5 ms·
Right, I personally find it exhausting how this experiment keeps getting raised up as the gold standard for basic income policy. Mincome is a terrible data poin
by bane 12y ago
Right, I personally find it exhausting how this experiment keeps getting raised up as the gold standard for basic income policy. Mincome is a terrible data point for basic income advocates.
> A needs based system results in fear of losing what little you have. Low income housing in extremely desirable areas works in similar manner and traps people, instead of incentivizing them to seek higher paid employment because that higher pay will make them not qualified for the subsidy, yet not able to afford the area.
Ding ding ding! Mincome is not much different than a restructured welfare program, not a basic income program. At best it's a Partial Basic Income scheme, which is more or less what we have as welfare/benefits today.
Basic Income programs guarantee a minimum standard of living, which Mincome did not. Mincome guaranteed a below poverty level standard of living, which then required people to continue working. It's just like getting a few dollars per hour raise. If this happened for everybody in the economy, it'd just be called inflation and standards of living would remain about the same after adjustment.
To put Mincome into perspective, the amount it paid is about what you get from Social Security (in the U.S.) without retirement savings or investment plans. Ask any retired person living on a fixed income of solely Social Security income how they get on.
Island economics are poor predictors for global economic effects. And any workable UBI scheme has to assume two things:
1) Most of the workforce would drop out and enjoy the minimal, but completely free standard of living it affords them.
2) Labor (which provides the input capital for the UBI scheme) thus becomes punitive. Each person working is supporting multiple people who aren't. Rational actors won't do that (exacerbating #1 above), so to get anybody working, there has to be a forcing mechanism to get them into the labor pool.
- tbrake 12y agoYour first assumption is a needlessly pessimistic view of the quality/quantity of intrinsic motivation in most people. By the same token something like "most people would drop out and enjoy the freedom of pursuing their passions, working on what they enjoy and spurring smaller scale local economies etc" might be equally naively optimistic, but I don't think the truth is at either extreme.
- jeffdavis 12y agoIs intrinsic motivation something everyone is born with? Or does it need to be learned and reinforced with positive outcomes? One potential problem is that people may never really develop an intrinsic motivation to work if they aren't given a push early on. Basic Income may eliminate that first push, which I think is crucial. Let's say you are 16. If you get a job, the expectations are low and your needs are low, so you take the first thing to come along. That puts you in a mild discomfort that encourages you to seek better opportunities as they come along, and you are likely to develop a strong intrinsically a motivated work ethic. With Basic Income, your needs are already met, so it's easy to rationalize it away and just say you'll get a job after you graduate from college. By then, the expectations are much higher and your needs are much higher, so you hold out for a better job that may never come because you have no experience. So, you just stay in your comfort zone forever.
- Retra 12y ago>Is intrinsic motivation something everyone is born with? Or does it need to be learned and reinforced with positive outcomes? Um... If it needs to be reinforced, then it is extrinsic motivation. That's pretty much the definition of 'extrinsic'. >people may never really develop an intrinsic motivation to work What is 'work?' Aren't most people happy to sit around socializing? Aren't people happy to sit around posting their thoughts on online forums? Why isn't this work? It produces value. >So, you just stay in your comfort zone forever. I guess suffering is what makes life great, then? What is the goal here, if not to let people be comfortable forever? What is the point of having a discussion when you throw out the basic premise? I could make a very strong argument that regularly beating one's children is the best way to raise them, and rationalize all day long with statistics and claims about how reward and punishment are obvious common-sense drives for human behavior. But at the end of the day, it's those beaten children who make the world a worse place, so what good does it really do? If the goal is to have a world where children aren't being beaten, then surely beating children is not a reliable way to achieve that. So what is the problem your argument is trying to solve?
- sologoub 12y ago
- dllthomas 12y agoThis is a little rambly, but... The fact that it wasn't unqualified is hugely important. I think you're not too far off in knock-on effects if we implement too high a basic income, and for the record I think the Swiss proposal runs significant risk of being too high (although I welcome the experiment). I think, however, that a basic income should be enough to live, but not enough to live comfortably without savings, another source of income, or cooperation. One thing to bear in mind, regarding poverty levels, is that there's a tremendous difference between having $X while working 60 hours a week, and having $X while putting that same effort into living better.
- bane 12y ago> I think, however, that a basic income should be enough to live, but not enough to live comfortably without savings, another source of income, or cooperation. So here's the heart of the BI argument: Define "comfortably" Why is your definition correct? > without savings Why bother? I'm already earning a living doing nothing? I don't need to save anything, more money will come. I don't need to worry about retirement, more money will come when I'm too old to work. I'm going to just throw this out there, I'm guessing if I'm getting UBI I'm probably getting free healthcare. So I don't need to save for that. Outside of a grand assumption that UBI will somehow propel everybody to the top of Maslow's Hierarchy and enough people will just somehow "self actualize" (despite all evidence to the contrary) and continue to work and support all the lazy layabouts living off the dole, what exactly is the reason I or anybody receiving the UBI would bother working?
- dllthomas 12y agoWhat you wrote here sounds like you skimmed my post for things to argue with, rather than actually reading my post. It's far enough off point I'm not going to bother responding to it. I know you can do better - I've seen it.
- bane 12y agoI'm supposing you're taking umbrage at my ignoring your point about conditional vs. unconditional BI?