3 ms·
Reading these replies just makes me sad. There's plenty of value in and plenty to learn from older technologies like Lisp, Scheme, Smalltalk, and Forth. Sure,
by pmoriarty 12y ago
Reading these replies just makes me sad. There's plenty of value in and plenty to learn from older technologies like Lisp, Scheme, Smalltalk, and Forth.
Sure, there's a lot of hype around newer technologies. There's never a shortage of hype. But the glow around virtually all of them will fade, probably sooner rather than later.
Ruby and Python are no longer considered hot and new, but not so long ago they were. Java and Perl had their share of hype back in the day, but the luster has certainly wore off by now.
Too many people involved in the tech field are endlessly chasing the next shiny thing.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoToo pessimistic. The new learns from the lessons of the old. I'd advise a new student to start with tools that reflected advancements in thought and practice. It might be cool to use the old tools because they are part of history; but its not helpful to the new student.
- pmoriarty 12y agoIf only they were advances rather than regressions. Far too much overhyped technology actually sets back progress by decades rather than advances it. Unfortunately, "the new student", never having learned the lessons of the past doesn't know any better and is condemned to repeat mistakes and reinvent and rediscover poor imitations of older technologies while calling them new.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoOk, learning to code and learning to design languages are different tasks. Those writing 'new' languages would be well-served to study the history and progression of languages. Those learning to code have enough on their plate, learning a mental model of computation and how to construct software for given tasks. History lessons are a case of 'too much information'
- pmoriarty 12y agoDevelopers can benefit from learning classic languages. By learning the classics, especially those that are radically different from what you already know, you expand your mind and your sense of what is possible. It helps you get a different perspective on any given problem you may run in to, having seen radically different approaches to similar problems in the past. It puts another tool in your toolset and lets you select the best tool for the job. Not that the above is not possible to get with exposure to hot new technologies, but whatever's hot in the market tends to be much more of a monoculture and popular due to being not too different from what most developers already know (Clojure and Scala being perfect examples).
- srgpqt 12y agoSome classics are relevant today, like C. Others not so much, and won't help "expand" anyone's mind. COBOL for example.
- rjberry 12y agoIt's definitely possible to learn things from those languages. But languages that are trendy today (at least from my experience in the London job market) - Clojure and Scala - are really amazing, too, and have a lot of interesting ideas about concurrency, immutable data structures, and functional programming. Scheme, when compared to Clojure, seems a bit outdated now IMHO, although its extremely simple, small core makes it great for teaching.
- pmoriarty 12y agoIf Scheme looks outdated to you compared to Clojure, I'd wager you are speaking from an unfamiliarity with modern Schemes like Chicken, Racket, and Guile. This is an unfortunate, but all too common a perspective, since most people who are exposed to Scheme are exposed to in in an academic environment where they only get to play with ancient, primitive Schemes such as MIT Scheme of SICP fame, and come away with an impression that Scheme is a quaint toy language that may be useful for pedagogy but probably nothing else. Nothing could be further from the truth, if you consider the capabilities of the modern Schemes.
- rjberry 12y agoRacket is so different it's basically a different language, so I'm not really talking about that. I do know Chicken and Guile have more advanced library support than the Scheme I worked with on SICP, but neither has as advanced concurrency features or advanced immutable collections, which is why Clojure seems to me a big advance on Scheme. Plus that you can leverage existing libraries on the JVM, plus its excellent compile-to-JavaScript support, etc., etc.
- pmoriarty 12y agoI view lack of dependency on the JVM as an advantage of Schemes over Clojure. The last thing I want to do when developing in Scheme is learn or have to deal with Java or the JVM. Chicken compiles down to C, so gets C's speed, size, and portability advantages. Chicken can also access C, Python, and Perl libraries, which aren't exactly lacking compred to those of Java. Not to mention that Chicken comes with a respectable set of libraries on its own, and that R7RS compatibility will bring a much larger "batteries included" core. Guile is looking like its going to become the core of Emacs, and is an extension language for various other tools (like GIMP), so there are wins for learning it if you are interested in any of these ecosystems.