4 ms·
What We Talk about When We Talk about Holes
- gjm11 12y agoIn the spirit of (and referenced by) the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry mentioned in the article, here's a lovely little philosophical (and not substantially mathematical) dialogue about holes: http://www.philosophy.org.vt.edu/files/9013/4455/4412/Lewis_and_Lewis_-_Holes.pdf http://www.philosophy.org.vt.edu/files/9013/4455/4412/Lewis_... . (I think the philosophers should be listening to the mathematicians, though. Part of the answer to the question "what is a hole", and part of the explanation for, e.g., the fact that counting the number of holes in a thing is problematic, is that what holed-ness really is is nontrivial homology, and the right question for holes is not "how many?" but "what homology groups?", etc.)
- derefr 12y agoFor those who prefer to listen (and see puppets making silly faces): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SoSx4nxgvgY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SoSx4nxgvgY
- skybrian 12y agoMisleading terminology alert: I would have said that a basketball doesn't have a hole, for the same reason that a tire doesn't have a hole: if it did, it would deflate. But he means that a basketball is in airtight container, so it has a sort of two dimensional hole. By his definition, when you put a cap on a tube of toothpaste, it creates a hole rather than closing a hole.
- ColinWright 12y agoThe point, to some extent, is that when you talk about a "hole" you need to specify what dimension you're referring to. Making that precise is hard, and is one of the things that makes serious topology difficult. And useful. I've worked with robot arm systems with 9 degrees of freedom, and thinking of the configuration space as a 9 dimensional manifold with "holes" was the key point. The terminology isn't misleading, it's technical.
- dang 12y ago> thinking of the configuration space as a 9 dimensional manifold with "holes" was the key point Fascinating. Can you expand on that? i.e. what is the configuration space, how did manifolds with holes connect with it, and how did you figure out that the problem should be represented that way?
- ColinWright 12y agoI'll see if I can write that up - It'll take more time than I have right now. In essence, people tend to think of moving through a space like "robot positions" as moving through ordinary space: "I can see where I'm going - I'll go that way." Unfortunately, in higher dimensions that doesn't work, and you have to develop an awareness of where the holes are so you can go round them. I'll write that up and submit it.
- prutschman 12y ago> he means She means.
- kazagistar 12y agoBoth are holes, they are just different dimensions of holes. The holes in swiss cheese are still holes, even if you haven't exposed them yet.
- Mz 12y agoI am having trouble following this. It kind of breaks my brain, like discussing time and dimensions with my sons. But I cannot help but think of portable holes in old cartoons, like Bugs Bunny. Edit: Though I will say I am impressed with her example of torus. Donut glaze is something everyone should be able to relate to.