4 ms·
I made my first money online in the SEO/IM scene at Wickedfire/Digitalpoint/Sitepoint/etc. Those guys are really good at what they do. It's funny to hear you c
by chatmasta 12y ago
I made my first money online in the SEO/IM scene at Wickedfire/Digitalpoint/Sitepoint/etc. Those guys are really good at what they do.
It's funny to hear you call the WaFo products "guru" here on HN (I would agree they are), because HN itself is subject to the same kind of guru-bullshit. There are multiple people on HN who make money selling info products purely to the HN crowd. I would classify them as "guru" as well. I enjoy watching it play out, because as HN builds as a community, it seems a lot of trends are evolving in the same way the IM community did. Someone makes money, makes a blogpost, gains a following, writes an ebook, makes more money. I would call that "guru", but people on HN pay for it. I will say, however, that the content the "gurus" on HN produce is far better than 99% of the shit coming out of WaFo.
Relatedly, it's amazing how quickly people on HN will dismiss the SEO and affiliate marketing industry. It's a massive market. The "marketplace" forums on WF, WaFo, and BHW process five figures of transactions per day. That's mostly SEO services, some spammy, some not. Outside of that, there are multiple affiliates on those forums doing six figure daily revenues. The AM industry as a whole is ~6billion annually.
Despite all the money in SEO/AM, commenters on HN are quick to degrade the industry as spammy/blackhat/assholes/whatever, and yet most of those people are making more on their own than anyone here. It's quite funny, honestly.
- blumkvist 12y ago>, that the content the "gurus" on HN produce is far better than 99% of the shit coming out of WaFo. That makes quite the difference though. It's like comparing Jon's consulting thread to McKinsey or Boston Consulting. >Relatedly, it's amazing how quickly people on HN will dismiss the SEO and affiliate marketing industry. The opposite is also quite amazing too. WF is full of people who think they are running "real business", while making the most childish (and arrogant) statements and opinions. Also, out of those $6bn, majority is incremental sales for legit operations (mostly ecommerce, some financial services) through CJ, SaS, Zanox. Pills and bizops through Maxbounty/Neverblue are quite small in total numbers, not to mention pretty dissatisfying to run. My point is, it's not that much money. The holy grail "10k/day CEO" is just 3.6M/year. I'm sorry but this looks more like event budget than total revenue. What makes it particularly unappealing is the complete lack of predictability. I recognize your username from WF, so I'm sure you know what I'm talking about.
- shostack 12y agoI agree with many of your points, and have recognized the same pattern here before in terms of info products like you mentioned. Can spot those a mile away now. The distinguishing factor is that a large % of the businesses here attempt to really add tangible value, vs. just selling a dream that they hope some newbie suckers buy into. Again, quality over quantity. For example, Mike Hartl sells an info product. It also happens to be the definitive bible on Ruby on Rails and has helped numerous people start learning the language, including getting jobs as developers. Contrast that with some random person's "WaFo Special" and I think the difference is pretty stark. I'd further add that I'm not dismissing SEO at all. I think it is quite important under the "Content" umbrella, but trying to game it is not sustainable and a waste of resources in the big picture. These days it is about creating linkable, high-density/value content, and then getting relevant backlinks for it. That has never really changed in the SEO space. A lot of the random attempts at gaming the signals you send search engines has.
- chatmasta 12y agoGood points. The distinguishing difference between the crowds seems to stem from the differing skillsets. WaFo has more non-programmers than HN, and consequently differs in market dynamics from HN. "Gurus" on HN, considered in a context parallel to that of WaFo, enjoy the privilege of writing actionable content because most readers can program, and therefore can take a different route to profit from non-programmers. Thus books from HN authors can simultaneously promote profit and add value, unlike those from WaFo authors, which create a bullshit-cycle by selling things to each other. Then again, maybe that's just good business...