2 ms·
PG's argument is that there are only 10 great programmers, but 20 companies that need a great programmer, so no salary increase will solve this. Having only 10
by wodenokoto 12y ago
PG's argument is that there are only 10 great programmers, but 20 companies that need a great programmer, so no salary increase will solve this. Having only 10 companies work is a loss to society at large.
His second argument is that if the US won't let in great programmers from around the world, some other place will, and the US will lose its tech lead.
His 3rd argument is that imported programmers have higher than average costs.
I fail to see any of these arguments reasonably answered in this article.
- larrysalibra 12y agoThe companies that are able to get the best deal, get the 10 programmers, the other companies hire less than ideal programmers. The benefits of their skills accrue to the 10 superstar programmers who make a fortune (at the expense of the investors in the companies that didn't get them) and go on to self-fund their own companies. More people in USA are attracted to programming as a profession (instead of banking, medicine, etc) because they see how well they can do if they're good, increasing the future supply of great developers. This is how it works now (except for H1B). What PG suggests is that in this situation, the benefits should accrue to the investors in the other companies - which just serves to concentrate wealth. He's concerned HE and HIS industry will lose their tech lead because some superstar programmers end up getting paid millions a year (like top bankers) and become independently wealthy without bringing PG et al along for the ride. Re argument #2 who cares what country "leads the world"? I don't want to see individual programmers taken advantage of at the expense of VCs (or other groups) and told "but its for the greater good of the country" Re argument #3 they don't have average higher costs -> see many articles on h1-b abuse http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-10-08/high-rate-of-h-1b-visa-fraudbusinessweek-business-news-stock-market-and-financial-advice http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-10-08/high-rate-of-...