4 ms·
"Under" taxed in what sense? These taxes pay for things like street lighting and street sweeping, which is the same on every street. It should be the same fixed
by gaius 12y ago
"Under" taxed in what sense? These taxes pay for things like street lighting and street sweeping, which is the same on every street. It should be the same fixed amount for everyone.
- toyg 12y agoActually most council tax revenues (usually 40 to 50%) go to the local police.
- AlisdairO 12y agoThat's plainly not true. Even if we accept the notion that taxation occurs on a pay-for-direct-utility model (which isn't true in the general case for any western nation afaik), larger homes with more land will clearly require more lighting and sweeping per person than an apartment block.
- ksrm 12y ago>It should be the same fixed amount for everyone. We tried that. It didn't work.
- gaius 12y agoYeah... That's the dirty little secret of poll tax. It was fair and the people who protested were the ones who don't pay their fair share for local services.
- UVB-76 12y agoIt is patently absurd that, for example, the maximum council tax levied by The Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea is currently £2133.58. You can own a £10m property in the borough, earning upwards of £1m per year in rental income and appreciation, and only have to pay £2k to the local council. Meanwhile, those living in the absolute worst accommodation in the borough still have to pay £711.19.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThat actually sounds about right. The logic of fleecing those who can more afford it may not have good moral foundation. Its tempting, but can you explain how the borough gives more benefits to the rich than the poor? Possibly just the opposite.
- UVB-76 12y agoThat is how the existing system is supposed to work, but the property valuations and bandings have become divorced from the current state of the property market. Note that, in theory, a secondary function of the council tax should be to prevent habitable properties being left unoccupied for extended periods of time. Unfortunately when the tax amounts to a rounding error on the ROI for a property, it is completely ineffectual. Hence the large number of empty 'investment' properties in London, further inflating an already overheated property market.
- judk 12y agoThe rich have no moral right to real estate at all. Real estate was created by God or whatever you believe, not the sweat of ones brow. Property is a social construct; society sets the rules. Property tax is one way of smoothly implementing a lease concept (every century, the property must be repurchased from the government. This works out in both 99 year lease societies and in the common 1% annual tax rate societies). Furthermore, there is no moral right to ineritance.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI guess we grew up in different societies then. Mine has definitely a strong moral right to property. Maybe you need to find one that works in your imaginary way.