4 ms·
I got all of them right except 6. My initial response was that you had to turn over all the cards. Thinking about why I chose this option I realised that I was
by danieltillett 12y ago
I got all of them right except 6. My initial response was that you had to turn over all the cards. Thinking about why I chose this option I realised that I was not trusting the rule that a card must have a number on one side if it has a letter on the other side. My experience has made me highly suspicious that the model I have been given by someone is correct so I always like to test the assumptions of the model if possible.
- learnstats2 12y agoIndeed. This question indicates that we should trust one part of what is written, and only question another part. But both parts are written in the same voice, by the same authority. I like your answer. I got the question 'correct' (in part because I've seen the exact same question years ago) but I wonder if the results teach us more about the questions than the answers. In many human psychology experiments where humans are said to behave irrationally, I often think they are really behaving rationally when the context of the situation is taken into account.
- otis_inf 12y agoI had it wrong too, but mostly because I had an issue with the 8 card: IMHO it has to be turned over as it might have e.g. a 'V' on the other side, and that side also belongs to the card, but the answer explicitly states 8 isn't needed because apparently the other side isn't part of the card so the rule only applies to the sides you initially see. A bit of a trick question IMHO.
- pedrosorio 12y agoYou got that wrong. The rule is "vowel on one side implies even number on the other side". The only cards that don't follow this rule are the ones that have a vowel and an odd number. A card with an 8 will never disprove the rule regardless of the letter on the other side, that's why you don't need to turn it.
- otis_inf 12y agoYeah I got that now. I feel pretty stupid after I found that out... :)