3 ms·
> The difference between Anselm's original ontological argument and modern ones like Goedel's or Plantinga's is that while Anselm's is full of terrible reasonin
by philwelch 12y ago
> The difference between Anselm's original ontological argument and modern ones like Goedel's or Plantinga's is that while Anselm's is full of terrible reasoning, Goedel's reasoning is (unsurprisingly) watertight and all the terribleness is concentrated in the axioms.
To me that makes it a success. Part of the entire game of philosophy is to use watertight reasoning to illustrate flaws in the original axioms.