3 ms·
Regarding downvoting when disagreeing here's what pg said a few years ago: "I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the u
by Kiro 12y ago
Regarding downvoting when disagreeing here's what pg said a few years ago:
"I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness."
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
- organsnyder 12y agoI think that's a terrible approach. There are plenty of times when the most popular opinion isn't necessarily correct. Downvotes are a way to suppress discussion—they should only be used in obvious cases of factual errors, logic fallacies, mean spirit, etc. The proper response to disagreement is a follow-up comment. The problem is that up/downvoting is used by the software to determine how prominently the comment should be shown—even, in extreme cases, hiding it completely. If the metric was simply displayed, with no further action taken, then I might agree with pg's statement. Funnily enough, I found myself instinctively hunting for a downvote button (even though I don't have downvote powers yet) to mark my disagreement with pg's assertion. That behavior seems to be deeply embedded in many of us, even if we intellectually hold to the opposing view.
- Gracana 12y agoIt's not a great approach but it's probably better to acknowledge that people will use it that way than to make a unenforceable policy against it and have people whine about HN-iquette when they get downvoted.
- geebee 12y agoI'm not sure I agree here, because I think down voting is more serious than up voting. The threshold for an up vote could (and probably should) be lower than for a down vote. Think of it this way - if some of your compliments may be a bit more than what was truly deserved, does it follow that the same should be true for your castigations? I think it's probably wise to be liberal with the former and conservative with the latter. I'm sure I don't live up to my standards completely. But my aspiration for myself would be that I would only down vote when someone is clearly harming the quality of discussion on HN, not when I just happen to disagree with the point of view.
- classicsnoot 12y agoi feel this way too, but i wonder why. i do not why i feel the downvote has more weight... i wonder if it is because it is grayed out? What if enough upvotes == emboldened text?
- logn 12y agoThis discourages people from dissenting, moves their opinions to the end of the thread (or deletes them), and suggests to commentators they're not welcome in the discussion. PG is not the pope; I don't think we're bound by his stance.