4 ms·
Congressman Spends Week on Uninhabited Island in Pacific
- patio11 17y agoThat brings back memories of my days in Boy Scouts. Getting out in the outdoors is a wonderful character building exercise and presents opportunities that you won't get so much in city living. And yes, it can be breathtaking beautiful and serene. That being said, I'm keenly aware that it is a fun diversion for rich people. (The Congressman is probably a good deal wealthier than my family growing up, but either of us are quite rich in comparison to the typical inhabitant of the Marshall Islands.) Nature can be breathtakingly beautiful and awe inspiring. It can also be terrible and merciless, every inch the avatar of the old pagan gods, and it has a virtually infinite number of ways to kill you. The foundation of human civilization that people enjoy temporarily escaping from so much is minimizing the chance of terrible, brutal death dealt out stochatically by an uncaring world. This is why while I enjoy the occasional escape to nature (with sensible precautions taken) I feel no particular urge to venerate it per se. The folks who live in uncontrolled nature 365 days out of the year -- the global poor -- live in misery, squalor, and constant fear of death from things the rest of us can scarcely comprehend you can die from. (One well-fed American can survive on plentiful crabs for a week but, then again, he could survive on rainwater for a week. A child in a village full of barely-making-it folks can succumb to diseases exacerbated by famine if the local subsistence food production is just a bit worse than it typically is -- and they don't have a panic button to summon the Coast Guard.)
- revorad 17y agoThe foundation of human civilization that people enjoy temporarily escaping from so much is minimizing the chance of terrible, brutal death dealt out stochatically by an uncaring world. Wow, thank you for putting it so well!
- frisco 17y ago> Depending on how permanent Sharpie markers really are, I may have managed to confuse anthropologists years from now, who will surely wonder how it is that hermit crabs on Jabonwod are numbered. That is awesome.
- cake 17y agoIt kind of bother me, I mean can't he find another way to distract himself without "damaging" his environment ?
- JshWright 17y agoWhat, are you worried the hermit crabs are now going to set up some sort of repressive caste system based on their shell numbers?
- cake 17y agoYou never know ;-), but the main problem I have with this is that when camping or when you have some sort of outdoor activity there is one precept : "Leave no trace behind". More details : http://wikitravel.org/en/Leave-no-trace_camping http://wikitravel.org/en/Leave-no-trace_camping I don't think he has done much damage to these crabs, it's insignificant, but he's ruining the beauty that nature has to offer him. He's also ruining it for others and that's more annoying. I'm sure he was pleased to discover this untouched place, he's gesture in my opinion is selfish because he is depriving others from the experience he had, he's even saying at some point : I thought I was watching a large graceful bird in flight, like a red-tailed hawk [...] I was watching a large manta ray, spotted and absolutely beautiful. Now I'm not sure this mantra would have seem so beautiful to him if someone had written his name on it for example. Agreed the Sharpie might disapear in a few days, I'm more concerned about the behaviour : he was bored so he wrote on crabs.
- mquander 17y agoIt's hard for me to tell what exactly you're concerned about. He didn't injure or probably even bother the crabs. The Sharpie really will disappear within a few days, so even if some future nature-lover stumbles upon the island later, his experience won't be "ruined" by numbered crabs (I would find it charming if I found such a thing!) So why are you concerned at all?
- 17y ago
- known 17y agoI think it will help to bootstrap.
- learnalist 17y agoAt first, i wanted to scream out. Who cares. No really your country is up the creek and here you are filling up an article with nothing more than a blow by blow summary of your week alone on an Island. Yet still i read on. Partly that boyish dream of living the crusoe life style. The time i reached the end. Jealous and day dreaming. It hammered home the fact we mostly choose the life we lead today. Equally if i had children, i would want them to read this piece. To allow them that moment to dream and let their mind create Vivid imagery. After all how different was this guys desire to yours and mine to convert that vivid idea into something tangible, real and perhaps even profitable ;) I trust he won't write a book or turn it into a movie!
- junklight 17y agoI'm just jealous. I think I need a holiday: A week alone on a desert island sounds like paradise right now.
- wmblaettler 17y agoAlthough the printer-friendly version made for a nicer read, I became curious at the end to see some photos, since he had mentioned he had at least an underwater camera with him. Here is a link to the main article with photo gallery: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10/11/AR2009101101760.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10... I'd recommend waiting until after you read the article, as it's fairly well-written and descriptive without the images.