5 ms·
This was particularly memorable for me as during that time, my dad, a wheat farmer, during the winter would construct shelters for folks in town. None were qui
by wglb 12y ago
This was particularly memorable for me as during that time, my dad, a wheat farmer, during the winter would construct shelters for folks in town. None were quite so elaborate as the more extreme ones shown in the article.
A little later, the county was dotted with the Minuteman missle sites and control centers. One silo was on a friends farm. He said it was sobering to think that the several-foot thick concrete lid would blow the better part of a hundred yards away just before launch.
- arethuza 12y agoI'd have thought it would be even more sobering to think about what would be arriving 20 to 30 minutes after the missiles blasted off. NB The novel "Arc Light" includes one thread where the crew from a a Minuteman control center surviving an attack and spending weeks underground then having to make an escape through the devastated landscape: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arc_Light_%28novel%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arc_Light_%28novel%29
- hga 12y agoEven that nasty a situation is survivable with sufficient strength shelters, luck to avoid a random direct hit, and enough food and water/water supply to wait out the longer period required before evacuating the indeed "devastated landscape". What I find weird is the attitude that it's better to die than survive with most all of your loved ones and friends, albeit at a reduced quality of life for a long time. A rather ultimate materialistic attitude, or perhaps it's as Dean Ing put it in Systemic Shock: The American public had by turns ignored and ridiculed its cassandras: city planners, ecologists, demographers, socialists, immigrants, who had all warned against our increasing tendency to crowd into our cities. Social stress, failure of essential services, and warfare were only a few of the spectres we had granted only a passing glance. We had always found some solution to our problems, though: often at the last moment. Firmly anchored in most Americans was the tacit certainty that, even to the problem of nuclear war against population centers, there must be a uniquely American solution; we would find it. The solution was sudden death. A hundred million Americans found it.
- VLM 12y ago"What I find weird is the attitude" Its a manifestation of binary thinking. Well, either we "must" have no nuclear attack, or it "must" be post apocalyptic. Not allowed to be just one shipping container in LA or one maintenance accident at a missile field. A good analogy is often heard for bicycle helmets. I'll either be squashed underneath the wheels of a bus or I won't get into an accident, either way the helmet doesn't matter so I won't wear one. Even if slipping on gravel and hitting your head on the curb is about 100x more likely than either of the binary options.
- wtbob 12y agoWell, with bicycle helmets in particular the odds of the particular type of injury they are effective against are very low, while wearing the helmet itself is risky (cars drive closer to people wearing bike helmets), and the helmet costs money, and it looks bad. My judgement is that the helmet's cost outweighs its benefit in most circumstances, just like walking helmets (yes, they exist!).
- brianlweiner 12y agoDo you have a citation for "the odds of a particular type of injury [helmets] are effective against are very low"? Studies seem to suggest that helmets reduce the risk of a head injury by as much as 85%. In 2012 for nearly 2/3 of bicycle accident fatalities the rider was not wearing a helmet. This used to be an even higher percentage but fortunately the # of fatalities has decliend signficantly in the last 20 years. http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/pedestrians-and-bicyclists/fatalityfacts/bicycles http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/pedestrians-and-bicyclists...
- wtbob 12y agoCheck out http://www.cyclehelmets.org/ http://www.cyclehelmets.org/ > In 2012 for nearly 2/3 of bicycle accident fatalities the rider was not wearing a helmet. That's irrelevant, since it indicates nothing about what fraction of those 2/3 would have survived if they'd been wearing helmets (as an example, if someone is hit my a truck at 50 mph, it really doesn't matter if he's wearing a helmet or not). Also, what fraction of cyclists wear helmets? I'd be surprised were it so much as 1/3; if it's less, then that would indicate that helmet-wearers are more likely to die than non-helmet-wearers (due to risk-tolerance on the part of both cyclists and drivers, c.f. http://www.cnet.com/news/brain-surgeon-theres-no-point-wearing-cycle-helmets/ http://www.cnet.com/news/brain-surgeon-theres-no-point-weari...). There are three types of head strike injury: those with so little force that no death or severe injury would occur, with or without a helmet; those with sufficient force to inflict death or serious injury without a helmet, but which a helmet would prevent; and those with so much force that a lightweight foam-and-plastic helmet wouldn't help. > This used to be an even higher percentage but fortunately the # of fatalities has decliend signficantly in the last 20 years. It looks to me from that IIHS graph that it merely reflects the fact that more people are wearing helmets now than previously.
- wglb 12y agoWell, the concrete lid blowing off was just the beginning point. And the point to putting the silos out there was that there wasn't much to target. There was a joke going around at the time that one of the silos towards North Dakota went off inadvertently and caused $40 damage.
- bdunbar 12y ago> NB The novel "Arc Light" Ah! I read that '95, and recently got to wondering what the title was. Could not think of it for the life of me.
- revscat 12y agoMy grandmother had one of these, as well. She lived in a small town in far west Texas, surrounded by pump jacks and oil fields. The shelter (or cellar, as it was later called) was always stocked with jams and canned goods, and as kids we would occasionally go down there to play, if we could manage to brave the spiders. The thing I realized as I got older, though, was the psychological impact that the threat of nuclear war had on that generation. My grandmother was not wealthy -- she worked most of her life at the cafeteria of the local high school -- and her husband died when he was in his 30's, leaving her to raise 5 children. At some point they decided to spend not-insignificant amounts of money on building a bomb shelter. As I grew up, I realized that this had a subtle but profound impact upon the attitudes of my grandmother and her children: they were all just a little paranoid, careful to the point of it almost seeming neurotic at times. My cousins and I did not share the same fear about the world at large that we witnessed in our parents, and came to believe that this was due to the fact that we grew up in a world where nuclear threats were not so pervasive. It all tied back to the bomb shelter. The mere existence of this cinder block-lined hole in the ground was a daily reminder of what could happen, and what they believed would very likely happen. Many of my aunts and uncles were also prone to believe in the apocalyptic scenario de jure, from upcoming depressions[1] to stockpiling food and water in preparation for Y2K, to more extreme beliefs about race wars and the second coming of Christ. Anyway, this shelter had an impact on me at a young age, but in the opposite direction. It taught me that living in fear like that is no way to live. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Depression_of_1990 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Depression_of_1990
- wglb 12y agoInteresting. My grandparents homesteaded in Northern Montana in 1911 about six miles from a small town. Of necessity, they had a basement (cinder blocks as in your story) and it was always filled with probably six months worth of food. There were periods in my childhood where travel would be infeasible for a week or more, and that was in the age of automobiles. My uncle told of a dinner invite he and my aunt got from a neighbor after a snowstorm that closed their particular road. Having been cooped up for the better part of a week, they decided to go. To travel, they hopped in the diesel tractor (think of a very small caterpillar) and, to the surprise of their hosts, showed up on time. I imagine they left early, as top speed of the tractor was maybe 5mph.