4 ms·
Godel's proof is essentially Anselm's with some mathematical window dressing added. It is worth noting that Anselm's argument applies equally well to Satan as
by lisper 12y ago
Godel's proof is essentially Anselm's with some mathematical window dressing added. It is worth noting that Anselm's argument applies equally well to Satan as to God: The most evil thing we can conceive of would be more evil if it actually existed, therefore Satan must actually exist. If you're into this sort of mind game, it makes an interesting exercise to translate this version of Anselm's argument into formal modal logic.
- michaelsbradley 12y agoWould it really apply to Satan? Historically, most Christian thinkers consider him to be a creature and thus finite in every respect; likewise, evil is generally considered by the same thinkers to be insubstantial, i.e. it is the absence of good and not some kind of entity (or put another way, it's not a matter–anti-matter kind of thing). So it seems evil would have a kind of local maximum, or floor value, depending on your perspective, which would be "zero good". At the same time we could speak of evil being compounded over time, i.e. an accumulation of depraved acts and persons. Of course, you may have other definitions of Satan and evil in mind, and I don't mean to imply that those concepts are solely the province of Christian minds.
- lisper 12y agoOne must not get too hung up on terminology here. The point is that the same argument that applies to "the greatest good that can be conceived" applies just as well to "the greatest evil that can be conceived." You can attach whatever labels to these things you like. The point is that if a great good becomes greater by actually existing, then so does a great evil, and so you can apply Anselm's rhetorical trick just as well to the latter as to the former.
- michaelsbradley 12y agoBut a "semantics of evil" was the point I was trying to bring to the fore. If the maximum local evil (e.g. in a person) is "zero good", i.e. the complete absence of good, then the greatest evil is a fixed value and doesn't seem subject to the same line of reasoning.
- lisper 12y agoNope, doesn't work. If you admit the existence of even a single affirmative evil act (torture, say) then one can always increase the amount of evil by doing more of that affirmative evil act. Mathematically it's analogous to trying to reason from the premise that zero -- the "absence of anything" -- is the smallest possible number. You can do it, but it leads to incredibly messy math. As soon as you try to define subtraction, all hell (pun intended) breaks loose. And as soon as you admit -1 into your system you can no longer have a smallest number (if you have addition and induction).
- michaelsbradley 12y agoJust a thought experiment: What if we define The Good as unity, and evil as the ratio of The Good to relative attainment of the The Good. We might then define compounded evil as a ratio of The Good to the multiplication of the denominators of each ratio-evil consider on its own. So an act of torture might be (/ 1 ½) and three acts of torture would be (/ 1 ⅛).
- lisper 12y ago(/ 1 ½) == 2, and (/ 1 ⅛) == 8, so you're just mapping n onto 2^n. How is that supposed to change anything? You still have a total order and no upper or lower bound, which is all that matters.
- michaelsbradley 12y agoThe multiples of ½ were arbitrary, just an illustration re: denominators. Also, your points above are well taken; I was simply trying to come at the matter (and my previous points) with a bit more precision than I had previously, but I cut my elaborations short as I needed to run out the door. So with my idea above, you would basically have two notions for assigning magnitude to evil. Absolute evil would be defined as the complete absence of good in a person or other locus of circumstances and acts. So the greatest real evil would a fixed value, "zero good", and "negative amounts of good" would be a void construct. The other notion of evil, "evil considered", would be a metaphor for understanding how evil gets compounded according to our usual perception that some lives and acts are more evil than others. It's basically a "score" which doesn't correspond directly to any substance.
- philwelch 12y agoSuppose more of a Manichaean devil rather than the Christian one.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dvt 12y agoTo say that Godel's proof is essentially Anselm's is somewhat shortsighted. Godel used not only modern notation, but also modal logic (which would not exist until the mid-20th century) to prove the necessary existence of God. My biggest point of contention with your claim is that Anselm didn't make a contingent/necessary distinction. Instead, he was caught up in a muddled "exists in understanding/exists in reality" distinction which is decidedly not an analogue of the former. To go a step further, Anselm merely assumed the possibility of God, whereas Godel actually proved it.
- lisper 12y ago> Godel used not only modern notation, but also modal logic (which would not exist until the mid-20th century) Formal modal logic wasn't invented until the 20th century, but Anselm is using modal logic nonetheless. A modal logic is simply a logic that allows operators to be applied to propositions. Necessary-truth and possible-truth are only two possible operators. "Knows" and "believes" are two other classic examples. Anselm's logic uses the operators "actual-truth" and "conceptual-truth". All these proofs have essentially the same structure whether the operators are actual/conceptual or necessary/possible. You could even render the same proof in the modal logic of knowledge and belief. In fact, modern evangelicals often do this. The result renders as something like, "Look at all the martyrs who died. No one makes that kind of sacrifice for false beliefs, therefore their beliefs must be true."
- dvt 12y agoEven though you are correct and logicians like Avicenna and Peter of Spain wrote in gory detail about (what we take to be) Medieval Modality[1], this does not make Medieval Logic even remotely as rigorous as its modern incarnation. The issue here is about having a sound, consistent, and complete logic. S5[2] (what Godel used) has those properties, whereas Anselm didn't even have the notion of soundness or completeness, let alone a logical system that would satisfy them. [1] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/modality-medieval/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/modality-medieval/ [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S5_%28modal_logic%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S5_%28modal_logic%29