3 ms·
Everyone freaks the heck out when Github is down. If you're looking for a github-hosted project, I guess that makes sense. But I don't know if most folks realiz
by KirinDave 17y ago
Everyone freaks the heck out when Github is down. If you're looking for a github-hosted project, I guess that makes sense. But I don't know if most folks realize, if github were to vanish today, you and your friends could quickly and easily continue to work. One of the big value propositions of Git, that GitHub provides as a feature, is flexible configurations for sharing code. Github never locks you in. You just change your remote addresses and continue working like nothing changed.
So many people I talk to seem to believe that Git is kind of like SVN but with better local branching, but it's really not like that at all. Sometimes I joke that GitHub should make people pass a written test on git before being allowed to open private accounts, because so few people seem to know how the system actually works.
Now, I suppose if you depended on the GitHub UI or put files into github's wiki or filestore that you didn't back up somehow, that'd be problematic. But that's also your fault for not having a bit of redundancy.
- Afton 17y agoYou've been downvoted, so I thought I'd provide this feedback. 1. So far, this is the best post for this submission. Seriously, what was the point of submitting this? A blog post by someone talking about why it went down, how to avoid it, blah blah blah, I'd understand. But a point of fact? 2. "Everyone freaks out...". Yeah, normally I'd downvote this too. Does everyone? Do most people? Do most people that use github? I doubt that any of those questions can be truthfully answered 'yes' 3. "but that's also your fault..." Really? I'm expected to mirror github's wiki? If I were hosting a f/oss project there, and using the wiki, I doubt I would. I wouldn't 'freak out' but I can easily imagine circumstances where I'd be annoyed or concerned or embarrassed. TK;DR: the interesting info in your post is hindered by the attempts to score conversational points. Otherwise, good post.
- dlsspy 17y ago> Github never locks you in. That's why I started giving them money the first day they would accept it, but it's not entirely true anymore. The wiki has been the most obvious case for a very long time now. They just need to sit down and fix that. It's rotting both in features and in the "doesn't lock you in" issue. Also, because the content only lives there, it is a bit of an issue for people who actually use the wiki (I tend to avoid it). Not to focus too much on the wiki but it's not... version controlled. sigh Issues have an API, but not hooks, etc... If it at least had a hook, you could mirror the issue tracking off as events occur so that if you needed to, you could provide an alternate view. Other than that I agree with you and work to keep my dependence low (and still give them money because I appreciate most of what they do): http://dustin.github.com/2009/09/06/buildbot-git.html http://dustin.github.com/2009/09/06/buildbot-git.html
- pjhyett 17y agoWe're gonna give the wikis love at some point in the near future, we know they need it.