3 ms·
Dozens of comments here assume that there is an important difference between reflected light that enters the eye and light shining "directly" into the eye. It's
by leephillips 12y ago
Dozens of comments here assume that there is an important difference between reflected light that enters the eye and light shining "directly" into the eye. It's obvious that spectrum, intensity, flicker, and other properties of the light can have an effect on us, but what difference could it possibly make, aside from these factors, whether the light is reflected or "direct"? Why is there an essential difference, everything else being equal, between backlit and frontlit readers?
- dragonwriter 12y agoReflection off anything but a perfect mirror has a significant effect on spectrum, intensity, flicker, and other properties of light. So, given the limited set of available artificial light sources suitable for inclusion in an e-reader (which limit the starting set of options for those properties before considering reflection), even if there is no essential difference in the abstract between reflected and directly-emitted light in terms of the human effect, the effect of those properties likely creates an important difference between practical reflected and direct lighting in e-book reader devices. The comments that assert (not "assume") that there is an important difference between reflected and direct light in portable e-book readers largely expressly note that the difference they are discussing is in that context, and neither assert nor assume a fundamental difference in reflected or emitted light in general. If you could make a back-lit reader that simulated a front-lit reader in all relevant features of the light reaching the eyes, it is obvious (tautological, even) that there would be no difference in the effect that light had -- but in real-world devices, "everything else" isn't equal between front-lit and back-lit devices, and the issue here is the effects of real-world devices, not hypothetical devices that exist only in thought experiments.