5 ms·
How much of a given total cost of a launch to Mars is the fuel? According to the article, it shaves 25% off the fuel costs - but what percentage of the total is
by pavel_lishin 12y ago
How much of a given total cost of a launch to Mars is the fuel? According to the article, it shaves 25% off the fuel costs - but what percentage of the total is that, let's say, for the past few missions?
It seems that the bigger advantage of this is adding a few months but doing away with waiting for a launch window. Definitely great for equipment, though it would put two months' worth of extra stress on actual human travelers.
- steanne 12y agoIt might not be great for humans, but it's good for cargo mass. Send the big stuff the slow way earlier and the people the fast way with a later departure.
- tokenadult 12y agoAccording to the article, it shaves 25% off the fuel costs Yes, by the facts and speculation reported in the article kindly submitted here, the headline phrase "on the cheap" is plainly wrong, and "anytime" is an exaggeration, as the overall trip time will tend to be longer for most such missions. The article also notes, "The burn-free, capture altitude is also quite high—some 20,000 kilometers above Mars, far beyond where science satellites set up shop to scrutinize the planet up close. But taking along just a little extra fuel can then gently lower a ballistically captured spacecraft into scientifically valuable, standard orbits of around 100 to 200 kilometers like those achieved with Hohmann transfers—or even onward to the Martian surface for a landing." So one part of the article says that the mission will take less fuel (to leave the vicinity of earth), while another part of the article says that the mission will have to carry along extra fuel (in the Mars exploration modules) to arrive at a location where useful science can be done. The bottom line here is that these missions will still be about as expensive as current missions, and manned flight to Mars and back will be staggeringly expensive.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoBut the trip time is only 2 additional months - which sure beats waiting over two years for the next launch window!
- jccooper 12y agoLaunch costs for small Mars missions are on the order of a third of the project budget. Fuel is cheap... on the ground. But paying to send it to Mars is not. Less fuel means more payload, which means more science or less cost (because you don't have to build so exotically to save weight.) Either way is good. Only in a radically different launch cost regime will we cease to care about efficiency of transfer.