4 ms·

I frankly don't know how to improve on clicking the big fat green button in the popup to whitelist a site (Ctrl-click for a specific page).

by gorhill 12y ago

ddorian43 12y ago
sorry, i never hovered on it. thanks
pjlegato 12y ago
It's not at all obvious what that button does. The icon is typically associated with "power on/off." While I can see how this is supposed to suggest whitelisting in an abstract and metaphoric sense, making that connection is a bit of a stretch, particularly for casual users. I suggest removing the icon and just putting a plain old checkbox with a label that says "Whitelist Site".
- _asummers 12y ago
  If you hover over it, it tells you exactly what it does.
  - lomnakkus 12y ago
    "hover over it to find out what it does" does not constitute good UX unless you're talking about a toolbar with a multitude of icons which cannot all (by sheer numbers) be "intuitive".
    - _asummers 12y ago
      I'm not claiming it's the best UX, and I have no particular affinity to this program, but it's really not hard to tell what it does, especially for the demographic here.
      - lomnakkus 12y ago
        Nor do I have any particular affiliation or affinity. It just sounds like poor UX/UI. I guess the whole "hover over it if you're confused" thing is pretty established by now, so I'd say your original assessment is probably the correct one. I just want us (the industry) to get better at this stuff! :)
        _asummers 12y ago
        Fair enough; that's totally reasonable, and I agree with you. I guess I just had an objection to the post I originally replied to which (seemingly) had the attitude of it being impossible to tell what the button did. The UX could certainly be better, but it's not bad.
      - Zuider 12y ago
        Yes, but it is not intuitively obvious for the ordinary user who would account for the majority of page views and potential advertising revenue.
- pjlegato 12y ago
  Addendum: The apparent scope of the icon is browser-wide, not limited to the current page. Since the "power on/off" icon is unqualified, it seems like clicking it will turn the entire plugin on and off, not merely whitelist the current site.

I frankly don't know how to improve on clicking the big fat green button in the popup to whitelist a site (Ctrl-click for a specific page).

by gorhill 12y ago

I frankly don't know how to improve on clicking the big fat green button in the popup to whitelist a site (Ctrl-click for a specific page).

ddorian43 12y ago

sorry, i never hovered on it. thanks

pjlegato 12y ago

It's not at all obvious what that button does. The icon is typically associated with "power on/off." While I can see how this is supposed to suggest whitelisting in an abstract and metaphoric sense, making that connection is a bit of a stretch, particularly for casual users. I suggest removing the icon and just putting a plain old checkbox with a label that says "Whitelist Site".

_asummers 12y ago
If you hover over it, it tells you exactly what it does.
- lomnakkus 12y ago
  "hover over it to find out what it does" does not constitute good UX unless you're talking about a toolbar with a multitude of icons which cannot all (by sheer numbers) be "intuitive".
  - _asummers 12y ago
    I'm not claiming it's the best UX, and I have no particular affinity to this program, but it's really not hard to tell what it does, especially for the demographic here.
    - lomnakkus 12y ago
      Nor do I have any particular affiliation or affinity. It just sounds like poor UX/UI. I guess the whole "hover over it if you're confused" thing is pretty established by now, so I'd say your original assessment is probably the correct one. I just want us (the industry) to get better at this stuff! :)
      - _asummers 12y ago
        Fair enough; that's totally reasonable, and I agree with you. I guess I just had an objection to the post I originally replied to which (seemingly) had the attitude of it being impossible to tell what the button did. The UX could certainly be better, but it's not bad.
    - Zuider 12y ago
      Yes, but it is not intuitively obvious for the ordinary user who would account for the majority of page views and potential advertising revenue.
pjlegato 12y ago
Addendum: The apparent scope of the icon is browser-wide, not limited to the current page. Since the "power on/off" icon is unqualified, it seems like clicking it will turn the entire plugin on and off, not merely whitelist the current site.