4 ms·
You are both stretching the definition of "good scientific evidence" as well as completely misunderstanding the very nature of the science producing those studi
by pron 12y ago
You are both stretching the definition of "good scientific evidence" as well as completely misunderstanding the very nature of the science producing those studies.
First, are you saying that whatever "differences in risk preference" found (for some definition of "good level evidence": I haven't seen the studies, but I'm sure they weren't done on, say, a sample of a ten-thousand people) account for the huge difference seen in SV startups? I mean, I don't know what the effect size was in the studies you were referring to, but I'm sure it was nowhere near that we see in SV.
I call such an attitude "sciency" -- ascribing small-n studies with low effect size the scientific rigor of proof or strong evidence to reinforce existing biases. You will never seriously consider this level of evidence "good" if something important to you depended on it.
Second, and much more importantly: even pretending those studies were conducted on a billion people and showed a 5x difference (or whatever it is among SV entrepreneurs), all it means is that this is how people behave now.
Sociology doesn't purport to be physics, and those aren't laws of nature. I mean, you could have done literacy studies in the 1800s and shown that blacks are illiterate (with much more statistical rigor, BTW); what does that mean? You must remember that sociology (and often psychology) studies snapshots of society that are a result of forces that we have the power to change (and probably the moral obligation to). Sociology studies things so that we could change them. It doesn't claim (in fact, it claims the opposite) to uncover fixed laws of nature.
- minthd 12y agoRead the link. It has GOOD scientific evidence, including talking about "a large meta-analysis involving 150 studies and 100,000 participants, in 14 out of 16 categories of risk-taking, men were over-represented. " And secondly i'm not saying they account for all the differences in SV, just that there are large biologically based differences.
- v13inc 12y agoI think the truly important question is: Are those differences caused biology or society?
- belorn 12y agoIf it is society, how should it be handled? Should schools educate girls to take more risk while boys are instructed on the negative aspect of risk taking? Or to phrase the question in a different way. If risk behavior is a socially learned behavior, and risk behavior is the cause of gender imbalance in SV entrepreneurs, what would the ethical action be to create equal opportunity for people of both genders?
- mc32 12y agoInculcating risk could be risky... I'd rather sensitize boys/men to risk than make girls/women risk tolerant. Risk tolerance leads boys and some girls to take stupid risks from adolescence to? Well, for boys, over-representation in correctional institutions. If one could just get all to avoid stupid risks but take other more acceptable risks, I suppose but can they be decoupled? This is not to say that oppotunities should not be there for all to consider and take, if they so desire... just making risk in general more acceptable can have unintended consequences --unless there is a way to direct the risk energy into productive avenues (i.e more job risk tolerance but less risk of engaging in dangerous activities..
- pron 12y ago> Should schools educate girls to take more risk while boys are instructed on the negative aspect of risk taking? Let's ask the question another way: if schools (and parents) are currently educating boys to take more risk (or educating girls to take less risk), should they start treating both sexes the same way?
- belorn 12y agoI have heard of no school that has a program to increase risk taking in boys, nor do I know of any teacher education that instruct teachers to teach boys in taking more risk. Could you explain why you are suggesting that some do? What schools could do is educate about actually risks, so that any personal or cultural level of risk aversion is confronted with reality. That would be treating children of both genders equally and could mitigate differences between genders.
- pron 12y agoI have. The figures aren't included, but by what statistical reasoning do you interpret "men were over-represented" and "highly significant sex differences" as "large biologically based differences"? I mean, even supposing those studies proved biological difference, where do you learn about the large effect size? It's not mentioned in the article at all (except in those studies showing biases). It is also true that studies showing cultural biases find significant ones, usually with far, far higher effect sizes. What I find most disturbing is the "sciency" reliance of people on studies showing small effect size as an excuse to not even try to change an unfair power structure, and ignore the findings showing cultural impact. I mean, even if it's not possible to erase any-and-all difference, shouldn't we at least try to eliminate some? If anything, you're showing a clear cultural bias by treating this situation differently from other scientific findings. Also, how do you explain the constant decline, since at least the 1980s, of women participation in CS?