8 ms·
Solidarity against online harassment
- gnu8 12y agoDon't be too quick to dismiss this harassment as part of the gamergate-style nonsense that has been going on as of late. This type of thing is typical of the frat boy intelligence community. It's considered the height of their tradecraft to anonymously harass opponents with facile mockery and threats. Recall the FBI's campaign against Dr. Martin Luther King: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/fbis-suicide-letter-dr-martin-luther-king-jr-and-dangers-unchecked-surveillance https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/fbis-suicide-letter-dr...
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoI am almost certain that it's related to this: http://charon.persephoneslair.org/~andrea/pandorasts/jeremy_becker/ http://charon.persephoneslair.org/~andrea/pandorasts/jeremy_... It really has nothing to do with gamergate, except I suppose insofar as being subjected to your own harassment might give you solidarity with other people who have been harassed.
- krakensden 12y agoI'm pretty sure it's just more of this slapfight: http://pando.com/2014/11/14/tor-smear/ http://pando.com/2014/11/14/tor-smear/
- psycr 12y agoHaving just read that article, and also having just learned about Tor's funding - is there any independent/third party summary of this news?
- srslack 12y agoIt has nothing to do with that, and there's no evidence to back up the claim that gamergate is a harassment campaign, which seems to be what you are implying. Here's an actual, statistical network analysis: http://chrisvoncsefalvay.com/2014/12/07/Gamergate.html http://chrisvoncsefalvay.com/2014/12/07/Gamergate.html The only issue I have with the Tor statement is, who actually thinks harassment is a good thing, except sadistic individuals? It's a false dichotomy. The troll they're referring to was pretty pathetic.
- gnu8 12y agoYou've failed to understand my point, which is that this is likely state sponsored harassment. I only mentioned gamergate as an example of pointless trolling, which this incident might not be.
- bobcostas55 12y agoJust gonna leave this here: https://twitter.com/fucktyler/status/285670822264307712 https://twitter.com/fucktyler/status/285670822264307712 I can't wait until this outrage culture fad is over and we can collectively move on to more interesting things.
- manux 12y agoWhile you _can_ effectively go away from your screen, when people target your personal/professional mail/online accounts, that's not possible. Imagine if people called your phone all the time to insult you. You _could_ turn it off, but then how would your friends and family join you? It's rare that harrassing gets to that point, but when it does you can't just turn away and ignore it.
- rmc 12y agoYou can't walk away from threats to be shot.
- meowface 12y agoWho was threatening to shoot who?
- angersock 12y agoWe have decided that it is not enough for us to work to protect the world from snoops and censors; we must also stand up to protect one another from harassment. And with that, they've moved from being a dumb pipe to being a force for censorship. Way to go folks. :( The big problem we see with the internet, and basically any sort of truly open point-to-point communication system that is truly unbiased, is that means that people are able to talk to whomever they want. True, free, and open communication, with all that that implies. Personally, I think the only technological solution to this is to make it expensive enough to send messages that people won't just go and harass for the lulz. One could even imagine a system where, perhaps using some kind of bitcoin analogue, additional traffic to a user becomes increasingly "expensive" unless given specific rebates by the recipient--in effect, the more messages a user gets, the more expensive it is to message them, unless they give you permission to do so. As for non-tech solutions, people need to come to terms with the fact that others may say terrible and hurtful things to them, and they need to have the fortitude to deal with it or ignore it (and that's not easy, but it's essential if you want to be a responsible adult that encourages freedom in today's world).
- JackC 12y agoAnd with that, they've moved from being a dumb pipe to being a force for censorship. This has nothing to do with censorship. It doesn't attempt to make harassment impossible or illegal. It's a social strategy: you can choose to harass people online, or you can choose to be friends with the Tor developers, but you can't do both. For that matter, harassment is also a social strategy to discourage unwanted activity: you can choose to be a high-profile woman online, or you can choose not to have tons of strangers hate you, but you can't do both. So if this Tor statement somehow was censorship, harassment would be censorship as well. And so would lots of other things people do every day. We're social animals; we do things to encourage or discourage social participation that we like or don't like. If you have stinky shoes, we stand farther away. If you say shitty things to women, you can't be friends with the Tor developers. It's not censorship, it's freedom of choice. people need to come to terms with the fact that others may say terrible and hurtful things to them, and they need to have the fortitude to deal with it or ignore it If you need people to do that, you have a problem, because it is not going to happen. No snark here: if your plan for encouraging freedom depends on people not walking away from harassment, it is an unworkable plan. If you walk into a bar and everyone shouts terrible things at you, you are not going to "deal with it or ignore it"; you are going to leave. Right now big parts of the internet are like that for (e.g.) women: a bar they walk into, get terrible things shouted at them, and leave. The Tor devs here are saying, metaphorically, "hey, cut it out, man. You're making this bar suck for everyone." To me, that's a responsible way to encourage freedom in today's world, and more people should do the same.
- thrillgore 12y agoWhat movement is being used to harass whom again?
- exstudent 12y agoWhat exactly does this mean? Are there new centralized control mechanisms in the works for Tor? This seems like a really bad idea TBH. I don't want my privacy tools to come with some strangely ambiguous "political" feeling sentiment. Focus is the key to success and this doesn't seem like it.
- MeadowTheory 12y agoI see no indication in the statement to that effect. Please take your baseless speculation and political naivete somewhere more appropriate.
- tonysuper 12y agoI really hope this blog is only talking about Tor the community and not Tor the technology. I'm pretty sure it's impossible to ban people who are harassing others without storing some identity information, which completely defeats the purpose of Tor.
- 0x5f3759df-i 12y agoI don't think this is anything other than a public condemnation of the people who use anonymity to harass people. >This declaration is not the last word, but a beginning: We will not tolerate harassment of our people. We are working within our community to devise ways to concretely support people who suffer from online harassment; this statement is part of that discussion. We hope it will contribute to the larger public conversation about online harassment and we encourage other organizations to sign on to it or write one of their own. Key word is "declaration". I don't think this will effect the tor technology in any way.
- signalsmith 12y agoThis isn't a technological change - they're just publicly stating that members of the community are being harassed (especially women), and that's not OK. So it's not de-anonymisation, it's calling out bad behaviour that is often ignored (because it's nicer to pretend it's not an issue).
- foragerone 12y agoWhy is this tagged with "feminism"? I'm really uncomfortable with that. I don't want ideology (of any kind) in my technology.
- johnloeber 12y ago>I don't want ideology (of any kind) in my technology. That too is an ideology, and it's not a trivial one.
- signalsmith 12y agoI can't +1 this enough.
- foragerone 12y agoThinking about it, I'll concede that it is an ideology. One I'm proud to hold and I think is very tech friendly and progressive. I'll restate it: I think tech should be tech. I don't want privacy tools to contain censorship mechanisms because I believe in free speech.
- JackC 12y agoSo, just more food for thought: this ideology (that it's bad to look at your tech through a feminist lens, or any other random social lens) tends to be a conservative force, not a progressive one. Tech has to be built for someone. You build for people you (probably) assume have eyes and ears and hands and written language and a financial system and a predictable reward mechanism and a notion of privacy and on and on and on. The only thing that makes a product "good" or "bad" is its interaction with a massive stack of assumptions you're making about the user. But you only know like 0.000002% of the possible users of your product. So really you're extrapolating wildly from a tiny set of clues about your user, based on signals sent to you by your culture. (Where "culture" is just the set of stuff that filters through to you about the people around you who you don't know personally.) And that culture holds some people to be more "normal" than others. Consider (as just some examples) that test subjects start to see a crowd as half women when it's much less than half. A movie poster with women on it is intended only for women; a poster with men on it is for everyone. A movie poster with only black people is intended only for black people; a poster with white people is for everyone ... So the product you build is based on a dirty signal -- it incorporates a massive stack of assumptions about the user, derived from a culture that you know is lying to you about what a normal person is. If you build for your internal idea of a "normal" user, letting tech be tech, then you reinforce whatever happened to be handed to you without realizing you're doing it. That's why this is a conservative ideology. "Feminism" in this context is a progressive tool -- it's a way to look at your product with fresh eyes. How do anonymity tools look if we assume that all users are equally important, focusing on the experience of men vs. women? Huh, it seems that the user base includes a significant number of men who are hateful toward women, and that has a big impact on who participates in anonymous forums and how men and women experience them. Now we have a lot of different options for dealing with that (censorship being only one, and obviously not one the Tor project would choose). Before we* used this lens, our only option was to ignore it and preserve the status quo. Other "-isms" are just other tools. Anything that your culture cares too much or too little about -- and therefore tends to lie to you about -- is a possible lens to learn about users you're ignoring, because your mental model of "normal" doesn't match reality. (* Note I'm not at all affiliated with Tor, just using "we" generally here.)
- comex 12y agoI see three different top-level comments suggesting that this post is an oblique announcement of some kind of censorship or banning system being developed for the Tor software. It is clearly nothing of the sort, and Tor developers value the system far too much to try to shoehorn a backdoor into it. Respond to it for what it is - a statement of social principles.
- exstudent 12y agoI wouldn't say "clearly". They make reference to doing something about harassment but give no outline what that might be. The post is tagged feminism. Believe it or not, not everyone supports this type of feminism. I'm not comfortable with Tor being so overtly political.
- MeadowTheory 12y agoYou mean some people are uncomfortable in having their place in the social pecking order challenged? News at 11.
- exstudent 12y agoNo. First of all you're being pretty rude. Secondly, I don't want ANY pecking order in Tor. They should just focus on making privacy tools and leave the unrelated political messaging aside.
- tptacek 12y agoWhat other volunteer organizations would be better if they just did whatever you wanted them to?
- IsaacSchlueter 12y ago"Making privacy tools" IS political. Why is it a surprise that the people making these privacy tools were motivated by a desire for communication free of the chilling effects of violence?
- 12y ago
- curiously 12y agowhat was nature of the harassment that they were getting that warranted such a strong response?