3 ms·
[Disclaimer: I am indirectly affiliated with Mozilla - I'm also an UX dev in addition to a programmer] I don't just remember Android 2.0: I have an HTC Desire
by scrollaway 12y ago
[Disclaimer: I am indirectly affiliated with Mozilla - I'm also an UX dev in addition to a programmer]
I don't just remember Android 2.0: I have an HTC Desire phone running it (it can't upgrade any further due to its limited hard drive space).
First impressions are awful: The Flame feels slow and extremely unpolished (the stretching is ridiculous, no progress bars in the system updates and other places, hard-to-find text-only buttons, missing fade-out effects...). The screenshot gesture/keybind that triggers almost every time I unlock the phone. Confusing wording all over the place. Performance issues everywhere, even on the lock screen and camera, etc etc.
These are just some the ones I gathered in the first couple of hours. I stopped writing them down... and I stopped using the phone altogether after two days. I wanted, I really wanted to contribute to it but the amount of basic UX issues made me feel like there is little QA/UX being done at all.
My FOSS time is limited. I have a job in FOSS, and I do LXQt work in my off time (in addition to personal project). Being put in front of Firefox OS made me feel like what you guys needed were more full-time UX devs on it, not an assorted basket of contributions. This is why it felt very hopeless to me.
This was a couple of months ago. I have to admit I did not update since, the phone just went unused. Upgrading it is on my TODO some time in the next few months, unless you tell me things radically improved since.
- hardwaresofton 12y agoDo you know what version you were running? There was a recently an upgrade to 2.0, and I have to say that it is pretty amazing. Definitely a lot better than 1.3. They went a drastically different way with the home screen (I say drastic, but they basically went from horizontal scroll to vertical scroll, but that's a pretty drastic UX change), and I think the UI is much better and much more consistent.
- zbraniecki 12y agoWhich version are you describing? As I said, I use "nightly" 2.2 and it is drastically different experienxe (altough still fairly raw) than 1.3/1.4. I used android G1 (same as your dream). Do you claim it was smoother? Faster? More polished?
- scrollaway 12y agoNightly from october or so. I believe it's the 2.x branch.
- throwawaymsft 12y agoMozilla, if you're listening, please take this as feedback on how to improve the QA/user acceptance tests. Even if v2.0 is better, v1.0 shouldn't have shipped to the public in this condition. Another dev who desperately wanted to use your phone couldn't. Users experiencing these types of issues in 2014, when the alternative is silky smooth phones, is negative word of mouth. The expectations around phones have changed and it isn't 2006. I wish you luck.
- scrollaway 12y agoI think you put it very well: The expectations have changed, and while Android had rough starts, it also had the benefit of the doubt and of a completely new field (there was just ios then, and it too was very primitive!). In LXQt, as desktop environment devs, just because the software we create is alpha, users don't expect things to look and feel like windows 95. They expect something modern right off the bat, and we should integrate our own previous experiences on all the other systems that did what we're doing. I think because of that, we have an advantage.. and so should Firefox OS.