3 ms·
> I think, however, that a basic income should be enough to live, but not enough to live comfortably without savings, another source of income, or cooperation.
by bane 12y ago
> I think, however, that a basic income should be enough to live, but not enough to live comfortably without savings, another source of income, or cooperation.
So here's the heart of the BI argument:
Define "comfortably"
Why is your definition correct?
> without savings
Why bother? I'm already earning a living doing nothing?
I don't need to save anything, more money will come. I don't need to worry about retirement, more money will come when I'm too old to work.
I'm going to just throw this out there, I'm guessing if I'm getting UBI I'm probably getting free healthcare. So I don't need to save for that.
Outside of a grand assumption that UBI will somehow propel everybody to the top of Maslow's Hierarchy and enough people will just somehow "self actualize" (despite all evidence to the contrary) and continue to work and support all the lazy layabouts living off the dole, what exactly is the reason I or anybody receiving the UBI would bother working?
- dllthomas 12y agoWhat you wrote here sounds like you skimmed my post for things to argue with, rather than actually reading my post. It's far enough off point I'm not going to bother responding to it. I know you can do better - I've seen it.
- bane 12y agoI'm supposing you're taking umbrage at my ignoring your point about conditional vs. unconditional BI?
- dllthomas 12y agoNot at all. What set me off the most is "But why bother [saving]?" The entire point of the passage from which you drew the reference to saving to recommend keeping the BI low enough to preserve enough of a benefit from working or having saved. Obviously, people would bother if they want that benefit in the future without working, and if people choose not to save that doesn't actually undermine anything I said.
- bane 12y agoI'm sorry, I'm having a brain fart, are you saying that people would save as a mechanism to ensure the BI stay low? I'm not sure people in aggregate think that abstractly. Though I will say there's lots of evidence that people's personal microeconomic decisions are impacted by macroeconomic conditions so...
- dllthomas 12y agoThat's still not what I'm trying to say, no... Look at how I referenced saving. I said that BI should stay low, and that a comfortable life should be derived from "BI plus something" - with drawing down savings being one possibility. What motivates working people to save, in that context, is the hope of maintaining a higher standard of living in the future when they work less (or on something unpaid) or in the face of adversity. We probably shouldn't expect people receiving only the BI to be saving much - I don't know how that factors into the broader scheme of things, but it doesn't seem to have much impact on anything I was talking about. In terms of a mechanism (beyond advocacy) for keeping BI sufficiently low: I'd propose (tentatively) pegging inflation adjustment to targeted inflation rather than actual inflation. If the BI is high enough that more people stop working than we can afford, wages and prices will rise and the real BI will fall.
- bane 12y agoSorry, didn't mean to be extraordinarily dense. I think the counter argument is the present state of things. It's not too terribly hard to do small things, none of which are secret, to improve your value and demand higher pay: go to school, get certifications, build up experience, ask for more money, better financial management, etc. Yet still most people in low-end jobs don't do these things. Anecdotally, I have very frustrating conversations with my own family members and several close friends, who never made it out of being poor, and simply refuse to follow advice on how to improve their lot, then endlessly call me up to complain about how they don't have money. A few of them have even had extraordinary opportunities come up to go to school for free or otherwise improve their situation and simply choose not to do it. When I think of poor outcomes from BI schemes, I think of my family and friends, who simply would stop working, but wouldn't put their time to other productive or value growing opportunities. Or would continue working as is, but BI would simply be an inflation driver and would result in less effective income from their labor.
- sologoub 12y agoThe sad situation is that most American's don't have nearly enough saved for retirement and most never will. That's why social security actually exists and it's not that great for those that end-up depending solely on that type of income. Essentially, we already have the situation you described without any of the other benefits BI would bring. Here's another HuffPo article that has some very disturbing figures on this: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/10/27/die-than-retire-poor_n_6042682.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/10/27/die-than-retire-poo.... If the given individual is ok with the standard of living BI offers, there is no need to do extra work. That's kind of the point. On the flip side, if the person wants more luxuries or spending power, he or she will stay in the workforce, either working part-time or full-time. The amount of work and effort a person will need to exert will depend on how much better than the base he or she wants to live. BI will undoubtedly result in some inflation, but if managed properly, will prevent poverty as we know it today. Of course poverty in US today is nothing like poverty in the middle ages Europe, so one day people will look at living on BI alone as living in poverty. It's all in degrees of better or worse. The benefit of BI is that people no longer live in fear of their world collapsing completely if they lose their employment. Today in US, for most people if you lose employment you also lose healthcare. Obamacare is still not there to truly act as a safety net. (Speaking from family member experience.) With BI, the unemployment rate becomes a lot less important, because so long as the capital streams are flowing and proper taxation is in place, consumption won't collapse beyond the minimum level afforded by BI. In the end, I still believe people will continue to work regardless of BI. Some will drop-out, but enough will stay. It's about empowering personal choice.
- bane 12y agoWhat you and every other BI advocate simply ignores (I don't even know why I'm wasting my breath on this) is that people who remain in the labor pool will not necessarily realize benefits from staying in the pool. Increasingly, they will be supporting more and more people who choose not to join the pool. The percentage of money they earn that they actually get to keep will grow less and less because more of it is going out to pay for people who aren't working. Eventually, a rational actor in the labor pool will ask themselves, "why bother?", and will drop out as well. It's a vicious cycle, not a virtuous one. A working person in a universal BI scheme is not earning BI + a normal job earnings, they're earning BI + job earning - cost to provide BI for non-productive people. It's that simple and BI advocacy circles continue to refuse to produce an economic model that even acknowledges this simple truism let alone demonstrates how efficient the remaining workers need to be to both cover their increasingly non-working fellows and gain any benefits worth working for. More likely, and what usually happens in schemes where earned labor value earned is separated from labor input is that laborers become disincentivized. People who wish to work would simply stop working in the formal economy and maximize value capture by working in an underground economy. This creates a negative feedback cycle as fewer and fewer people take part in the formal economy (where the government can capture and redistribute their production to people who aren't). This rapidly bankrupts the scheme and turns labor into a punitive action by the state. "We need workers producing capturable value, therefore you must work" and the point of BI is quickly lost. BI advocates are unable to demonstrate why this isn't simply true and why every single time labor is disentangled from incentives the system goes bankrupt except with the vaguest possible handwaivy nonsense and pronouncements that it simply won't happen under their particular version of the scheme because of no particular reasons at all except for wishes and dreams. And then Mincome is usually brought up somewhere. BI models must account for labor drop-out, must account for how this disincentives the remaining labor pool and reduces value capture within the labor pool. "Empowering personal choice" is not a valid model. "Some will drop-out, but enough will stay." is not a model. How many, what percent? Why that percent? What's the impact of various drop-out rates on various actor models? How much does production need to increase on the remaining labor pool to maintain equilibrium? Is that achievable? What happens to purchasing power when most products become effectively free? What about maintaining growth at x,y and z percentages? If new money supply is introduced to compensate, what impact does this have on inflation? What's the delta from the best-case model to the worst-case? How are both of those extreme models justified by observed and predicted actor behavior? What compensation levers does the government have to incentivize labor participation? What's the degree of input in each and the known and/or expected outcomes? How does each lever's outputs change the previous questions output? I've never even seen so much as an Excel spreadsheet that models the simplest question I've put here. What happens when drop-out is 5%, 10%, 20%, 50%, 70%? Is the proposed BI scheme sustainable? Why or why not? What happens in an unsustainable system? Can unsustainable systems be "fixed" and brought back into sustainability? By what means? What happens if there's not full local/national/regional/global participation? How does the scheme compensate for imperfect participation? Has this compensation plan been modeled and tested under previously identified circumstances? If the system becomes unsustainable, what does failure look like? Can hard failures be corrected? How do we adjust to bring unskilled out-of-labor-pool people back into the labor pool in the event of a lack of sustainment and eventual failure? The modeling isn't hard, it's just tedious and it has to be done or BI will continue to be the butt of economic jokes. BI needs a body of real thought behind it, not hand-waivy well wishing. It needs a cumulative and unimpeachable story to show that it really is a better idea than the ideas we're working off of now. But BI doesn't offer any of that. It offers wishes and naive hopeful dreams of a global population suddenly achieving self-actualization all at once. It's a nice picture, but anybody can write any sort of Utopian fantasy fiction that makes any sort of crazy idea sound workable. Here's one: - We all need underwear - Let's all make underwear - I've solved supply-demand issues, monetary imbalance, underwear shortages and brought about a golden utopia for all time. The numbers must work out. Math cannot be fudged by our personal feelings. I've seen HVAC system with better planning documents than any BI scheme. It's absolutely exhausting to keep explaining this. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8794247 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8794247