8 ms·
Some experts don't buy the FBI claim that North Korea hacked Sony
- websitescenes 12y agoThere is something interesting happening in the media in relation to hackers and I think that is evident by the fact that this article refers to white hats as "anti hackers". To me, that is a deliberate separation that is intended to hide the good that hackers do.
- egwor 12y agoI'd read 'anti-hackers' just like someone who was described as 'anti-war'. On the plus side at least they're starting to understand that not all hackers are bad?
- valarauca1 12y agoNever attribute to malice what can be just as easily attributed to stupidity. Largely outside of the hacker community, the true definition of hacker is lost. If you only look at popular culture there aren't a lot of in-roads to the correct definition of hacking. Therefore how would the average person know?
- websitescenes 12y agoInteresting take here: "Never attribute to malice what can be just as easily attributed to stupidity." I think there is much truth to your sentiment. My only qualm would be applying it universally. I am sure there is malice in the world that is masked as stupidity.
- valarauca1 12y agoTo apply something universally is idiotic and short sighed at best. No philosophy applies everywhere, and in every case. Only though understanding the events around you can you formulate a correct assessment. This grew out of Enlightenment thinking in the 18th century. And its why our modern courts have such foundation on understanding the circumstances, evidence, etc. Also why we have "degrees" of murder.
- websitescenes 12y agoI agree that acts attributed to malice, often, are merely manifestations of ignorance. The use of "anti hackers" in this article may in fact be one of these manifestations but I am hesitant to say "Never attribute to malice what can be just as easily attributed to stupidity." as you had initially suggested. It's just the word "never" that does not sit well with me. Your most recent comment seems to share this position, so it appears we agree.
- valarauca1 12y agoWe do. I was just using a quote to express my opinion on the matter.
- jakobegger 12y agoI actually think the term anti-hacker is great! For years hackers complained about their negative image, and failed to explain the "real" meaning of the word. Now there's a pragmatic solution: just call yourself an anti-hacker! Instant credibility!
- websitescenes 12y agoSo what about dark skinned Americans calling themselves anti-blacks? Or perhaps feminists calling themselves anti-women? It promotes a point of view that is incorrect. Just because someone uses a lock pick to break into a home does not make all locksmiths criminals. I think using the term "anti hacker" in place of "white hat hacker" is indicative that a "hacker" is bad when in fact the "anti-hacker" is a "hacker".
- dragonwriter 12y ago> So what about dark skinned Americans calling themselves anti-blacks? That would often be true, though not in a way analogous to the topic under discussion. Blacks aren't the only darker-skinned people in America, and Black vs. White isn't the only divide along which racism occurs in America.
- jakobegger 12y agoYou are missing my point. The issue is that there are two different meanings of the word hacker. Nobody disputes the meaning of "woman" or "black". To the general public, a hacker is someone who breaks into a computer system with bad intentions. We are offended because the general public doesn't understand that we mean something different with the term "hacker". I'm suggesting to just adopt the meaning of the word that the general public uses, especially when talking to the general public. This way we can avoid misunderstandings. However, it would be even better to just use more specific terms. "Hacker" is such a catch-all term with different meanings for everyone. For example: If someone performs an elaborate practical joke, call them a "prankster" instead of "hacker". When you talk about a lab with a bunch of 3D printers, call it a "makerspace" instead of "hackerspace". And when you quote someone about the latest vulnerabilities in OpenSSL, just call them a "security expert". No one will be offended, everyone will understand what you are trying to say, problem solved. But I understand that many hackers like to call themselves hackers, and they like the secretive-undergroundish tone that comes with it, and they will continue to use it and they'll continue to be offended when mainstream media use the term in a different way.
- hobs 12y agoI love comments about the "anti-hacker community" though the underlying link to marco's blog (as this entire article is just commentary on original source material) http://marcrogers.org/2014/12/21/why-i-still-dont-think-its-likely-that-north-korea-hacked-sony/ http://marcrogers.org/2014/12/21/why-i-still-dont-think-its-... gives his entire opinion. I dont think its news to most of us here that the NK connection to the hack is circumstantial; Sony's security has been penetrated by non-state actors before, and without a lot of effort from what I can tell.
- mathieuh 12y agoNorth Korea could produce evidence definitely proving they had nothing to with it and it would still be dismissed as propaganda. The number of people who believe that north Koreans are all brainwashed, and yet will accept unquestioningly all of this crap made up about NK is astounding. Do people /honestly/ think that they have to have haircuts "in line with a socialist lifestyle"? Even after their national TV network reported that it was slander? Regardless of what you think about NK, it's a product of the circumstances that led to its creation, and it's a bit rich for the American government in particular to say these kinds of things about NK.
- xnull2guest 12y agoWhat sort of evidence, in this case and in general, proves a negative?
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoExactly the point I was going to make. Why is the burden of proof on the accused to prove they are innocent?
- turk- 12y ago"Do people /honestly/ think that they have to have haircuts "in line with a socialist lifestyle"? " My father grew up in communist Bulgaria and long hair was prohibited. I don't doubt that long hair and extreme hairstyles are also prohibited in North Korea.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rl3 12y ago>Do people /honestly/ think that they have to have haircuts "in line with a socialist lifestyle"? Yes. [0],[1] >Even after their national TV network reported that it was slander? Setting aside the implicit credibility you're ascribing to North Korea, I think you may have been confused with another story. [2] >Regardless of what you think about NK, it's a product of the circumstances that led to its creation, and it's a bit rich for the American government in particular to say these kinds of things about NK. I agree, the US clearly does not have the moral standing to sully North Korea's good name with accusations so serious as computer hacking. [3] --- [0] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4157121.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4157121.stm [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Let%27s_trim_our_hair_in_accordance_with_the_socialist_lifestyle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Let%27s_trim_our_hair_in_accord... [2] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2014/03/26/are-the-men-of-north-korea-really-being-forced-to-get-kim-jong-un-haircuts/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2014/03/26... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yodok_concentration_camp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yodok_concentration_camp
- k-mcgrady 12y agoAlthough I don't like to believe everything the government says (and I have no idea whether they are correct or not in this situation) please stop turning HN into conspiracy theory central. The last week has seen a few of these 'experts debunk North Korea theory' on the front page every day. Due to the fact the FBI has withheld some of their evidence from the public we won't know. Unless we can see all of the evidence we won't know their reasoning. If the US was threatening war with NK over this I would be much more worried and glad to see these posts but considering the only action they are even considering is putting NK on a 'terrorism list' they probably aren't all that confident in their own evidence never mind the stuff they've made public. I guess my point is please stop posting this stuff. Whenever anything newsworthy happens the 'experts' (in any field) come out in force debunking stuff when they don't have all the evidence. It drives me nuts. I know this is a community and if people find it interesting it'll end up on the front page - that's fine, it's just getting a little annoying.
- joelrunyon 12y agoI don't think they're "debunking" anything as much as asking certain questions that lots of people have. I think it's worth having that discussion. Nobody is proposing any conspiracies - just due diligence.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoOf course, but the discussion has taken places several posts per day for the last week. Unless the FBI releases more information or Sony releases more information there's likely nothing new to discover.
- xnull2guest 12y agoHaven't those discussions been largely mixes of new people? I think it's fair for the people who didn't get a chance to weigh in the first time to have their own deliberation about it.
- 12y ago
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoI think denials of state actor hacking is bewildering. Its seem more credulous that a previously unknown hacker group (the GOP? Really?) suddenly take down Sony in such an elaborate fashion, especially when a movie literally protraying the murder of NKorea's leader is about to be released (In June N Korea vowed to "mercilessly destroy" anyone involved with The Interview.) Groups like the Lizard Squad who perform Sony attacks tend to have a history and reputation. This group has no history. That itself should be a huge mark against those who go against the FBI's claim. Not to mention we have a massive history of NK and Chinese cyberwars against the west. Often both countries working hand in hand, with the NK hacker team reported to be headquartered in a hotel in a Chinese city under the auspices of the Chinese government. Shenzhen I believe. I think a lot of this "debate" is centered on how people feel about the USG and specifically its foreign policy. I think a lot of black-hat and grey-hats tend to idealize autocratic regimes like Russia, China, N Korea, Syria, Iran, etc because they are "counters" to US foreign policy, so they often will take an anti-US spin on things. This isn't technology or informed commentary. Its just the same lazy outrage politics that has taken over any other type of discourse on the internet. From a rational perspective, this attack obviously points to the NK regime. Its fits their MO, their history, and, if we take the FBI's claims as true, their technology and capabilities. The same way many anti-US/anti-Western commentators were telling us that those weren't Putin's troops in Crimea or in Eastern Ukraine. They kept saying "more proof" when it was obvious no amount of proof would convince them. They just had an anti-US bone to pick and liked the attention of being contrarian. I also think its emotionally comforting to pretend there isn't a massive multi-party cyberwar going on, all the time. I think people want to believe its just some bad apples, not nation states and their leadership ordering attacks left and right, with impunity. Its a little scary to think what is possible from a determined attacker and how little of our industry and practices are focused on security.
- higherpurpose 12y agoHave you missed the Lulzsec series of hacks against Sony? Lulz It's not like they hacked Google here. Sony probably had lower security standards than your average start-up company. And their first request was a money reward, not to stop the movie from being published. Also the US gov and its intelligence agencies have earned their share of distrust here. I would be more worried if HN as a whole would automatically trust the US intelligence agencies after all of their lies from the past two years. The US agencies are like the boy that cried wolf. If they want us to trust them when something actually happened, then they should stop lying all the other times, too. All actions have consequences, but the US gov has acted way too many times as if they do not. The recent execution of the two cops is also a consequence of the US gov acting lawlessly and saving their murderous cops from prosecution. I have no doubt the person that did it had mental issues, but I don't think he would've gone and executed two cops without the murderous cops being saved from justice by the US government (two times too many).
- snarfy 12y agoThe government has no credibility anymore, conspiracy theories aside. This is the real problem. Even if they are telling the truth, nobody believes them.
- dragontamer 12y agoUS Government only had credibility in the 40s, when the office of censorship stamped out anti-war propaganda and the DoD spent millions (billions in today's money) on Pro-War propaganda. The trend continued in the 50s and 60s with McCarthyism being a "soft censor". It wasn't technically illegal to talk about Communism or other governments... but if you did, you'd probably lose your job. We've got freer speech today compared to back then. So naturally, anti-government claims are going to be louder today than ever before.
- debacle 12y agoAt least we used to just call it the Department of War. It was much more honest.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> At least we used to just call it the Department of War. > It was much more honest. The Department of War was only really analogous to the modern Department of Defense for about a decade from 1789 until 1798 when the Department of the Navy was pulled out to its own department. From 1798 to 1947, the "Department of War" was at least as misleading as the modern Department of Defense, since a whole lot of war was conducted under the auspices of another department (the Department of the Navy.)
- dragontamer 12y agoBull. The 1798 Sedition Act outlawed speech, outlawed prominent authors who were critical to the Adam's administration. Hundreds of dollars in fines and months in prison. (worth a lot in today's money) The First Amendment was passed in 1791. And only seven years later, the US Government was already censoring its citizens who were critical of the presidency. The Bill of Rights only has as much power as the people who watch over the government. It was a battle to get the government to recognize our rights in the 1700s, just as much as it is a battle to get them recognized today. Welcome to politics, this sort of thing _never_ changes. And don't just look at the past with rose-colored lenses. Look at it critically. Politics / government has always been a dirty business. "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all others" May I remind you: the Government (and Media) lied about the USS Maine so that we'd get into the Spanish-American war. "Remember the Maine, to Hell with Spain". We also lied about a number of facts in WW2, but fortunately history proved that we were in the moral right to do so in that war. The US Population is far wiser and smarter today. The difference is that we're no longer ignorant to blatant lies from our government. So I'd argue that today's government is more honest than our ancestors / forefathers even.
- techtivist 12y agoI hate to feed conspiracy theories, but with the focus on state sponsored cyber security threats, we completely forget that corporate sponsored threats are equally potent. Every time there's an attack on intellectual property of Western companies, fingers are raised straight to state sponsored groups in China and Russia. It's bewildering to me that privately sponsored attacks are hardly considered seriously. With the Sony attack we have been focusing on the movie, while the movie could've been just an excuse for an attack that was aimed to financially dismantle Sony, which it did.
- dragontamer 12y agoMany corporations in China and Russia are state-sponsored. The whole communist / socialist thing blends government and corporations in a way that is alien to the typical US Citizen. With the Sony attack we have been focusing on the movie, while the movie could've been just an excuse for an attack that was aimed to financially dismantle Sony, which it did.* But they didn't attack Sony proper. If they attacked Sony and stole the tech to PS4 something, then it'd probably be China or Russia. But these guys attacked Sony Pictures Entertainment... not just any part of Sony. The scope of the hack IIRC doesn't go any further out than Sony's Hollywood branch. Frankly, there aren't any corporations in the world who actually care about a (probably) awful movie being made at some studio. And the Chinese corporations that make movies are distinctly not competing against Sony Pictures. Sony Pictures Entertainment is the parent company of "Columbia Pictures" and "MGM". Tell me, who the hell would attack "Columbia Pictures" ??
- justcommenting 12y agoadd schneier to the list of skeptics: http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-best-thing-we-can-do-about-the-sony-hack-is-calm-down http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-best-thing-we-can-do-ab...
- rgbrenner 12y agoNorth Korea said in June that The Interview was a "wanton act of terror" and promised "merciless" retaliation if it was released. Said it was an "act of war" and "is absolutely intolerable" http://time.com/2921071/kim-jong-un-seth-rogen-the-interview-james-franco/ http://time.com/2921071/kim-jong-un-seth-rogen-the-interview... Edit: In July they made a complaint to the UN about the film, saying: "To allow the production and distribution of such a film on the assassination of an incumbent head of a sovereign state should be regarded as the most undisguised sponsoring of terrorism as well as an act of war," http://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/jul/10/north-korea-un-the-interview-seth-rogen-james-franco http://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/jul/10/north-korea-un-t... <sarcasm>I'm sure they had nothing to do with what happened to Sony</s>
- xnull2guest 12y agoHow do you square this with the fact that NK makes empty threats all of the time?
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoThey have thousands of pieces of artillery pointed at Seoul and have nuclear weapons. Every couple months they shell the S Korean side or a S Korean ship or kidnap someone. They may not have started WWIII, but they do act out violently. They are not all talk, unfortunately.
- xnull2guest 12y agoRight but they still make plenty of empty threats especially on a global scale. Nor have their threats to use many of the artillery they have pointed toward South Korea (including nuclear arms) been fulfilled. Of course North Korea and South Korea have violent exchange. They are countries founded by settling down opposing armies on a border neither thinks is fair. I do not see how this 'squares' the fact that they are known for making empty threats?
- mikeash 12y ago
- downandout 12y agoSo let me get this straight. The North Korean government publicly warns that the release of The Interview will cause dire consequences. Shortly before the release of the film, said dire consequences occur. The moment the movie is pulled, all of a sudden the consequences stop. Right, that doesn't sound like NK was involved at all. The real question is: why are these "experts" - including some here on HN - taking such extreme and unfounded positions on this? I think it's quite likely that they didn't do the hacking themslves. Perhaps they paid members of Lulzsec to do this on their behalf. But to deny that NK is behind this is absurd and makes the whole security community look crazier than Kim Jong-Un.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoThe dire consequences include the release by the hackers of the exact bit of video that NK is claiming they never want released. Now that is absurd.
- joenathan 12y ago> including some here on HN - taking such extreme and unfounded positions on this? I think it's quite likely that they didn't do the hacking themslves. Perhaps they paid members of Lulzsec to do this... I'm struggling to see how you don't see the irony or hypocrisy in what you are saying.
- downandout 12y ago? All I said was that I don't know who actually carried it out, but it's pretty obvious that it served NK's interests.
- Squarel 12y agoNo, you said "But to deny that NK is behind this is absurd and makes the whole security community look crazier than Kim Jong-Un"
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ExpiredLink 12y agoThe politico-medial complex told you that North Korea was the culprit. Believe it, immediately!
- tessierashpool 12y agoAt the moment that I'm writing, not one of the ten highest-ranked comments here addresses any of the technical detail or substance in the counterarguments which white hat experts have raised. Bruce Schneier is one of these skeptical experts. http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-best-thing-we-can-do-about-the-sony-hack-is-calm-down http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-best-thing-we-can-do-ab... The IP address blog post by Dr Krypt3ia makes the FBI look silly beyond words. http://krypt3ia.wordpress.com/2014/12/20/fauxtribution/ http://krypt3ia.wordpress.com/2014/12/20/fauxtribution/ The Marc Rogers post makes a lot of sense to me. http://marcrogers.org/2014/12/21/why-i-still-dont-think-its-likely-that-north-korea-hacked-sony/ http://marcrogers.org/2014/12/21/why-i-still-dont-think-its-... I remember a time when a discussion like this on Hacker News would have concerned itself with the technical details of the analysis, in an honest attempt to discern the truth of the matter, rather than a bunch of opinionated political rambling, and although that was a very long time ago, I still consider that type of discussion more worth our time here.
- martincmartin 12y agoOn the other hand, Hacker News commenters have been complaining about the dropping quality of Hacker News comments since soon after Hacker New started.
- ChikkaChiChi 12y ago"Remember the Maine! To hell with Spain!" The US has been seeking a tangible threat in cyberterrorism for years. Anonymous is too ethereal and China is too big of a sleeping dragon for them to poke. Enter a hack loosely tied to a movie about North Korea and BINGO; you have an enemy to fight on the cyberfront.
- debacle 12y agoIt is much, much more likely that the FBI is pointing the finger at North Korea in the interim while they actually try and figure out who did this. The reasons are many: * It might make the investigation easier if the culprits think that the FBI is looking at NK and thus are less careful than they might otherwise be. * NK is an easy scapegoat. If the reality is that the perpetrators cannot be uncovered, the FBI looks more competent by pointing the finger (unprovably) at NK than saying "We have no idea." * The FBI doesn't care if NK actually did it. If they can merely tangentially prove that NK was involved, it prevents a massive security breach from being an unsolved crime. To have a breach the size of Sony's remain unsolved would bolster every would-be hacker in the world.
- tokenadult 12y agoI take it that most of the people commenting on the issue in the submitted article, and most of the people commenting on the issue here on Hacker News, have visited the United States. All of us can read and write English. But how many of those people have ever been to north Korea, or even to south Korea? How many can read Korean and regularly follow the Korean-language press from both sides of the demilitarized zone, or regularly have conversations with Korean friends? Applying critical thinking to a complicated issue usually requires domain-specific knowledge. One part of the domain-specific knowledge here is knowledge of methods of unauthorized access to computer networks and computer security measures, which many Hacker News participants have. But another part of the domain-specific knowledge needed to size up the disputed issues in this case is knowledge of Korean internal politics, and I think that very few Hacker News participants have that knowledge or even attempt to gain it. AFTER EDIT: Someone's silent disagreement with my comment is evidence as I type in this edit. On my part, I'd be glad to hear from people who have all of the relevant forms of information about what happened recently to Sony and about how various governments have responded to that before making up my mind. So please join in the thoughtful discussion here if you have knowledge of the geopolitics involved or of other issues I didn't even bring up above. What's most persuasive in any discussion is actual evidence, and thoughtful discussion of evidence from reliable sources is what I like best about Hacker News.
- oblique0123 12y agoThat's nothing check out this. https://www.facebook.com/unknownnewWarstrategies?hc_location=timeline https://www.facebook.com/unknownnewWarstrategies?hc_location...
- oblique0123 12y agoThat's nothing check out this. https://www.facebook.com/unknownnewWarstrategies?hc_location=timeline https://www.facebook.com/unknownnewWarstrategies?hc_location...
- oblique0123 12y agoThat's nothing checkout this. https://www.facebook.com/unknownnewWarstrategies?hc_location=timeline https://www.facebook.com/unknownnewWarstrategies?hc_location... The real Iraq war strategist + known secret strategies and not done strategies.