4 ms·
So what Kept the Bolsheviks from becoming an economic empire, after all it was the same land Germany would try to use for its economic powerhouse. I mean very
by mc32 12y ago
So what Kept the Bolsheviks from becoming an economic empire, after all it was the same land Germany would try to use for its economic powerhouse. I mean very productive land, lots of mineral resources... obviously the Germans saw it that way. Still to this day, Russia underdelivers, given its vast resources --natural and human/intellectual.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoDecades of trying to keep up with the US militarily at the expense of everything else.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- alricb 12y agoWell, it's probable that, Hitler being Hitler, his plan wouldn't have worked in reality. So long as Britain controlled the sea, a "super-Germany" would have been at a serious disadvantage relative to the historical US, which did a lot of trade by sea. As for why the USSR didn't turn into the US, it's probably related to poor economic organization, too much resources put into the military, too little international trade, and a dependency on primary resources like oil, with all those factors and others interacting in fun ways.
- vacri 12y agoThe trade is a big one - one of the reasons for the recent annexation of Crimea by Russia is to give Russia another deep-water port. They have surprisingly little viable coastline given their size. The other thing is that the US sits on very wealthy land that's in the temperate zone. Large amounts of Russia is difficult to access and the viable parts spend more of the year affected by bad weather. You can even see it in the national stereotypes - the US citizen wears a t-shirt and jeans, the Russian citizen wears an ushanka and heavy coat. Similarly, once the US conquered the west, it was in a situation where there was no real credible military threat bordering it - it could afford to shift more defence spending to power projection rather than home defence. It's not to say political ideologies had nothing to do with the differences in success stories, just that ideology alone is not responsible.
- alexqgb 12y ago"A moat the size of two oceans."
- frozenport 12y agoRussia has its own expansion story, moving eastward to get Siberia, but unlike the US west, there wasn't much there except for the Japanese.
- iaejpiejf23 12y ago> I mean very productive land, lots of mineral resources... It wasn't productive like the US territory was. It was mostly inhospitable tundra. The bolsheviks weren't an economic superpower for the same reason the canadians aren't. > Still to this day, Russia underdelivers, given its vast resources --natural and human/intellectual. Russia is the 8th largest economy in the world.
- mc32 12y agoWell, compare Russia to Japan or SKorea, or Taiwan, or the UK.
- iaejpiejf23 12y agoJapan, SKorea, Taiwan and the UK have the benefit of living in pax americana and being an ally of america. It has access to all the resources they need... Russia's problem is that their vast territory is also their achilles heel. They stole land from japan and skorea and every other nation on its border. China, germany, turkey, ukraine, iran, mongolia, etc... Their land is a blessing AND a curse. Russia can't fully trade with china or japan because of territorial issues. So they didn't fully capitalize on japan's economic miracle. And now they aren't fully capitalizing on china's economic miracle. Politics and power are an unforgiving discipline. If russia keeps missing out on opportunities and keeps falling behind, the russian empire is going to collapse. Doesn't matter how many nukes they have or now powerful they think they are. What separates the US and russia is this. After ww2, russia stole a bunch of islands from japan and annexed it. That's why japan and russia still haven't signed a peace treaty. The US returned okinawa. We didn't steal it so we can have normal relations with japan.
- mc32 12y agoI don't know. Some of those countries have minimal natural resources and small fractions of the pop of Russia yet, they enjoy relatively disproportionate economic success. Maybe you have a point, but it's not the whole point. I think they wear a heavy shackle of ancient culture. One which has acclimatized them over centuries to a serf-state mindset they have not broken out of. It's very patriarchal (or statist). The state is their master in more ways than one. It'll take a cultural shift in the newer generations to shake it and allow them to achieve their potential.
- finid 12y ago> Still to this day, Russia underdelivers, given its vast resources --natural and human/intellectual. That makes it sound as if Russia and the former USSR are one and the same. They're not. A better way to restate that sentence is, "The USSR under delivered, in spite of its vast resources - natural and human/intellectual." And you don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure out why. In an atmosphere where fear and uncertainty rules, individual and group creativity suffers. Russia is doing better in that area, though there's still a lot of room for improvement. But it is a young country. Some old habits from the former USSR still lingers, which is expected given that most of the current leadership grew up in the former USSR. It take at least one generation to shake bad habits.
- mattmcknight 12y ago"In an atmosphere where fear and uncertainty rules, individual and group creativity suffers." Some would suggest it was the lack of incentives to independently pursue success. There's little point in working hard to get ahead if it is going to be taken from you.
- zurn 12y agoPresent day Russia is very much a laissez faire capitalist society. Money and power are pretty liquid, taxes are low, and self-interest is everybody's assumed motive. Perfect system of incentives, no? (This is why the political scene is so hard to decipher, nobody in russia pays any attention to the stated aims or motives and conspiracy theories are the default mindset)
- dsq 12y agoNo independent court system, no independent media, no freedom of expression, completely corrupt police force, extreme alcoholism...these are disincentives
- aminok 12y agoWithout an effective police and judiciary, you can't be secure in your person or property, and end up paying an informal tax to organized criminal elements and corrupt police, so no, Russia is still not laissez faire.