4 ms·
We can't calculate the probability of life arising though because even if we did know how it arose here—which we don't exactly—we don't know all the possible di
by danieltillett 12y ago
We can't calculate the probability of life arising though because even if we did know how it arose here—which we don't exactly—we don't know all the possible different ways it can arise, which may or may not also be a number raised to a large power.
We can't, but we can assume that any process that arises from a series of unlikely chained events (where the likelihood of each event are not correlated) will most likely occur near to the latest time possible. For example, if you run a trillion parallel 10-step chained experiments over a year starting at Jan 1 where each step is very unlikely to occur so that only 100 reach step 10, then the last steps are all likely to occur in December. The less likely each step is (or the more steps involved) then the more the experiments that reach the final step will cluster towards Dec 31. If you have a group of such events then you can actually calculate the likelihood of the chain series.
Intelligent life in a large universe is a similar to this imaginary experiment. While we only have one observed data point, we do know how close the appearance of intelligent life on earth is to the last possible time that it could occur. Outside of our geologically recent anthropogenic boost to the CO2 in the atmosphere, the long term trend of CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere is down (this is due to the sun becoming warmer over time requiring CO2 to be removal from the atmosphere to keep earth in the habitable temperature range). We are in geological terms close to the point where any further removal of CO2 will mean photosynthesis will no longer work (plants are already CO2 limited) - maybe a few 10 millions years. In geological time this is very close to our Dec 31.
What does this all mean? Basically it appears humans have evolved close to the latest time point possible. While we can't calculate the exact probability of intelligent life arising in the universe from our one example, we can say that the evolution of humans is consistent with the hypothesis that the evolution of any intelligent life in the universe is very unlikely.
- dennisgorelik 12y agoWhy do you think that current CO2 concentration levels are important for intelligent life? Slight adjustment in how body works can easily adapt organism to new CO2 levels.
- danieltillett 12y agoI did explain it in my post, but maybe it was too short. Earth has been kept in the habitable temperature zone over the last 3.5 billion years through falling CO2 levels. Around 3.5 billion years ago the sun provided ~25% less energy than now and the CO2 levels were much higher. This is the green house effect. As the sun got brighter over time the level of CO2 in the atmosphere has fallen. For more on this see the slow carbon cycle [1]. The problem is that the level of CO2 in the atmosphere is getting very low (~0.2%). At this level plants are starved for CO2 - if it gets down to 0.01% then plants can't grow at all and the ecosystem needed to support the evolution of intelligent life would collapse. 1. http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/CarbonCycle/page2.php http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/CarbonCycle/page2....
- dennisgorelik 12y agoSo some CO2 is needed for plants. It does not make certain CO2 levels a requirement for intelligent life. Change in temperature does not necessarily kill intelligent life either.
- sampo 12y agoAt least for the foreseeable future, we still need plants and natural ecosystems to survive on Earth.
- danieltillett 12y agoPhotosynthesis is required for the evolution of intelligent life. The point I was making is that intelligent life has evolved on Earth pretty close to the latest time possible.
- sampo 12y agoC4 photosynthesis is an adaptation to higher temperatures and lower atmospheric CO2. And C4 is a very recent innovation (25 to 32 million years ago, says Wikipedia). But yeah, I don't know if even the C4 plants could handle 0.01% ambient CO2.