5 ms·

TPB was effectively a modern cultural library for millions. If a child from a poor household wants to experience the greatest music or films created by the arti

TPB was effectively a modern cultural library for millions. If a child from a poor household wants to experience the greatest music or films created by the artists of our era, and doesn't have hundreds of dollars to pursue that wish, then I think that we are doing ourselves AND the artists a huge disservice by shutting them out and telling them: Go watch some youtube videos and play some shitty flash games, kid.

loblollyboy 12y ago
I never thought about it that aspect. Good point. I did have a similar thought yesterday though at Barnes and Noble, when you check out this time of year they ask if you want to buy a book for a charity book drive. I figured most of the people who would be interested in reading would have already found a way to get material without getting ripped off by a bookstore. Be it pirating, project gutenberg library or thrift shop
res0nat0r 12y ago
They can also go to the library.
- ticviking 12y ago
  You may be surprised at the barriers to that for a young person with parents unable to devote time to assisting them with that. Minors need a parent to sign for them(since someone has to be liable for the late fees and repair fees if a book is trashed). In rural communities there may not be a library, or transportation. The school library's book selection is almost always heavily censored, and/or hopelessly out of date.
  - anigbrowl 12y ago
    What about the barriers involving possession of a computer, access to fairly high-speed internet, and the technical knowledge to use Torrents and video codecs and so on?
    - Karunamon 12y ago
      I'd say that a random person is more likely to have access to a computer and usable internet than access to the library. The "technical knowledge" involved in downloading videos involves having a torrent client and a codec pack installed (two download-and-run installers.. my gran could do it). Then, you go to your torrent site, click on what you want, and wait. Nowadays, it's no harder than downloading any other random file from any other random site.

loblollyboy 12y ago

I never thought about it that aspect. Good point. I did have a similar thought yesterday though at Barnes and Noble, when you check out this time of year they ask if you want to buy a book for a charity book drive. I figured most of the people who would be interested in reading would have already found a way to get material without getting ripped off by a bookstore. Be it pirating, project gutenberg library or thrift shop

res0nat0r 12y ago

They can also go to the library.

ticviking 12y ago
You may be surprised at the barriers to that for a young person with parents unable to devote time to assisting them with that. Minors need a parent to sign for them(since someone has to be liable for the late fees and repair fees if a book is trashed). In rural communities there may not be a library, or transportation. The school library's book selection is almost always heavily censored, and/or hopelessly out of date.
- anigbrowl 12y ago
  What about the barriers involving possession of a computer, access to fairly high-speed internet, and the technical knowledge to use Torrents and video codecs and so on?
  - Karunamon 12y ago
    I'd say that a random person is more likely to have access to a computer and usable internet than access to the library. The "technical knowledge" involved in downloading videos involves having a torrent client and a codec pack installed (two download-and-run installers.. my gran could do it). Then, you go to your torrent site, click on what you want, and wait. Nowadays, it's no harder than downloading any other random file from any other random site.