3 ms·
Virtually all American (and American-style) sitcoms follow the same simple formula. In the UK, the rules of sitcom are very different. The BBC commissions a la
by jdietrich 12y ago
Virtually all American (and American-style) sitcoms follow the same simple formula.
In the UK, the rules of sitcom are very different. The BBC commissions a large proportion of sitcoms, so the standard length is a full 30 minutes. Our series (seasons) are typically just six episodes long, and few programmes are commissioned for more than three series.
As a result, huge committees of writers are unnecessary, and most programmes are written by just two people with help from a handful of editors and consultants. Scripts can reflect the idiosyncratic voice of the writers, rather than having to conform to an industrial process where writing can be delegated within a team. Characters and plots don't have to reset to zero by the end of an episode, because there is no expectation that a successful series will run indefinitely.
An obvious comparison would be the British and American versions of The Office. The British version finished after just 12 episodes (plus two Christmas specials), following a clear dramatic arc; The American version ran to 201 episodes. The British version was written wholly by Gervais and Merchant, while the American version had over 40 credited writers. One is a work of art, the other is an industrial product.
The medium is the message.
- orf 12y agoNot all BBC sitcoms are like that, look at Not Going Out (which I do love), Citizen Khan and Mrs Browns Boys. While not as sickeningly produced as American sitcoms they do follow a common pattern not dissimilar to the one in the article. I do agree with you though, I'm just playing devils advocate. The Office isn't a great one to choose because the American and English versions cannot really be compared as they are very different beasts, and while the American series shares inspiration it is trying to be something completely different while the English series is a one off stroke of genius (and not really a sitcom).
- jdietrich 12y agoThere are plenty of lazy and derivative British sitcoms, but I wouldn't call The Office a one-off stroke of genius. A great many British sitcoms have similar depth and substance - Gavin and Stacey or The Inbetweeners would be good contemporary examples. Going back further, you have programmes like I'm Alan Partridge, Blackadder, Porridge, The Likely Lads and so on. None of those sitcoms could plausibly have been produced in the US, they're just not sufficiently marketable. British TV commissioning isn't perfect, but it affords a level of creative freedom that is largely absent in the US, and that is necessary for programmes like The Office to come into being. British commissioners really do think in terms of artistic merit rather than purely commercial value. American networks are excellent at producing huge international hits, but there's no room in the system for smaller, quirkier productions. The BBC and Channel 4 tend to take a lot of small risks on cheaper productions rather than always swinging for the fences. Success and failure is far less binary when there isn't the pressure to recoup a huge budget. Some of those cheap experiments will be total flops, some will survive as lowbrow primetime filler, some will find a small but loyal audience, a rare few will be huge hits. None of those outcomes are career-ending catastrophes, they're just part of the process. Commissioners expect and allow that level of variance.
- branchless 12y agoThe BBC and in part Ch4 are funded by the license fee and therefore don't need to have a hit. Failure is an option which can in theory give more room for creativity.
- g_lined 12y agoWhile both the BBC and Channel Four are public broadcasters with a public service remit, Channel Four receives no money from the licence fee and is solely dependent on advertising and similar income.[1] It's better to say not that failure is an option, but rather than making a season of programmes as they are being produced and axing the show if it is failing, the UK system allows shows to be produced well ahead of transmission but in small chunks so that if it does do badly it doesn't need to be recomissioned. [1] http://www.channel4.com/4viewers/faq/name/does-channel-4-get-any-of-the-licence-fee/id/400286880 http://www.channel4.com/4viewers/faq/name/does-channel-4-get...
- tonyedgecombe 12y agoIt is publicly owned though.
- jedberg 12y agoWhenever I watch a British show, I always feel like the writing is much better than American sitmcoms. Don't get me wrong, I love American TV too, but watching British TV doesn't feel like "TV". It usually feels like a series of movies. This completely backs up what you said, and makes a lot of sense in the context that it's ok for characters to change and that most shows only get a limited run.
- Klinky 12y agoI wouldn't put British media on too high of a pedestal. Churning out inspector/detective crime drama swill is one of their specialties. Many of these are about as creative as an episode of Law & Order, some less so.
- stormbrew 12y agoThe thing about perceptions like this is that you have to recognize that there's a filter in place for you that isn't for the people consuming it at the source. Bad British shows are pretty unlikely to make it across the ocean because there's very limited shelf space for foreign media product in the American market.
- jedberg 12y agoThis is an excellent point. I only see the best British shows because those are the ones that Netflix picks up and/or that are recommended to me.
- minthd 12y agoYes, it's true that American series run for a long time. In many cases it's really bad for the story - but for comedy,i find that the story is of less importance and good jokes at a rapid pace are the core - and good comedies can do quite a few great seasons before they lost their charm.
- zem 12y agoi remember watching my way through rowan atkinson's "thin blue line", and being really taken aback that it had so short a run for so enjoyable a comedy. when i asked some british friends about it their opinion was that it was likely written to be two seasons from the outset and then just not extended for the sake of extending it, rather than an indefinite run with each season's existence depending on the popularity of the one before.
- james1071 12y agoYou might explain this better to our American friends by reminding them of the fact that they have a highly commercial film and TV industry, where the profit and loss of individual shows is monitored very closely. What works gets repeated and hence the industry is highly formulaic, with those in control of the money going for the explainable and repeatable. That is not the case in other countries, where the lack of business sophistication has given more room for the creatives to flourish.