3 ms·
You must factor in that such a region would contain a low percentage of the total number of civilizations intelligent enough to consider the question. A well-tu
by dTal 12y ago
You must factor in that such a region would contain a low percentage of the total number of civilizations intelligent enough to consider the question. A well-tuned universe would be teeming with life - it is therefore more likely that we find ourselves in such a universe (which was the point of the GP). You can think of it, not as a bullseye, but as a gaussian spot.
It strikes me that the issue at play here is how one chooses to "sample" the anthropic principle, for want of a better term. When you say "pick a region at random", you assume a uniform probability distribution over the set of all universes supporting life (which incidentally is not possible if the number is infinite). But you don't say how to resolve the probabilities with universes containing multiple intelligent life forms - you do select randomly among those too? If so, shouldn't you rather be picking "randomly" from the set of all intelligent life forms in all universes in the first place?
- danieltillett 12y agoYes it all concerns the shape of the distribution. I have not assumed any any sort of distribution by the way as I have no means of estimating it. It may be possible in the future to estimate how well tuned a universe could be made for the appearance of intelligent life and also how large the surrounding non-tuned space could be. In the mean time we can only speculate :)