5 ms·
Back-lit e-readers 'damage sleep and health,' doctors warn
- dschiptsov 12y agoMeme-science. What about those laptops people staring at for 8 hours/day and those 50" back-lit TVs running 16h/day? Do they contribute to a "health-damage"? To what extend? How do they factor out "stress" from being a subject in a "study" from "stress" of being exposed to deadly back-lit? "Methodology" aside. Let me guess - the "study" has been sponsored by affiliates of e-ink display producers/sellers?
- Raphmedia 12y ago"They spent five days reading from a paperback and five days from an iPad." ... and proceed to show a kindle in the pictures. Of course, the iPad has a screen so it's going to damage your sleep. The refresh rate + bright blue light is bad for you. Why did they need to make a study for that? That's know. What I am wondering is a backlight e-ink display. No refresh rate, and a dim backlight. Now, that's a study that is worth it.
- frik 12y agoI still keep around a few halogen and incandescent light bulbs for the evening. They emit a better light (color temperature) than fluorescent & LED lamps (and contain no hazardous waste). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_temperature http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_temperature
- jaydub 12y agoI'm not changing my habits from a study based on 12 people.
- ekianjo 12y agoGood Man. Unfortunately, lots of piss-poor researchers out there write study reports with very small n sizes, and 12 is not the worst one I have seen.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoHasn't this already be researched quite a lot with Laptops and PC's? I thought it was common knowledge now that the light emitted from those devices would effect your sleep. A sample size of 12 isn't good but I'm sure there are much more comprehensive studies that have already been done on this. I think they're the reason apps like Flux exist.[1] [1] https://justgetflux.com/ https://justgetflux.com/
- oskarth 12y agoIt's a shame https://justgetflux.com/ https://justgetflux.com/ isn't available in the App store. As far as I know you have to jailbreak to install it (so it's not a technical limitation per se). Can anyone think of a good reason why Apple doesn't ship with f.lux like software by default? It's pretty much a necessity for using a computer device at night.
- minikites 12y agoBecause all it does it makes your colors screwy, it doesn't actually help anything?
- scrabble 12y ago"They found it took longer to nod off with a back-lit e-reader, which led to poorer quality sleep and being more tired the next morning." So going to sleep later means you get less sleep and are more tired the next day. This is not a shocking revelation. I'd also be curious what they think about frontlit eReaders as opposed to backlit.
- Cakez0r 12y agoYou stripped the context from the quote... They're not comparing going straight to sleep vs using an before bed e-reader. "A team from Harvard Medical School compared reading paper books and light-emitting e-readers before sleep."
- falcolas 12y agoA bit more important context, by "light-emitting e-readers", they really mean iPads positioned at a fixed distance with a fixed brightness. Feels like a rigged experiment to me, frankly. "I hypothesize that reading on an e-reader has a negative impact on your sleep, let's design a study which shows exactly that."
- gingerlime 12y agoThe key here is "Light Emitting" rather than eBooks. So the title is more than a bit misleading since it's mostly tablets that emit direct light. The experiment specifically used an iPad in comparison with a paper book. Seems odd to generalize it to all eBooks. This article[0] seems to have a more accurate title. [0] http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/12/141222131348.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/12/141222131348.ht...
- Rainymood 12y ago>So the title is more than a bit misleading I already made a comment here some dutch news thing that picked up on this and debunked it. It's weird to see it on HN this late and this upvoted. Technically it's not misleading. Why not? Let's grab Wikipedia's definition: "An e-reader is a mobile electronic device that is designed primarily for the purpose of reading digital e-books and periodicals." e.g. there is being made NO distinction between e-ink displays and normal LED displays (iPad, tablets, screens and the sort). It's kind of misleading because people usually think of e-readers as e-ink display type of e-readers. But this is only a small subset of the 'actual' e-readers. Conclusion? Don't stare at a light emitting screen (iPad, TV, PC) before you go to bed. Read from an e-ink display or a book. I, personally, am still waiting for the day that 60 Hz e-ink PC monitors will be available.
- gingerlime 12y agoThe title on HN was edited. It used to say what the BBC article title still says which is "E-books damage sleep..."
- falcolas 12y agoI think it's fair to say that an iPad was not "designed primarily for the purpose of reading digital e-books and periodicals." Ironically, its size and backlight make it very poor for that purpose, but its ubiquity makes it easier for the iPad to fill the role of the e-reader in addition to its multitude of other roles.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoE-book readers with a backlight 'damage sleep and health'.
- nathanaldensr 12y agoHeadline is definitely a bit click-baity. "Hmm, how can we write a story about how bright lights mess up your body clock, but not make it as boring or mundane? I know, we'll say e-books are the culprit!"
- Cakez0r 12y agoYou know you're reading a quality article when one of the subheadings is literally just (quotation marks and all) 'Concern'
- wwarren 12y agoI prefer the non backlit ones anyway - much more like reading a paper book. I suppose the drawbacks are also the same as paper books in that you need a light to read by
- wlesieutre 12y agoMisleading title, it's reading ebooks on a tablet that's a problem, just like doing anything else at night on a tablet or laptop. Reading ebooks on an ebook reader with an eink screen is fine.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoThe new Kindles (Paperwhite, Voyage) are backlit. If that trend spreads to other e-readers it won't just be a tablet problem. I guess this is a good argument to keep the old style Kindles around.
- RedSocks112 12y agoPaperwhites are not backlit. "Paperwhite guides light toward the surface of the display with its built-in front light—unlike back-lit tablets that shine in your eyes—so you can read comfortably without eyestrain." Source: http://www.amazon.com/Kindle-Paperwhite-Ereader/dp/B00AWH595M http://www.amazon.com/Kindle-Paperwhite-Ereader/dp/B00AWH595... Illustration: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/12/26/technology/light-reading.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/12/26/technology/lig...
- k-mcgrady 12y agoInteresting, thanks for the info. The article specifically calls out 'original Kindles' as being ok which led me to believe the Paperwhite could be an issue - however that might have been referencing the Fire.
- philbarr 12y agoExcept that you can vary the amount of backlight on a paperwhite. Surely that makes a difference?
- erikwiffin 12y agoThe Paperwhite and Voyage are front-lit, not backlit. They should be fine. This article on what I assume was the same study http://arstechnica.com/science/2014/12/e-readers-and-tablets-really-do-seem-to-alter-your-sleep-schedule/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2014/12/e-readers-and-tablets... mentions specifically "iPads, Kindle Fires, and Nook Colors", and also says "A Kindle without a backlight, as you'd expect, only reflected about as much light as a book and had its peak omission in relatively red wavelengths."
- ekianjo 12y ago> Our bodies are kept in tune with the rhythm of day and night by an internal body clock, which uses light to tell the time. That body clock has been completely destroyed the day we started to use lamps and night and even more since we use Electricity. It's fine to say it's bad for your health, but seriously, being exposed to bright light until late at night is nothing new at all. And so far the Human race still endures.
- codyb 12y agoThe point made here is that when you hold a back lit e-reader you're literally staring into the light. Unless you're staring directly into the lights which light your home for long periods of time it appears to be an appreciable difference. However, I had thought back lights were well known for preventing strong sleep cycles before this.
- ekianjo 12y agoHow about TV then ? It's not so popular nowadays but people used to watch TV until they went to sleep, late at night. That was even worse than LCDs or e-Ink backlights.
- codyb 12y agoHmm, maybe it's because of the proximity of the screens? I hadn't considered TV. Interesting point.
- ekianjo 12y agoTVs were much brighter than LCDs and directly throwing electrons at your eyes on top of the emitted light. I can' fathom why they would have been more harmless than a tablet in 2014.
- codyb 12y agoYea, all I can figure is the 14 inch proximity from face. Perhaps the electrons don't matter as much as the relative dispersal of light. When you look at a tv from 8 feet away or so your peripheral vision can generally see a lot of things that aren't blasting light into them. That's not so much the case for me right now staring at my monitor. Pure speculation from a tired man ;-)
- buss 12y agoI asked a friend of mine and Kindle engineer for an amber-hued backlit kindle about six months ago. He thought it was a good idea, so maybe we'll get one in another year or so.
- aw3c2 12y agoFrom the paper itself (highlight mine): > During LE-eBook reading sessions, the light-emitting device was set to maximum brightness and placed in a stand that held it at a fixed angle. This stand was placed on a table directly in front of the individual at a 30- to 45-cm distance from their eyes. Participants were allowed to turn pages on the LE-eBook, but were asked not to hold it while reading or make any adjustments to the settings. During the printed book reading sessions, participants were allowed to hold the book at any desired distance from their eyes. Is this anything new anyways? Shining bright blueish light into people's eyes before bedtime has got to be a well researched topic already. This feels like media-tailored hype while a simple "yes, back-lit ebook readers use this kind of light so those existing findings apply" would have sufficed.
- mgiannopoulos 12y agoBad science combined with terrible reporting from the BBC where "light emitting e-book readers" become in the headline "e-books"...
- oalders 12y agoOn my laptop, I've been using f.lux [0] to prevent the bright monitor lighting from keeping me too alert late into the night. It took me a while to get accustomed to the hues, but I really like the way the light softens as the evening progresses. [0] https://justgetflux.com/ https://justgetflux.com/
- nsxwolf 12y agoI love f.lux. It would be nice if you could run it on iOS without jailbreaking.
- kordless 12y agoThis is one of those comments we'll look back on in 30 years and say "what the hell were we thinking letting a company control our devices like that?".
- minikites 12y agoDo you miss the days where you had to manually adjust the choke while driving and decoke the engine every few thousand miles? I think we're going to look back on computers of the 90s and 2000s with a similar quaintness. More people care about a bullshit-free computing experience than an abstract concept of "freedom".
- nsxwolf 12y agoYeah but when we can't make the computers do what we want it is a problem.
- ay1n 12y agoI think it's not a true comparison - freedom to modify your hardware doesn't have to imply that it's a hassle to use such hardware. In other words: does "bullshit-free computing experience" (or let's just say usability) have to exclude freedom (i.e. your options to freely modify hardware/software you own/use)? I'm thinking about that for some time and I think that (as most of the things) it's not a objective thing but dependend on the philosophy of the producer/maker. And I'm sure that there are people who want to produce well designed things (be that a phone or an app) that can be modified by users/owners (here comes the topic of ownership in the light of digital world, but that's another thing).
- mswift42 12y agoI've got a Kobo Aura HD, and notice no difference in sleep quality compared to reading a normal book with a light on. YMMV, of course.
- richardwigley 12y agoFrom Doc linked from the page: "Dr. Czeisler received royalties from McGraw Hill, Penguin Press/Houghton" [1] It's shaming of the BBC not to have dealt with the findings more critically, rather than regurgitation of the press release. The characterization of iPads as e-readers in the context of the royalties looks suspicious. [1] http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/12/18/1418490112 http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/12/18/1418490112
- loco5niner 12y agoDing! Ding! Ding! We have a winner.
- nyc640 12y agoHe's the fourth author and receiving royalties from publishers for use of his intellectual property (at some unspecified point in the past) probably isn't uncommon for a leading researcher in a field, particularly one that is employed by Harvard Medical School. I'm not saying the paper is necessarily without its faults because of who he is (again, noting that he is only the fourth author of the paper), but implying that the paper was somehow funded by the publishing industry seems misleading at best.
- ranci 12y agoCan people at least stop saying that f.lux does nothing? I have used it for like a year now and it has profoundly improved the length of time I can look at my computer screen. Also once I started using it I didnt have the slight double vision you get from staring at bright blue light for long periods. The study may be shit, but f.lux is effective.
- leephillips 12y agoDozens of comments here assume that there is an important difference between reflected light that enters the eye and light shining "directly" into the eye. It's obvious that spectrum, intensity, flicker, and other properties of the light can have an effect on us, but what difference could it possibly make, aside from these factors, whether the light is reflected or "direct"? Why is there an essential difference, everything else being equal, between backlit and frontlit readers?
- dragonwriter 12y agoReflection off anything but a perfect mirror has a significant effect on spectrum, intensity, flicker, and other properties of light. So, given the limited set of available artificial light sources suitable for inclusion in an e-reader (which limit the starting set of options for those properties before considering reflection), even if there is no essential difference in the abstract between reflected and directly-emitted light in terms of the human effect, the effect of those properties likely creates an important difference between practical reflected and direct lighting in e-book reader devices. The comments that assert (not "assume") that there is an important difference between reflected and direct light in portable e-book readers largely expressly note that the difference they are discussing is in that context, and neither assert nor assume a fundamental difference in reflected or emitted light in general. If you could make a back-lit reader that simulated a front-lit reader in all relevant features of the light reaching the eyes, it is obvious (tautological, even) that there would be no difference in the effect that light had -- but in real-world devices, "everything else" isn't equal between front-lit and back-lit devices, and the issue here is the effects of real-world devices, not hypothetical devices that exist only in thought experiments.
- loco5niner 12y agoMisleading. Reading from an iPad is not the same as reading from an e-ink device.
- dang 12y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8787218 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8787218