7 ms·
After a traffic survey, the speed limit of the road is often set to the 85th percentile of speeds that people actually choose to drive on it. I propose that ea
by logfromblammo 12y ago
After a traffic survey, the speed limit of the road is often set to the 85th percentile of speeds that people actually choose to drive on it.
I propose that each genre of copyright-able work be subjected to a statistical analysis, to determine the number of years at which 80% of the total lifetime revenue of a work has been collected. Set the base copyright term for that genre to be the 80th percentile of that number.
So you might see that 80% of fiction novels earn 80% of their revenues within 10 years or less (invented numbers). If that were the case, set the default free copyright term to 10 years. Obviously, some outliers will be late bloomers, so perhaps you make a reasonable accommodation for those by granting renewals that each last 5 years, for a flat fee plus a modest percentage of the earned revenue, which then increases with every renewal.
That would work just fine for the stated purpose of promoting the useful arts. But I suspect that copyright is now also being used for the purpose of eliminating same-owner competition from older works. For instance, why watch the newest Disney animated film when you could watch any of them older than N years? Why play Gameseries 7 when you could also play Gameseries 1 through 6? So perhaps also add a "quashing and abandonment" clause, wherein if the owner refuses or is unable to license or sell copies for N years, the work enters the public domain.
Given those reasonable ideas, I think maybe the founders were just guessing, and they probably didn't guess correctly for 2014.