3 ms·
If the data can stay on the GPU, then it is likely a win. GPU have 8GB or more now. Thus it depends on how much polygon data one has.
by bhouston 12y ago
If the data can stay on the GPU, then it is likely a win. GPU have 8GB or more now. Thus it depends on how much polygon data one has.
- berkut 12y agoNot necessarily: even if the data's on the GPU so doesn't have to pay the PCI-E transfer penalty, GPUs still have cache hierarchies and these have latencies as well, and they can be worse than for CPUs as the branch-predictors and pre-fetchers of GPUs are still fairly primitive in comparison to what CPUs are capable of, meaning access patterns on a GPU can actually matter quite a bit - you end up having to change block-size per GPU type and code which works on one very well doesn't work as well on another GPU. However, point-in-polygon is a fairly simple algorithm, and if each polygon was mostly < 40 vertices, I suspect a GPU might be faster. However, for more complex algorithms, GPUs don't do as well and with many more vertices I suspect GPUs won't do as well for point-in-polygon tests. In terms of raw theoretical FP processing power, GPUs look good - but when you start to do more complex things with them - i.e. when branching happens a lot, say with path tracing, they don't look as good. E.g. a dual Xeon 3.5 Ghz quad i7 (costing ~£950 each) is as fast at path tracing as a single NVidia K6000 costing ~£4100.
- bhouston 12y agoHere is a production quality path tracer that for most users runs noticeably faster than competing CPU-based renderer: https://www.redshift3d.com/ https://www.redshift3d.com/ Pragmatically, it produces results of similar quality quicker than CPU-based competitors. It is really taking the high end rendering world by storm this year.
- berkut 12y agoErm??... That's a biased renderer that uses all sorts of caching and approximations that there's no CPU-based renderer that supports (VRay's closest with it's ability to configure primary and secondary rays using different irradiance cache methods), and as Redshift doesn't support CPU rendering, it's hardly a comparison worth talking about as you'd be comparing different algorithms. The pure brute-force without any caching numbers I've seen for it don't look any better than the other top CPU renderers doing brute-force MC integration. Also, a quibble, but I guess by "high-end rendering world" you mean archviz (where VRay and 3DSMax are dominant) and a few small VFX studios who happen to be running Windows?
- Varcht 12y agoYour selling it a little short, pretty much everyone not doing feature films like game cinematics, commercials and product viz.
- berkut 12y ago"Pretty much everyone" Really? I know companies like Blur are trialling it, but they're still using VRay. I know The Mill have done stuff with it, but they're still using Arnold too.
- Varcht 12y agoI mis-read, thought you were saying not many studios using windows and VRay, agree on Red Shift.