4 ms·
[DELETED, wait for an official company response or canary update]
by StavrosK 12y ago
[DELETED, wait for an official company response or canary update]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 12y agoThat's pointless. It's like allowing an alarm to ring without cause. Next time it rings the canary won't be trusted until you personally vouch for the fact that it wasn't an accident, and if that's the new channel the canary has lost its value. False alarms are lethal for something as important as this. Sorry...
- spacefight 12y agoThat's what I exactly tried to convince the parent before and I even got downvoted for it. So it sure looks like, someone has to explain everyone here why Silent Circle has a warrant canary and how we should interpret it....
- jacquesm 12y agoI suspect you got downvoted more because of the tone than because of your intended message. But don't sweat it, I got downvoted more than once in this thread too. What matters is that silentcircle realizes that missing such self-imposed deadlines is something that matters and that everybody is on the same page. Shouting 'you don't have a clue' and 'resign' doesn't help at all, when clearly it is mostly a matter of interpretation.
- StavrosK 12y agoI'm not trying to tell you that it's okay that this happened, I just saw this post while waiting for a deployment and figured I'd comment. Now I'm kind of regretting that.
- jacquesm 12y agoI'm sure you're aware of why it is called a canary, but on the off chance that you or anybody else reading this is not: It's a reference to mine gas detecting canaries, the canary would die when an otherwise invisible gas was present which would kill the people later than it would kill the canary. So when the canary keeled over it was well past the time to leave the mine pronto. Now that your canary is dead you are going to have a hard time to revive it for that particular entity, silentcircle is - as far as I'm concerned - dead. From now on you'd have to assume the site has been compromised and any remarks by you or others that there is nothing going on here should be interpreted as having been coerced. See, if you were outside of the reach of LE then you could have done without the canary to begin with, the fact that you decided to set it up means that you are essentially saying: 'my words can't be trusted, but you can monitor the canary, if it ever fails that's the clue that something is going on which I can not reveal'. That signal has now gone off and I have no clue how you could put the genie back into the box without a time machine.
- StavrosK 12y agoIn my PERSONAL opinion, I see the canary as something saying "this is the last time we were known secure". If it gets updated, then things are fine. If this weren't the intended use, they'd have archiving systems so you could go back and see if someone missed an update. Then again, I don't know if the US can make you lie and coerce you to sign the canary. If so, then what you say makes sense.
- jacquesm 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary "If the canary has not been updated in the time period specified by the host, users are to assume that the host has been served with such a subpoena." That seems pretty clear to me.
- StavrosK 12y agoSure. The question is what happens when it starts getting updated again. If a LEA can't force you to update it, the only reasonable explanation is that there was an unrelated failure in updating it, and that everything is fine after all.
- rsync 12y ago"That's pointless. It's like allowing an alarm to ring without cause. Next time it rings the canary won't be trusted until you personally vouch for the fact that it wasn't an accident, and if that's the new channel the canary has lost its value." That's not really true. The canary is only "dead" and that channel is only useless until a new one is published. Unless the operator of the canary has decreed in advance that a particular time period elapsed should be considered "dead" regardless of future updates, then the canary is alive and well as soon as a new update comes out. Here's the thing - a warrant canary is, by definition, a manual process. It should never be automated. A human has to resign and republish (or they are doing it wrong). And this means that sometimes they get published late. In the 9 years that we (rsync.net) have been publishing our canary, we've probably missed our normal Monday morning publish 10 or 15 times. But as soon as we publish, with the affirmative canary and it's signature and language, etc., it's alive and well again. Obviously this changes if someone is months late with an update.
- spacefight 12y ago"Obviously this changes if someone is months late with an update." That's what I was asking before - what is a reasonable timeslot for being "late"? Is it "months" or "weeks" or the <deltaManualUpdateT+1d> of canary x? In this case, SC was almost 3 times their weekly update rate late (December 5th to December 25th).
- rsync 12y agoWhen we have been late, it's been 8-12 hours. Once it gets to weeks, I think something else is going on.
- jacquesm 12y agoThat's pretty accurate. So now you need to figure out what a reasonable time is. Once you get public postings about your canary being dead without having made an update it is in beyond repair territory for me. A day late, maybe. More than the normal interval between updates late: too late. In between: debatable, but not looking good either. It's like making a promise and then not keeping that promise. By how much did you miss your Monday morning deadlines? Did you ever go a whole week without an update? Is someone tasked with doing it and someone else tasked with checking that it has been done (which is the way this should be set up, preferably with more than one person for the second role backed up with an automated process that sends out messages of impending aviary demise).
- late2part 12y agoI'd like to see a cryptographically signed assertion on this forum that says that the company has not been compromised by a foreign government entity, that you have not been served by an NSL from the US or similar from another country, and that Silent Circle "simply" forgot to update. I don't care for all this "I'm 99% sure" and "blah bah bah." Make an affirmative assertion, and back it up, please.
- StavrosK 12y agoThen you should wait for an official response. I never said I'm in charge of the canary (I specifically said I'm not) or that I know what happened or why, I just happened to see this and tried to get some more info. My comments here shouldn't be taken as official at all.
- jacquesm 12y agoThat completely defeats the purpose of the canary. If you trust cryptographically signed assertions over the canary it had no reason to exist in the first place.
- late2part 12y agoGood point. I Don't suggest the assertion would refute the inferences from the canary death, but I'd like to see some non-repudiable assertion, as it would lead them to make some position. All this non-sense about their "offices being closed" is just silly. My conclusion is that they've lost the trust of the public, and their reputation and credibility is tarnished, perhaps irreperably.