're avoiding. But there's another issue here. Not only they believe they can escape not only the fate but the cause of the human condition, they are also, in many ways, blind to it, and this is what makes them different from other religions and even Communism. They are privileged, blind to the misery of the under-privileged, and their persecution story (every religion has to have one) revolves around intellectual superiority. In fact, they are distinguished by having led lives somewhat removed from the concerns of most people. So I think that makes for a pretty lousy religion. The big question is, are they harmless? > A guy wept because previous generations didn't have Kahneman and Tversky's foundational findings in behavioral economics? Excuse the following several minutes of nonstop giggling. I laughed when I read that, too. That story, as given in the magazine, is meant to echo Christians lamenting those generations that lived before the time of Christ and therefore -- by definition -- could not have been saved.