4 ms·
How Thinking Goes Wrong: Fallacies That Lead Us to Believe Weird Things
- nazgulnarsil 17y agotoo disorganized. I prefer these linked lists, I collectively call them the skeptic's bible. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases
- tokenadult 17y agoThanks for the Wikipedia lists link. I like Shermer's writings for the examples that they give as he discusses general principles. After edit: Oh, and there is some doubt that the Hawthorne effect (mentioned in the link you kindly shared) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect#Interpretations_and_criticisms_of_the_Hawthorne_studies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect#Interpretation... is a genuine phenomenon.
- tlb 17y agoReally? You don't believe such an effect ever happens? It's one thing to say that particular results are not due to the effect, but the effect itself seems like a pretty likely source of error in any not-very-rigorous experiment.
- tokenadult 17y agoI spent most of my youth believing that there is a Hawthorne effect as described in the usual anecdote, but then on Usenet in the 1990s a psychologist referred me to a peer-reviewed article that actually went back to the data gathered by the original researchers. The article said that it is more likely that the change in worker performance was due to operant conditioning based on changed working conditions that were going on at the same time as the changes in factory lighting and so forth that the anecdote is about. Is there any replication http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html of a straight-up Hawthorne effect anywhere else in the peer-reviewed literature?
- tlb 17y agoOK, fair enough. It hasn't been convincingly demonstrated. But maybe you'll agree that it's still a good idea to watch out for the Hawthorne effect when doing human performance research, because it seems like a possible source of error. You wouldn't tell experimenters "there is no Hawthorne effect, so stop worrying about it."
- tlb 17y agoAbout cold fusion, he says: Maybe fifty years of physics will be proved wrong by one experiment, but don't throw out your furnace until that experiment has been replicated. Pons and Fleischman's announcement can hardly be described as telling people to throw out their furnaces. They announced that they had measurements which were not explainable by the prevailing theories, and the new theory it suggested would be hugely valuable. Some journalists made it seem even more exciting than that, but I don't think you can blame scientists for the way they are reported in the popular press any more than you can blame politicians for what's reported on Fox News. Of course, it turned out that their numbers were better explained by some subtle measurement errors, but it took hundreds of chemists years to convincingly refute the theory. It was not an unreasonable decision to announce it publicly, in order to mobilize the resources necessary to get to the bottom of it.
- tokenadult 17y agoit took hundreds of chemists years to convincingly refute the theory Some observers were skeptical from the beginning because the neutron output of a genuine fusion process was never found by the persons who announced their discovery of "cold fusion." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_fusion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_fusion It's also a matter of opinion whether the errors in measurement of total system energy inputs and outputs were subtle or gross. Being the son of an industrial engineer who studied chemistry, I'm of the opinion that the errors were inexcusably sloppy for researchers who held a press conference to announce their results.
- tlb 17y agoOh, but the lack of neutron output was the most interesting part! If there had been neutrons, people would have assumed there was an obscure sort of inertial confinement fusion going on at some particular kind of defect in the crystal structure, perhaps a microscopic Farnsworth Fusor. Such an effect would be intriguing if it existed, but not very fundamental and probably not that useful. Cold Fusion was important because it raised the possibility of a previously unknown mass/energy conversion mechanism, or at least a manifestation of a poorly understood one like neutrino emission or absorption. Neutrinos are a good lesson in how much we actually understand the world. The neutrino flux from the sun is thought to be 10^12 particles per square meter per second, yet its mass is "Unknown, probably nonzero" [Wikipedia]. They don't seem to interact with ordinary matter much, but we can't rule out them interacting strongly with particular molecular structures in Palladium-Deuterium alloys. Nor can we rule out the presence of particles that interact even more weakly than neutrinos. The 1995 Nobel was awarded for finding evidence of neutrinos that are now thought to have been antineutrinos. Particle physics is not a solved problem.