11 ms·
They estimate in their chart that Athletic trainers have a 0.007 chance of being automated, the third lowest chance after therapists and dentists. it's hard to
by SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago
They estimate in their chart that Athletic trainers have a 0.007 chance of being automated, the third lowest chance after therapists and dentists.
it's hard to know exactly what they class as "Athletic trainers". For Olympic athletes, there will always be staff. For the rest of us, what would that "unlikely" automation of the coach look like? Perhaps it would start with a movement sensor on the wrist? A smartphone app to track and recommend exercise?
That's not looking unlikely to me, it's looking like it's already here in plain sight:
http://www.fitbit.com/ http://www.fitbit.com/
http://www.microsoft.com/microsoft-band/en-us http://www.microsoft.com/microsoft-band/en-us
https://play.google.com/store/apps/category/HEALTH_AND_FITNESS https://play.google.com/store/apps/category/HEALTH_AND_FITNE...
- anon4 12y agoSo you're saying the future is in robotics.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoThe future is monitoring and surveillance. That's what these systems do. That and a few data-driven suggestions here and there.
- midnightreactor 12y agoHere's a novel perspective for you: This class of devices are subsidized pieces of technology for use by a group of people, a portion of which for whom it could argued would not have access to the resources this technology provides, and they have access to a greater wealth of data because they are not entitled to rights management for the data they produce, for better or worse. The challenge of these systems is gaining value and insight of understanding different aspects of human behavior while considering the risk/reward calculation each actor engaged in the system. Your use of the words monitoring and surveillance betrays an implied connotation which could be described in the vein of paranoid or Orwellian. It's disingenuous to distill the entirety of what these systems do as "monitoring and surveillance [...] and a few data-driven suggestions here and there". It's more like "monitoring and surveillance" are what these systems are, implied context or not, and what you and I get out of it are suggestions informed by the data of what you and I and everyone else participating actually does within a system.
- angersock 12y agoTo midnightreactor: You've been shadowbanned by the HN hivemind. Better luck next account. :(
- raverbashing 12y agoBut then again, the intersection of people who would pay for a trainer and had it switched to a fitbit is not so huge (Kind of similar to "lost sales due to piracy" given some limits)
- _lex 12y agoThis shows me how myopic and out of touch these guys are - I already use the biggest loser on xbox kinect, and it's replaced both a gym and a trainer for me.
- raverbashing 12y ago"and it's replaced both a gym and a trainer for me" Exactly The game is enough for you (and for a lot of people) And that's in the universe of people that do exercise currently. But the game doesn't replace weights/equipment (as much as the bodyweight people want to convince it's not needed) or more advanced training techniques (and frankly, several "fitness trainers" are misguided) But trainers and gyms etc are going to keep existing for people who want to go further, or want to socialize, do something different, have specific training requirements, etc
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoWeights and equipment can't be emulated in software. And you need a gym to keep them in and provide hot showers after. But I'd say that there's less need for a personal trainer than ever before. You can find the how-to use video on youtube, the community on reddit/r/fitness, the training calculator on your phone, etc. I don't see that trend reversing.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoThere is a chemical compound going through investigation currently that emulates exercise in your muscle tissue: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/07/17/exercise-in-a-pill-the-search-continues/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/07/17/exercise-in-a-pill-... What we can't emulate in software or robotics, shall be done in biology.
- maerF0x0 12y ago> "Weights and equipment can't be emulated in software. " But if you have a friggin strong robo butler, it can provide all the resistance you need.
- 12y ago
- JshWright 12y agoYeah, the same chart lists a 17% chance that "firefighters" will be automated... I'm equally curious what then definition of "firefighter" is. If they are talking about woodland (or "forest") firefighting, then _maybe_ (I could see drones accomplish at least some of the tasks involved). But for structural firefighting? No way... Not in 20 years.
- vosper 12y agoBut this is exactly the right reading of the chart - the description says "chances that automation will lead to job losses", not "chance that all jobs will be replaced by automation". So, perhaps it will be drones assisting in wildfires that reduce the need to pay as many people to fight that type of fire, whilst structural firefighting remains the domain of humans - for now.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWhy not? Is it the chaotic environment? The temperature extremes? The unpredictability of each situation? All those are strong reasons TO automate firefighting. Machines can function better in heat/smoke/violent structural collapse situations. They can make objective analysis when their own mortality is not an issue. Nobody made money betting against advances in computing.
- JshWright 12y agoI'm all for advances in technology making things safer and putting fewer people in harms way. I just don't think there is anything close to a 17% chance that it will happen in the next two decades. I say this as someone who has a foot in both worlds, so to speak... I work in technology, build UAV quadcopters (including playing with various sensors) as a hobbyist, and work at least one shift a week as a firefighter/paramedic. Technological advances in recent years have made life much better in the fire service. Thermal imaging cameras have gotten lighter, with much larger thermal ranges. Gas detection has similarly lighter and more accurate. Breathing apparatus have gotten 'smarter' and lighter, allowing longer working times, less fatigue, and better insights for incident commanders on the status of their crews. Research in fire development and behavior has led to significants advances in strategy and tactics. However, those tactical decisions are still well beyond the scope of what computers (and computer vision) are capable of. There is just too much variation in how homes are build and occupied (and modified). Here are just a few of the issues I see: -Moving an unconscious victim requires a fair amount of care, and I don't think robotics are there yet... -'Reading' smoke coming from a structure gives a lot of insight into the design and occupancy of the structure. I think that's well beyond the current limits of computer vision and decision making. -There are many activities performed by firefighters outside the scope of 'putting water on fire'. Responding to medical emergencies, technical rescue scenarios, etc... Extricating a victim of a car crash is a very delicate operation that employs equipment capable of exerting many thousands of pounds of force, and a few inches is the difference between freeing someone from a deformed care and crushing them to death... Really the biggest issues I see have to do with tactical decision making based on a huge number of subtle variables (which would involve very sophisticated computer vision), and simply navigating in and around a structure. Designing a robot that can move autonomously through all areas of a house, into closets, under beds, etc, while still being strong enough to lift and move a disabled victim, or employee various tools seems like a pretty difficult problem to solve. How would you power it? Batteries aren't anywhere close to that point, and tethers would limit mobility too much. Personally I think the next 20 years will see continued augmentation, rather than replacement of the men and women in the fire service. For instance, I would love to see an SCBA facepiece with an integrated heads up display providing an infrared image and levels of various gasses that are good indicators of air quality. Once we have that, I'd love the ability to switch between 'tank' air (which I carry a very limited amount of on my back) and 'filtered' air (which would just come from the environment, filtered for particulates, allowing me to save my bottle for when I need it). I think there is also an opportunity for improved 'mapping' of structures as a firefighter moves through them (again, integrated on a HUD inside the facepiece). That would significantly reduce the number of deaths and injuries that occur when firefighters become disoriented and lost in zero-visibility situations. This ended up being much longer than I expected it to be... TL;DR; The next 20 years will see augmentation, not replacement. Who knows what the 20 years after that will bring...
- digi_owl 12y agoI recall seeing articles on what may be described as high tech long johns. They were covered in sensors that would give you a readout about every major muscle on your body. Hook that up to a stripped down Watson that can tell you exactly when and how you are doing wrong.