5 ms·
> Many differences have been proven to be biological. Absolutely none that are pertinent to the matter at hand. > What if the problem of parity is that there
by pron 12y ago
> Many differences have been proven to be biological.
Absolutely none that are pertinent to the matter at hand.
> What if the problem of parity is that there is something intrinsic in women that they're just not stupid enough to work 80 hours a week for 3-5 years to have a chance at a few million dollar exit?
Sure. And what if it's impossible to find intelligence in the universe, create true AI and extend life? There are good signs that that's indeed the case. I guess you would argue we should stop pursuing those goals.
> I do believe that half(ish) of the women on any sort of government body should be women.
And don't you think Silicon Valley is a center of concentrated power?
- debacle 12y ago> And what if it's impossible to find intelligence in the universe, create true AI and extend life? These are scientific endeavors. If you want to try and get to the heart of why men are so much more prevalent than women in successful SV exits, be my guest, but that would be a scientific goal. Trying to force the model of what you think the world should be is not scientific, it's ideological - even if that ideology were to be backed up by science. In your case, it isn't.
- pron 12y ago> These are scientific endeavors. They are absolutely not (well, except for ETI)! They are technological goals, some funded by private businesses with monetary interests (i.e., they are driven by values). And besides, what is it that you're saying? That in order to increase our knowledge of the universe we must stop at nothing, but when it comes to sharing power and improving the lives of disenfranchised groups we must stop... well, right here would be good?
- spacehome 12y ago>> Many differences have been proven to be biological. > Absolutely none that are pertinent to the matter at hand. Are you saying that a propensity for risk-taking is unrelated to gender or that it's not pertinent to entrepreneurship?
- pron 12y agoI am saying that whatever biological differenced "proven" re propensity for risk taking have an effect size several orders of magnitude smaller than that among SV entrepreneurs, while cultural biases are shown to be of similar effect size (and greater). So no, the effect sizes found can have no more than negligible bearings on reality.
- minthd 12y agoThere's good level of scientific evidence on differences in risk preference, the importance of status, thinking styles(abstract vs concrete), levels of attachment and child care abilities - at least between average males and females. Sorry for not linking papers,but a good start would be this debate[1] between pinker and spelke. And it's clear those things impact participation in startups. [1]http://edge.org/event/the-science-of-gender-and-science-pinker-vs-spelke-a-debate http://edge.org/event/the-science-of-gender-and-science-pink...
- pron 12y agoYou are both stretching the definition of "good scientific evidence" as well as completely misunderstanding the very nature of the science producing those studies. First, are you saying that whatever "differences in risk preference" found (for some definition of "good level evidence": I haven't seen the studies, but I'm sure they weren't done on, say, a sample of a ten-thousand people) account for the huge difference seen in SV startups? I mean, I don't know what the effect size was in the studies you were referring to, but I'm sure it was nowhere near that we see in SV. I call such an attitude "sciency" -- ascribing small-n studies with low effect size the scientific rigor of proof or strong evidence to reinforce existing biases. You will never seriously consider this level of evidence "good" if something important to you depended on it. Second, and much more importantly: even pretending those studies were conducted on a billion people and showed a 5x difference (or whatever it is among SV entrepreneurs), all it means is that this is how people behave now. Sociology doesn't purport to be physics, and those aren't laws of nature. I mean, you could have done literacy studies in the 1800s and shown that blacks are illiterate (with much more statistical rigor, BTW); what does that mean? You must remember that sociology (and often psychology) studies snapshots of society that are a result of forces that we have the power to change (and probably the moral obligation to). Sociology studies things so that we could change them. It doesn't claim (in fact, it claims the opposite) to uncover fixed laws of nature.
- minthd 12y agoRead the link. It has GOOD scientific evidence, including talking about "a large meta-analysis involving 150 studies and 100,000 participants, in 14 out of 16 categories of risk-taking, men were over-represented. " And secondly i'm not saying they account for all the differences in SV, just that there are large biologically based differences.