4 ms·
If we think (EDIT: or know) jurors are dumb enough to be swayed by superimposing the word "GUILTY" over a mugshot, what's the point of jury trials? All of this
by humanrebar 12y ago
If we think (EDIT: or know) jurors are dumb enough to be swayed by superimposing the word "GUILTY" over a mugshot, what's the point of jury trials?
All of this sound and fury about PowerPoint seems like a bunch of melodrama. We live in a visual age. Normal people do not routinely attend live theater or listen to lectures anymore.
On the other hand, if you're reading it, it's for you. Maybe the point of the article was to get me to be irked about arbitrary courtroom rules. If so, mission accomplished.
EDIT: I added an edit above, clearly marked, to allow you to respond on the interesting points (why jury trials? when are images unfair?) and ignore topics that are less interesting to me, such as "how much is everyone else a mindless sheep?"
- quesera 12y agoAnd yet.. Advertising works -- at least partially by mechanisms that do not belong in jury trials.
- humanrebar 12y agoWhat exactly are the mechanisms that do not belong in jury trials? What in concept is so bad about attorneys using AV presentations to make their points? If the objection is that the prosecutor is labeling the defendant as guilty, isn't that the job of the prosecutor? And why can't defendants use AV presentations to portray their clients as innocent or point out contradictions by the prosecution?
- msandford 12y agoThe bad part is that prosecutors are generally held in regard in the community while defendants are not. Further things which are written down often seem more factual than things which are spoken. Combine the two and you've seriously un-leveled the playing field between prosecution and defense. And that's before you consider that many defendants don't have the means to pay for their lawyer and thus are represented by overworked, underpaid public defenders.
- _delirium 12y agoFrom a systems-design perspective, the question would be what effect prosecutors using AV presentations in this way has on conviction accuracy. Imo an important design goal of the criminal-justice system is to have a very low rate of false positives, and secondarily a low rate of false negatives. Whether trials should be set up to allow the lawyers to use AV-enhanced presentations is that question that, for me, turns on what effect it has on those statistics.
- bunderbunder 12y ago> If we think jurors are dumb enough to be swayed by superimposing the word "GUILTY" over a mugshot It's not a matter of simply thinking this might be an issue; we know it's an issue. And it's not a matter of being smart or dumb. It's just basic human psychology of the type that you'd likely learn in any introductory course nowadays. There's even a $500bn global industry (advertising) largely built around exploiting these same psychological heuristics. And yes, you're right, that does raise some questions about the validity of the jury trial system. One could quite readily argue (and many do) that a lot of what we've learned about human psychology over the past few decades raises similarly disturbing questions about a great many other aspects of the way we handle criminal justice.
- humanrebar 12y ago> There's even a $500bn global industry (advertising) largely built around exploiting these same psychological heuristics. First, advertising is largely a mass market phenomenon. Spammers only need a small fraction of recipients to click through and give their credit card info. Second, point one aside, isn't advertising undermined by all the churn in the advertising world over the last decade or so? I was under the impression that the question is actively being reevaluated. Perhaps advertising is great at branding (remember us!?) and information (we do this!) but poor at changing minds (now you're buying Androids and not iPhones!). Third, I still don't see what makes these particular examples egregious. If the judge were displaying these images, there would be a problem, but prosecutors aren't supposed to be impartial. And the defense could similarly show photos of the defendant kissing babies, right? Don't both sides do the equivalent in oral arguments already? Why is photo-shopping crossing the line?
- hawleyal 12y agoThe point of jury trials is that it makes us feel better about keeping and torturing prisoners. "We have a system for that" and the fact that it is a committee removes personal responsibility for the effects imposed on the convicted.