4 ms·
Six Pictures of Paradise
- lui8906 12y agoWhat a beautiful article.
- VieElm 12y agoIt's interesting to me that the author spent years looking at these photos and wrote a very long article about them and still doesn't seem to understand the photographs. I think I spent less than a minute before I at least I think I got something more out of it than what the author saw. I could be totally misunderstanding the author though. All the reasons Nigel gives for what makes those photos interesting miss the point I think. > "although any of us could have taken those pictures, only one person actually did" > "Just knowing that these scenes aren’t the most beautiful places along the trail system provokes a rush of tenderness for that forest. It’s the same thing I feel looking at pictures of my wife caught unaware she’s being photographed, when she looks ordinary instead of radiant." > "reducing each of Struth’s photographs to a list of the plant species it contained and some observations on the successional state of the forest. " I notice this miss the point on artsy/literary stuff happens a lot when talking to other engineers. It's like there's a blindness that some can't seem to overcome. To see the pictures in another way, the keyword here used in the article was "complexity". Look at one, and image this wasn't a photograph at all. Imagine it if were an abstract painting, like a pollock painting. Forget about the forest, and that there are plants in it, just focus a little bit less and look at the lines. The author is looking at all the wrong details. Struth here seems to care about the tangle of lines, the massive dark structures contrasting with the little bits of tiny complex jumbles. I'd guess the best I could do is to say to an engineer, try to write a program that generates patterns like this. What would that look like? These aren't photos of randomness, there is complex, sophisticated architecture in these plants trying to fight for scraps of light. It's humbling and in a way reminds me of other types of structures in nature like the superstructures in the cosmos, like the CfA2 Great Wall[1]. Try and focus out a little, like I said, try and see it as a painting. Turn off the forest, and then if you get it, turn it back on, because context is important. A good analogy here might be the 3D Stereograms that were popular in the 90's. Some people looked at those things and couldn't see the 3D (I often couldn't) but would say they see something. [1] http://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full/2004/31/aa0696/img12.gif http://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full/2004/31/aa0696/img12.g...
- qopp 12y agoIt's hard to know with certainly exactly what the photographer was thinking (without asking them). I personally think it's a good point that a lot of pictures that are famous/considered visually interesting are of grandiose locations and subject matter while here we have artistically strong photographs of "common/boring" spots. Regardless of what the photographer intended, it's an mildly interesting thought.
- Nav_Panel 12y agoI agree with this post, and I think a lot of other HN readers would as well if they saw the context of Struth's work. I did a quick Google images search and found a few of his other works: http://classes.dma.ucla.edu/Fall13/173/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/thomas-struth.png http://classes.dma.ucla.edu/Fall13/173/wp-content/uploads/20... http://www.contemporaryartdaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/2009_PHARMACEUTICAL_PACKAGING__LABORATORIOS_PHOENIX__BUENOS_AIRES_2009_1500.jpeg http://www.contemporaryartdaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/... http://www.contemporaryartdaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/13552Struth-Ulsan2.jpg http://www.contemporaryartdaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/... Comparing these to the Paradise series, all exhibit the a similar sense of visual complexity, as discussed by VieElm. However, these photographs are not necessarily of "mundane objects" -- city skylines are commonly photographed. This leads me to believe that Struth's interest is in the visual appeal rather than an interest in "the obvious." Despite this, I liked the article. Well written and thought-provoking.
- minikomi 12y agoI was immediately reminded of Kanemura Osamu's rather pointed search for complexity amongst Tokyo's backstreets - many taken while he was working as a newspaper delivery boy. https://www.google.com/search?q=kanemura+osamu&espv=2&biw=1259&bih=1346&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=TwSdVP1-o82bBZmIgcAO&ved=0CAYQ_AUoAQ https://www.google.com/search?q=kanemura+osamu&espv=2&biw=12...
- wonnage 12y agoHaving art explained to you is like having a joke explained... now you "get" it, but that's beside the point.
- jacquesm 12y agoThat's a beautiful article and as apt an illustration of the proverb not seeing the wood for the trees as I've ever read.
- danieltillett 12y agoI have always been fascinated that people consider tropical rainforests "paradise". They are one of the most difficult places to live with the heat, humidity, disease, and dangerous flora and fauna. Fascinating places, but in my mind far from paradise.
- mkramlich 12y agovisually they seem like paradise. full practical reality: no. the ideal we should seek would have the best of both worlds.
- danieltillett 12y agoYes. The closest I have ever experienced are the islands of the South Pacific. You get the same lush vegetation, but with pleasant temperatures and few of the nasty critters. Some of the Cook Islands are a very nice :)
- percept 12y ago"...all of us were burning to write up whatever we learned in some technical journal that, years later, an associate professor might glance at on his coffee break."
- interesting_guy 12y agodoes anybody else get slightly aroused when they see/go to a forest? [serious]
- potench 12y agoI only see four photos (3 inline and 1 in the header). I'm on mobile safari. Where are the other 2?